The New York Times (New York, New York) 2 September 1909 Page 9
Obituary Notea. , CHARLES V. WING ATE. a brother 'of Git Oeorsa W... Wlnsale -d -d Brooklyn, died at lils home. TwillKht Park. Greene County. N. Y., on Tueaday night. He waa born in Manhattan In 1H47 and had been a ship broker, a newspaper newspaper writer, and a sanitary engineer. 11 waa the founder and Secretary of the Twilight Club, which tablli'hed TwlllKbt Park in the Tata. kills. Mr. Wlnaate bad written a Dumber of nooks and many articles on lantfecape gardening gardening and aanitary . work. Hla wife and a son su.vlve faim. .