Pittsburgh Post-Gazette from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania • Page 13

A-13 NEWS OBITUARIES JAMES QUILLEN JOHN HART ELY PITTSBURGH POST-GAZETTE MONDAY, NOVEMBER 3, 2003 Most influential scholar on Constitution Influential lawmaker from Tenn. for 34 years By Adam Bernstein The Washington Post James H. Quillcn, a self-made By Adam Liptak The Now Yok Times John Hart Ely, a constitutional scholar of dazzling originality and wide influence, died on Oct 25 in Miami. He was 64. The cause of death was cancer, his wife, Gisela Cardonne Ely, said.

Mr. Ely. who had taught law at Harvard' and Yale and had been dean of the Stanford Law School, was best known for "Democracy and Distrust: A Theory of Judicial Review" (Harvard, 1980). "It is the most important work of constitutional scholarship in the two generations from the time it was published to now," said Mark Tushnet. a law professor at Georgetown, echoing a widely held view.

The book proposed a distinctive middle ground between the two conventional positions on the proper role of judges in interpreting the Constitution. Mr. Ely rejected the view that the Constitution could be interpreted based solely on its text and history, saying that scholars who focused only on the original intent of its drafters were insensitive to the document's structure and the open-textured nature of some of its school, he worked as a summer clerk at Arnold. Fortas Portec a Washington law firm, assisting Abe Fortas. the future Supreme Court justice, in a landmark case.

Mr Eh wrote a first draft of a brief on behalf of Clarence Gideon, a Florida drifter who had been tried and convicted without a lawyer. The next year, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Gideon's favor, holding that poor people accused of serious crunes are entitled to legal representation paid for by the government. After graduating. Mr.

Ely served as the youngest staff member of the Warren Commission, which investigated the assassination of President John Kennedy. He went on to work as a clerk to Chief Justice Earl Warren, whom he considered a hero. Mr. Ely worked as a criminal defense lawyer in San Diego before joining the law faculty at Yale in 1968. He moved to Harvard in 1973 and then to Stanford, as the dean of its law school, in 1982.

He continued to teach at Stanford for almost a decade after he stepped down as dean in 1987. He moved to the University" of Miami School of Law in 1996 and was on its faculty when he died. language. But he was equally impatient with those who maintained that judges might infer moral rights and values Irom it. Instead, he proposed that courts should infer only one sort of value from the Constitution, a procedural one.

The Constitution. Mr. Ely wTote, requires judges to protect and enhance the democratic process itself, ensuring that it remains open and fair. Judges interpreting the Constitution should be, he wrote, in an uncharacteristically ungainly phrase, "participation-oriented, representation-reinforcing." Mr. Ely stressed the importance of giving disfavored minorities access to the political process, particularly in the face of unfair or artificial obstacles erected by the majority.

He WTote with special concern about voting rights, free speech and racial discrimination. According to a study published in The Journal of Legal Studies in 2000, "Democracy and Distrust" was, by a considerable margin, the single book on the law published since 1978 most often cited by other legal scholars in their own work. A broader companion study found Mr. Ely to be the fourth most frequently cited legal scholar of all time, as judged by references in legal scholarship since 1956. He trailed Richard A.

Posner, Itonald Dworkin and Oliver Wendell Holmes in that order. Both lists excluded textbooks and treatises. Mr. Ely's theory was both provocative and attractive because it proposed a solution to a vexing constitutional problem, that of how to reconcile an unelected judiciary with a democracy. It did so, moreover, without obviously taking sides in political and social debates.

His work nonetheless displeased partisans on each end of Uie political spectrum. Critics on the right said Mr. Ely's approach was just a fancy way for judges to impose their wishes over the objections of democratic majorities. "What is reinforced," Robert H. Bork wrote in 1990, "is not democratic representation so much as it is judicial power to redistribute the polity's goods." Critics on the left found the theory wanting because it did not protect rights they viewed as fundamental, notably the right of privacy.

Born in New York City in 1938, Mr. Ely was a graduate of Prince ton and of Yale Law School. In 1962, after his second year at the law businessman and sometime showman who represented northeastern Tennessee in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1963 to 1997. died-yesterday at a hospital in Kingsport, Tenn.

The Republican congressman had quintuple bypass surgery a decade ago and broke a hip in recent years. He was 87. Mr. buillen, who had banking and Committee. He protected Tennessee's financial interests on a range of projects.

At a public hearing, he once placed a goldfish in a water pitcher to show how a change to the Endangered Species Act would harm a potential dam project in his district. Some environmentalists thought the dam, valued at more than $100 million, would hurt the small-fish population. Quillen's pitcher strategy was meant to show how fish become acclimated to new environments and to put the fish, in Mr. Quillen's view, in perspective. Although he' could not afford higher education for himself, Mr.

Quillen helped bring millions of dollars to his district to build or add on to colleges. James Henry Quillen was the fifth of 10 children born to a poor sharecropping family near Gate City, a southwestern Virginia town near the Tennessee border. He grew up in Kingsport and held jobs as a teen-ager to support his family. He told an interviewer last year that he sold ads for the local newspaper until the publisher fired him for not being well-dressed enough to approach clients. In 1931, he began his own newspaper, the weekly Kingsport Mirror, making him one of the nation's youngest publishers.

When the weekly became a threat to his former newspaper, his old boss bought Mr. Quillen's business. Gradually, Mr. Quillen held executive positions in real estate, mortgage loans and insurance businesses in that area. He was a director of the Kingsport National Bank from 1961 to 1982.

After serving in the Navy in the Pacific during World War II, he went into politics. In the 1950s and early 1960s, he served in the Tennessee statehouse as one of its few Republicans. He was a protege of U.S. B. Carroll Re-ece (R), the former chairman of the Republican National Committee.

When Reece died in 1961, his widow served the remainder of his term. In 1962. she endorsed Mr. Quillen to succeed her. Mr.

Quillen did not seek re-election in 1996. real estate interests in his district, routinely won re-election with 90 percent 'of the vote against token opposition. As one of the longest-serving politicians in his state, "Jimmy" Quillen was a power broker in Ten nessee politics. His word could buoy or scuttle the political ambitions of others, and he was known to support contenders of all persuasions. He praised former U.S.

Sen. James Sasser in 1988 after the Democratic opponent signaled interest in Mr. Quillen's seat. In 1994, he campaigned for Republican Bill FrisL who defeated Sasser. FYist is OTHER DEATHS Senate majority leader.

Early on, Mr. Quillen became a master of constituent services and publicity. He once rode a mule up a mountaintop to tell a farmer that Ite had solved the man's trouble with the Agriculture Department. mances at the Met over the next two decades. Pandurang Shastri Athavale, 84, who founded an Indian religious movement based on selfless love for the poor.

Oct. 25 in Bombay, India of a heart attack. Mr. Athavale founded the Swadhyaya movement in 1954. when 19 followers visited crime-ridden Indian villages.

The movement, which sponsors housing and agricultural projects across India now reports 5 million followers. who played Detective Phil Fish's wife, Bernice, on "Barney Miller" and Judge Margaret Wilbur on "My Two Dads, Oct. 3 in Los Angeles from complications of a stroke. Ms. Stanley was a series regular on several shows, including "Nurses." Her films include "Outrageous Fortune," "Up the Down Staircase" and "Atlantis: The Lost Empire." Franco Bonisolli.

65. an Italian tenor who performed with the Vienna State Opera for decades, Takashi Sonobe, 62, chairman of Mitsubishi Motors Tuesday in Tokyo. Mr. Sonobe had been recently discharged from a hospital where he had been treated lor an undisclosed illness. He became chairman of the board of Japan's No.

4 auto maker in June 2002. In 2000, he had taken over as president after his predecessor resigned in disgrace to take responsibility for the defect cover-up scandal. Actress Florence Stanley, 79, Thursday An opera spokeswoman didn't identify the cause of death or say where he died. Mr. Bonisolli made his opera debut as Ruggero in Puccini's "La Rondine" at the renowned festival in Spoleto.

Italy, in 1962. later singing the part of the Prince in Prokoiiev's "The Love for Three Oranges." His debut with the Vienna State Opera came in 1968. and he eventually performed with top opera houses worldwide, including New York City's Metropolitan Opera, here he" first sang in 1970. He sang in 25 perfor When a political challenger "claimed Mr. Guillen was livine in op ulence and had a home with nine the incumbent responded: "It's better to have a weak blad der man a weak nuna.

In the House, Mr. Quillen was the fin I 'i IJunnhlin.m 1 i- 1 1 i'wl tr fi LATEST DEATHS To our readers: The Post-Gazette publishes two types ol obituaries. News Obituaries are prepared by our staff and published at the discretion of our editors. Classified Obituaries are paid obituaries preparea oy Tunerai-nome Directors, io piace Classified Obituary, funeral directors may call 412-263-1371. To suggest a News Obituary, call The following names are published by the rosi-iazene at no cnarge as puoiic service, we accept information for this list from funeral directors and representatives of crematoriums and memorial societies, who may call 412-263-1601 from 9 a.m.

to 8:30 p.m. daily. Listings followed bv the desianation (CO) indicate that a MARSCH, Joshua Jo." of Carnck. died Nov 1. John Slater Funeral Home.

Brentwood (CO) MAYER, Molhe. 92. of White Oak. died Nov 1 Jennifer Jordan Funeral Home. White Oak (CO) McCLELLAND, Lois V.

92. died Nov. 1. Bem-hauer Mortuary Beechview (CO) McCONNELL. Donna Jean DeJidas.

60. of North Braddock. died Oct. 31. Patnck Lanigan Funeral Home.

East Pittsburgh. (CO) McCULLOUGH, Joan M. 73. died Nov 1 Freyvoqel-Slater Funeral Home. Bethel Pa (CO) McNELIS, Kathryn Murray "Katie." 35.

of Munhall died Nov 2. Savolskis-Wasik-Glenn Funeral Home. Munhall (CO) MURTAGH, Bridget Mane. 46. of Shadyside.

died Oct 28 McCabe Brothers Funeral Home. Shadyside (CO) O'BRIEN, Richard died Oct 31 Novak Funeral Home North Side (CO) PATTERSON. Rose T. 89. of Turtle Creek died Nov 2 John L.

Qumlan Funeral Home. Turtle Creek (CO) PAWLOWSKI, Mary A 82. of West Mifflin, died Oct 31. Maloy Schleifer Funeral Home. Duquesne.

(CO) PORTA, Laura V. 94, of Robinson, died Nov 2 Joseph M. Somma Funeral Home, Robinson (CO) RIGA, Giuseppe of Highland Park, died Oct. 31. Frank R.

Perman Funeral Home. Shaler. (CO) RODGERS, Patricia Kelly. 71. died Nov 1.

Anthony Staab Funeral Home. West End. (CO) SCHMIDT, Gladys R. Hahne. 89 of Mount Oliver, died Nov 1 Boron Funeral Home.

Carnck (CO) SCULLY, Jacqueline F. 'Jackie." 73. of Cla'rton, died Oct 31. A.J. Bakavac Funeral Home.

Clairton. (CO) SHADISH, William Sr. 74. of Bndgeviile. died Nov 2 Bogan-Wolf Funeral Home.

Bndgeviile (CO) SKIBINSKI, Henry F. "Skip. 75. of Braddock. died Nov 1.

Patnck T. Lanigan Funeral Home. East Pittsburgh (CO) THOERNER, Ruth Jones Russ, 73. of Avalon, Schepner-McDermott Funeral Home. Crafton.

(CO) CALLAHAN, Nicolina Pern, of Point Breeze, died Oct. 30 McCabe Brothers Funeral Home, Shady-side (CO) CAPPY, Joseph 89. of Banksville. died Nov 2. William Slater II Funeral Service.

Scott. (CO) CHIEA, Roy 61. of Turtle Creek, died Oct. 31. Allien Funeral Home, Wilmerdmg (CO) CINORIC, David F.

Jr, 40. of Wilkins. died Oct. 31. Patrick T.

Lanigan Funeral Home, Turtle Creek. (CO) COLANTONI. Antonina, 94, died Oct. 31. Brus-co-Falvo Funeral Home.

Mount Washington. (CO) CONLEY. Gilbert T. "Gibby," 48. of Franklin Park, died Oct.

30. Walter J. Zalewski Funeral Home. Lawrenceville (CO) CRAWFORD, Linda 58. of the North Side, died Oct.

18 Robinson Funeral Home. Perry Hilltop. DELOGLOS, Gust. 71. of Moon, died Nov.

1. Huntsman Funeral Home. Moon. (CO) DILWORTH, Dorothy died Oct 28. Spriggs-Watson Funeral Home.

Homewood. (CO) DIXON, Gloria Jean, 60. of the North Side, died Oct. 30. Robinson Funeral Home, Perry Hilltop.

DREWERY, Timothy 68. of Manchester, died Oct. 30. Robinson Funeral Home, Perry Hilltop. DULAK, Mildred T.

Bunk "Millie," 87, of the North Side, died Nov. 2. Stephens Memorial Chapel, North Side. (CO) ECKMAN, Edna M. Ingold.

89, of Whitehall, died Oct. 31. John F. Slater Funeral Home, Brentwood. (CO) EVERS, Henry Martin, 93.

of Mt. Lebanon, died Oct. 31. H. Samson Funeral Home.

Oakland. (CO) FAHRNER, Stella died Nov 2. Thomas J. Gmiter Funeral Home. South Side.

(CO) FALLON, Margaret C. Magilson, 74. of Kennedy, died Nov. 2. Anthony J.

Sanvito Funeral Home, Stowe. (CO) FANTONI, Fred. 74, of Heidelberg, died Nov. 2. Bradwell Nirella Funeral Home.

Carnegie. (CO) FARRELL, Gladys died Oct. 31. McDermott Funeral Home. McKees Rocks (CO) FRANCESCHINA, Victor 83.

of Ross, died Oct. 31. Brandt Funeral Home. Ross (CO) FRANKLIN, Victor Sr. 80.

died Nov 1 Walter J. Zalewski Funeral Home. Lawrenceville. (CO) GIELAS, Elizabeth Betty." 80, of Brentwood, died Oct. 31 Thomas J.

Gmiter Funeral Home. South Side (CO) GRILTZ, Marion A died Nov. 1. Burket-Truby Funeral Home. Oakmont (CO) HARTMAN.

Sarah Taylor. 93. of Scott, died Nov. 2. Readshaw Funeral Home, Carnck.

(CO) HATCHER, Betty 78. of Mt. Lebanon, formerly of Steubenville. Ohio, died Nov. 1.

Laughlin Memorial Chapel. Mt. Lebanon. (CO) HEINTZ, Rae, died Nov. 1.

Scheilhaas Funeral Home. West View (CO) HURD, Elizabeth D. "Betty," of Robinson, died Nov. 1 Jefferson Memorial Funeral Home. Pleasant Hills.

(CO) HYNES, John 86. formerly of East Pittsburgh, died Nov. 1 Patrick T. Lanigan Funeral Home. East Pittsburgh.

(CO) JORDAN, Warren 83. of Bloomfield. died Nov. 1 Winter Funeral Home. Bloomfield.

(CO) KOLCZYNSKI. Joseph 84, of Lawrenceville, died Oct. 31. Walter J. Zalewski Funeral Home, Lawrenceville.

(CO) KRAUS, Robert C. 76. of Plum, died Nov. 1. Maurice L.

Knee Funeral Home. Plum. (CO) KRESSON, Michael. 83. of Sheraden, died Nov.

1 Hughes Funeral Home. Troy Hill. (CO) KUBALA, Theodore A. "Tubby," 85. of Dormont.

died Oct. 31. Laughlin Memorial Chapel, Mt. Lebanon. (CO) LECKENBY, Gary Kennedy, died Nov.

1. William Slater II Funeral Service. Scott. (CO) LOCANTE, Jenny 83. of Brentwood, died Nov.

1. John F. Slater Funeral Home, Brentwood (CO) MACKANYCH, Pavel. 65. of Leet, died Nov.

1. John Syka Funeral Home. Ambridge. died Nov. 2 Brandt Funeral Home.

(CO) TOXEY, John 81. of Munhall. died Nov 1 George Irvm Green Funeral Home. Munhall (CO) VAUGHAN. Thomas died Oct 31 John A Freyvogel Sons Funeral Home.

Oakland (COV WILD, Kathenne 89. of the North Side died Oct 31. Stephens Memorial Chapel, North Side. (CO) XENAKIS. Paul A 58.

of Chalfont. died Nov 1 Patrick T. Lanigan Funeral Home. East c0 WASHINGTON COUNTY LUKETICH, Mary 88. of Cokeburg diedNov 1 Leonard Paviic Funeral Homes, Bentleyviile (co MARCASE, Judy Diane 58.

of Houston, died Nov 1 Soilon Funeral Home. Canonsburg WESTMORELAND COUNTY PALAZZ1, Cory. 10 of New Kensington, died Nov. 1 Giunta Funeral Home. Arnold.

(CO) YUNGWIRTH, August. 84. of Delmont. died Nov. 2.

Bash-Nied Funeral Home. Delmont OTHER AGOSTINELLA, Olimpia 83. of Madison, formerly of Coraopolis. died Oct. 29.

Anthony J. Sanvito Funeral Home. Coraopolis (CO) BUCHANAN. Ronald 53. of Montgomery Y.

formerly of Pittsburgh, died Oct. 31 Milispaugh Funeral Home. Walden, (CO) STEINER, Sabina "Dee." 66. of Coudersport. Potter County, formerly of Pittsburgh, died Nov 1 Fickinger Funeral Home.

Coudersport. VOGEL, Julie P. 75. of Melbourne. Fla formerly ol Pittsburgh, died Oct 30.

FreyvogelSiater Funeral Home. Bethel Park (CO) YANEK. Steve. 87, of Ellicott. formerly of West Mifflin, died Oct 31 Jay A.

Hotter Funeral Home. Norveit. Westmoreland County. (CO) Classified Obituary appears elsewhere In this section. Each Classified Obituary can be found alsd atwww.post-aazette.com'classifiedoblta on our Web site.

Those wishing to express condolences or share memories can sign a guest book or post photos of the deceased at that Web address. ALLEGHENY COUNTY AMONICA, Rachel. 91, died Nov. 2. Rowland S.

Cooke Funeral Home. Park Place. (CO) ANKNEY, Claude 73. of North Braddock. died nov.

Thomas L. Niea Funeral noma, awissvaie. iO) ARRINGTON, Phillip 71. of Oakland, died Nov. 2.

Percy E. Law Jr. Funeral Home, Wilkinsburg. BECOATES-BEY, Russell, 61. of Swissvale.

died Nov. 1 Watts Memorial Chapel, braddock. (iu) BRENNAN, Harry 68, of Crafton, died Nov. 1 BRENNAN HARRY L. Age 68, of Crafton, formerly of Greenfield; on Saturday, November EPSSSXl 1- 2003; beloved hus and 12 great-grandchildren; also survived by one brother, three sisters, nieces, nephews and cousins.

Friends received Monday and Tuesday 2-4 7-9 pm at the THOMAS L. NIED FUNERAL HOME, INC. 7441 Washington Swissvale. Blessing Service at the Funeral Home Wednesday at 9:30 am. www.niedfuneralhome.com Please sign the guest book at post gazette.com band of Olive McNeill Brennan; dear father of William I ii and James Soracco, CAPPY JOSEPH R.

Age 89, on Nov. 2, 2003, of Pittsburgh (Banksville); beloved husband of the late Catherine Milius and Lois McCort; loving father of Ralph J. Cappy, Chief Justice Supreme Court of PA (Janet) and their son Erik, Patricia Cappy Smith (Jack); beloved grandfather of Barrett and Julie Smith, Catherine and Brian Shimko; greatgrandfather of Samantha and Lindsay; special father to John E. Kala-kos. Friends received at WILLIAM SLATER II FUNERAL SVC, 1650 Greentree Scott Twp.

Tues. and Wed. 2-4 7-9 pm. Mass of Christian Burial in St. Pamphilus Church, on Thurs.

Notice of Time Later. In lieu of flowers donations may be sent to Forbes Hospice, 6655 Frankstown PA 15206 or Childrens Hospital Free Care Fund, 3705 Fifth PA 15213. Please sign the guest book ot Friends received at ALFIERf FUNERAL HOME, 201 Marguerite Wilmerding, Sun. Mon. 2-4 7-9 p.m.

Service in the Funeral Home on Tues. at 10 a.m. Please sign the guest book at post-gazette, com CINDRIC DAVID JR. Of Wilkins formerly of Versailles Boro, age 40, on October 31, 2003. Dave was a carpenter with K.S.

Manufacturing, Ross Twp. and was a member of Millmens Union Local 1160. Dave also was a member of St. John Fisher ChurchLoving husband of Gayle A. (Getz) Cin-dric; proud father of Gabrielle Taylor "Gabi" Cindric; son of the late David F.

Cindric, Sr. and the late Agnes Mary (Lukas) Cindric; brother of Ruth Booner, Christine Gross, and Paul Cindric, all of Versailles; loving son-in-law of Howie and Dolly (Franceschini) Getz; also nieces and a nephew. Friends may call Monday 2-4 6-9 pm at' the PATRICKT. LANIGAN FUNERAL HOME, (TURTLE CREEKMON-ROEVILLE CHAPEL), 1111 Monro-eville Turtle Creek (412-823-9350). Mass of Christian Burial In St.

John Fisher Church Tues. at ldam. Family suggests memorial donations be made to the Gabrielle Taylor Cindric Trust, National- City Bank, 3474 William Penn Highway, Pittsburgh, PA 15235. www.laniganfuneralhome.com, Please sign the guest book at band Bill, of uncle of Jason and Bryan A. Topnick and Megan Topnick, all of other nieces and nephews.

Visitation will be Nov. 3, 2003, 6-9pm at the MILLSPAUGH FUNERAL HOME, 22 Bank Walden, NY. Service will be Nov. 4, 2003, 11am at the Brick Reformed Church, Rt. 17k, Montgomery, NY.

Reverend Brian Randazzo will officiate. Burial will be in Brick Church Cemetery, in Montgomery, NY. In lieu of flowers memorial contributions may be made to Brick Reformed Church Steeple Fund, P.O. Box 114, Montgomery, NY 12549. Arrangements were made by Milispaugh Funeral Directors.

lease sign the guest book at CALLAHAN NICOLINA (PERRI) Of Point Breeze, on Thursday, October 30, 2003; beloved wife of the late Edward J.Callahan; mother of Edward Jr. and Robert Callahan and Anna J. Urban; grandmother of great-grandmother of 11; sister of Jenny loli and the late Nicholas Perri; also survived by nieces, nephews, cousins and friends who knew her affectionately as "Aunt Funeral from MCCABE FUNERAL HOME, 6214 Walnut Shadyside, on Tues. at 9am. Mass of Christian Burial in St.

Bede Church at 10am. Visitation with family Sun. Mon. 2-4 7-9pm. In lieu of flowers the family suggests donations to Myasthenia Gravis Assoc.

of Western PA, 1515 Locust PA 15213. Please sign the guest book at AGOSTINELLA OLIMPIA M. (MATTACHIONE) 83, of Madison WC formerly of Coraopolis, on October 29, 2003; wife of the late Michael R. Agostinella; loving mother of Rosemary (Edward) Birzer and Michael (Karen) Agostinella Jr; sister of Nancy DeSalvio, Valentino Malta-chione and Peter Mattachione; also step-sister of Amilia Moore; also survived by one grandchild and many nieces and nephews. Friends received ANTHONY J.

SANVITO, FUNERAL HOME. 1316 4th Ave Coraopolis, family owned and operated since 1936 on Monday, until 12Noon followed by Mass of Christian Burial at St. doesph Church, Coraopolis. Please sign the guest book AMONICA RACHEL Age 91, on November 2, 2003; sister of the late Antoinette, Mary and Philomona Amonica; cousin of Peter Turrill. Friends received at the ROWLAND S.

COOKE FUNERAL HOME, 210 East End Tuesday 2-4pm. Mass of Christian Burial, St. James Church, Wednesday 10am. Please sign the guest book ANKNEY CLAUDE M. Age 73, on Sunday, November 2, 2003, of North Braddock; beloved husband of Janet (Meyers) Ankney; loving father of Dennis Theodore Eileen William James Ronald Sandra L.

and Anna I. and the late Thomas loving grandfather of 21 grandchildren I and the late Patricia R. Brennan; 7 grandchildren and 11 great- grandchildren; also survived bv nieces, nephews and great-nieces and nephews. Harry was a Korean Veteran with the US Army and a member of the American Legion Frank R. Kirk Post 145, also a member of of and Steam Fitters Local 449.

Friends received Tues. 7-9 pm and Wed. 2-4 and 7-9 pm at SC PN R-MCDERMOTT FUNERAL HOME, 165 Noble Crafton. Mass of Christian Burial 10 am on Thurs. in the Church of the Ascension.

Please sign the guest book at BUCHANAN RONALD W. Age 53, of Montgomery, NY, own-erof Enterprise Tile Inc. Montgomery and a long time resident of the area died Fri Oct. 31, 2003, at home; son of Carl W. Buchanan and Dorothy Edison Buchanan.

He was born Dec. 12, 1949 in Pgh. He served in the Marines and had been an avid hunter and fisherman for many years. Ronald was a member of the Brick Reformed Church, Montgomery; survived by wife Michele De-Quittner Buchanan; father of Colleen A. Buchanan and Mackenzie M.

Buchanan, tooth at home; brother of Marsha Sunderman and hus BECOATES BEY RUSSELL On November 1, 2003, Russell age 61, of Swissvale, beloved husband of Marlene (Chambers) Becoates -Bey; dearest father of Vincent Payne -Bey, Vail Payne -Bey, Veronica Becoates Toran, Vernice Becoates-Williams, and Maria Becoates-Bey Atkinson; brother of Wilma Jean Alstach; aiso survived bv eight grandchildren, other relatives and friends. Visitation will be Tuesday 2-5 pm and 7-9 pm at the Union Baptist Church, Swissvale, where the Funeral Service will be held Wednesday 11 am. Interment Homewood Cemetery. Services of comfort entrusted to WATTS ME-MORIALCHAPEL 808 Talbot Braddock, (412-271-3880). Please sign the guest book at post-gazette, com CHIEA ROY F.

On Oct. 31, 2003, age 61 of Turtle Creek, formerly of Wilmerd-ing, a son of the late Louis and Mary Belissimo Chiea; beloved husband of Rose Mary (Sarnicola) Chiea; dear father of Julia Ann (Steven) Lova; loving grandfather of Jordan and Hunter Lova; brother of the late John Chiea; son-in-law of Elizabeth and the late Peter Sarnicola; brother-in-law of Joan Chiea, Peter J. (Kathy) and Michael Sarnicola; uncle of Amy and Carrie Chiea, Nicole and Joseph Sarnicola. Cont. on Page A-14.