New-York Tribune from New York, New York • Page 3

INTRIGUES IN EGYPT FEARED Britain Orders AH Consu? lar Officers of Her Foes Out of the Country. APPEAL ALLEGED TO ALL MAHOMETANS France Openly Charges Relig? ious Propaganda in India and Turkey Also. Washington, Sept. German and Auatiian consular officers have been by British authorities to leave at once. Rumania has announced officially tbgt if abandons her position of neutrality it will he to follow the by Italy.

oreat ha? informed the that ah? would look on the of Ameri can lo Turkish ports? to ear? Christians in case there was a Mahometan uprising against them. in the highly critical situation brought about by the (reinig of the Triple Entant? that Tur certain to join the conflict on Germany and Austria were conveyed in official dispatches to the United States government. Britain's expulsion of German urd Auatrian consular officers was taken here to mean that had de? ad to the pro-1 propaganda which she believes have been con- the outbreak of hostili-l Influente l'ndermined. of Egypt, a semi-sov the suzerainty of tVf Sultan, been practically ad- i at Britain ever since of Alexandria and of ti insurrection ears ago. The natives save never entirelj lost their aver? sion, however, for the intruders, and Britain believes Germany has for a dread? fomenting anti-Eng? lish feeling w'ord of the Sultan's of lat? to Cerniany i by British officials read to Egypt, an ap no1 only to the rift- it of the natives, hut feelings also.

Fr.v charged in her with the American propaganda up pt. but in India l'are Christians. from Great Britain would be pleased to see ips in Turkish ports France informed a weeks ago. stated that in vii i made to they feared a gen Christians. On of their posi nd warships for the move a- a generally hos toward Turkey ard Russia have re wished to do noth? ing might aggravate Turkey to rrar.de?- position of neutrality.

therefore are now nited States to pro asc the expectod ling develops. North Carolina of relief, it is she will ren Mediterranean wa? ters for effect of her presence. Then of sending the Ten? be ready for any Great somewhat apprehen about the possi against her rule in Egypt. Khedive Abbas, the native be sympathetic? with Germany and Austria, having received 1 country and ited by to the Turkey. PARIS POLICE TRAP 3 GERMAN SPIES Catch Them Exchanging Illuminated Signals from River to Heights.

The police to-day who were signals from of th? Seine to the heights ef Belleville, in the northeast of Paris. in a vacant house in Hclle who formerly an in a I'aris hotel. In his mi order for safe conduct by the German starT in other spies vho with this man escaped. A liavas Agency dispatch from at the official journal long list alleged ed Germans upoi i Germany when Following the lint "After the eommunica public opinion in all will not fail to con behavior, which re? of the Mid-He patch from Madrid to "l.e Petit ransten" -ays that the new Spanish lo Krance. Marquis hand to Preaident Poin a letter which an authorired per will make an excellent im? ,1 of the killed in i-utenant Dubief.

son of Minister of War, Fernand Ungeron, an aviator, Lieutenant Larchey, son of Gen Larehey, also were killed. "Le re Jiil? interview with (he aviator, who al service, monotonous Mowed more activity. to reconnoitring trooIls and artillery. Ilesavs: lot me go and card with Emperor Will GERMANS FENCE IN BRITISH PRISONERS Sept. Flee Hl.te that three MILITARY EXPERT REVIEWS THE WAR American Observers Expect Allies to Take Offensive This Essential to Success of German Invasion.

The folitnrina rnedgtt) of the military situation in l'nnice is the result of the observation of a man nho has made a life of modern and naifarc. The passage of the right wing of i the Germany army to east of Paris indicates that the directora of the of the invading forces have no intention of investing a city defended by the strongest fortifications and 360.000 or 100.000 men while the allied? French and i British armies remain undefeated in the field. No such defeats as were inflicted upon the French armies in at Vionville, Gravelotte and Sedan have marked the progress of the German armies from the Belgian frontier since the early part of Au? gust. And the employment of a force of more than half a million men for the investment of Paris could only be justified by such tri? umphs in the field. The capture of Paris would give Germany no dis? tinct military advantage in a war with a nation in arms battling for its territorial integritj, if not its inde? pendent political existence.

Paris is supplied to withstand a year's block? ade. It is questionable whether the German F.mpirc, shut off from all sources of outside supply, which in the course of the last ten years has been changed largely from an agri? cultural to a manufacturing state, could feed its vast armies in France and in Eastern Prussia during the length of time it would require an investing force of 500,000 or 600, Ooo men to reduce the Hncient French capital. The retention of Pari? by France is of sentimental Interest rather than militnry or even politictil impor? tance. The mchinery of government has been set up at Bordeaux. The manufacture of cannon and small ordnance and other military supplies is conducted elsewhere Lnless the Hermans evince a disposition to place in front of the fortifications of Pari? a containing force at least as great as the garrison, sound military pol? icy would dictate its abandonment nnd the throwing upon the battle line the garrison intrusted to General Gallleni for its defence.

Victory of a decisive character Is becoming increasingly essential to the success of the German invasion. if not. indeed, to the preservation of her invading army. The exigencies of the campaign in Northern France have drawn the cr.veUiping rijrht Ming of the army to a peril distance from it? buses of sup? ply at Aix-la-Chapelle and Cologne, and entailed upon it the maintenance in the face of an active and well led enemy of a long and difficult line of communication. The tac? tics of the French and English com? manders been murderously ef? fective in the infliction of punish? ment.

Apparently authentic report indicate a loss to the Germans in killed alone of 62.000. and such a loss in killed presupposes a loss in disabled and captured of 200,000 or 225,000. No army can sustain such without suffering in morale and aggressive energy. Already American military observ? ers who have followed the course of the war In Northern France keen professional interest detect a diminution of vigor in the German punch. "Ihe steady reinforcement of the armies in France cannot con? tinue indefinitely in face of the in? creasing menace of the Russian in? vasion of Fast Prussia.

The tion of the Austrian army in Galicia puts the Dual Monarchy out of con? sideration as an aggressive power. Austria must keep the Servian i armies out of Bosnia and Herze? govina, which are ripe for insurrec? tion, defend Budape-t and Vienna from the threatened Russian attiek, and maintain on her southwest, rn an army of half a million or i more to meet possible invasion from Italy, whose neutrality the govern ment at Rome is maintaining with extreme difficulty in the face of the national hatred of Austria. The defence of Fast Prussia and the i route to Lerlin must be accomplished by German troops unaided und. in the face of the surprising i 'leriry devtlopid by Russia that work alone will tax the empire's hitholo unemployed military re Eoarces to the utmost. And of grave concern to the Gei mans is the reported landing of a Russian army, brought from Arch? angel around Lapland and through Great Britain, at Antwerp.

With Rus? sia's comparatively unlimited supply f.f trained soldiers and an English transport service which the Germans cannot molest the massing of a of 300,000 or 400,000 men ready to operate with the Belgian forces, i Possibly another English army, be accomplished in a few a force menacing their communi tions and threatening their would compel a of rr from the battle front in Fran IHspatches from the Belgian war yesterday indicated that this new lied force had begun an offensi movement, but it is not believed American observers that an army sufficient strength to completely i set the German strategic campaign France has been assembled yet, a it Is probable that the effect of action reported yesterday, which have been fought two days ago, which the Germans are alleged have suffered a reverse, will be ecceleratc the efforts of the Knisei general? to bring about a dedal action east of Paris and west of Ve dan before the situation in Bclgiu becomes critical. The defensive campaign of tl French and English forces since tl Germans crossed the Belgian fronti has been conducted on the sounde military principles. The policy i the commanders of these armies i accepting battle in strong defensi? positions, inflicting heavy losses the enemy and delivering brilliai counterstrokes when occasion fered as they retired before fore? too numerous to be in a gei eral battle, has preserved trn mora of the troops and inspired them wit confidence. The soldiers of th? a lied armies to-day are alert an ragcr. full of cherful confidence i their leaders and sanguine of ult mate success.

The French and English general! holding the inside of a vast crescent shaped line, one base resting on th impregnable fortress of Belfort, nea the Swiss frontier, the other on Pari; occupy an incomparable strategic pe sition. The country back of ther has not been trod by the invadei No railroad lines have been de stroyed, no telegraph wires have beei cut by raiding cavalry. The Frencl armies have been steadily reinforce? by troops from the south and south east, no apprehension being felt eon eerning the attitude of Spam am Italy, until they are nearly, if no quite, strong numerically as th? invading Germans. That the mi takes of the war of 1S70, which marked by the shutting up of heavj forces in fortified places, will not bi repeated was evidenced by the aban donment of the strongly fortifier post of Rheims. The defence ol Rheima would have required a force of 10.000 men, which will unques? tionably be of greater service on the battle line than locked up in a for? tress, and the action of the Wai in ordering the abandonment of Rheims may presage the abanilon ment of Paris and the assembling of such of the army of General Gal lieni as may be available for active field service at the point on the long drawn out German line selected by the General Staff for the delivering of the grand counter stroke which will mark the beginning of the allied effort to drive the Germans out of France and to carry the war into the enemy's country.

Occupying interior lines and com? manding routes of communication that have not been touched, the massing by the allied commander? of a superior force at the point select? ed for the first great aggressive ef? fort of the campaign to rid France of the invading Germans should not prove a difficult military problem. Opinions differ as to the time the expected counter stroke may be ex? pected. In some quarters it be? lieved that a fortnight may elapse before the commanders of the allied armies consider themselves strong enough to risk a battle, which, if it should go against them, might imperil the allied cause in the west, and that the interval will be utilized in fur? ther weakening the invading armie? by a Continuance of the l-'abiau policy which has characterised the retreat from the Belgian frontirr. In other quarters a change from defensive to aggressive warfare by the allies is ex? pected this v. eek.

Meanwhile the world awaits with the inter? est the contest which will show whether the great German war ma? chine, which bar passed like a steam roller over forces of inferior power through Belgium and Northern France, will prove as efficient in the open field fores at equal, and possible superior, in num? BRITISH LINER SUNK BY MINE IN NORTH SEA Runo, Carrying 600 Passengers, Strikes Explosive Only 40 Miles from Shields and Aboard Saved Except 1 wenty Russian Refugees. London, Sept. Wilson with passen? gers on buaril, struck a mine in the iVortll sunk yesterday afternoon, All crew ano passengers with the exception of about twenty Russian refusers were saved. Ihr Runo sailed from Hull to Archangel yesterday, and fouled mine when aboul fort? miles it o'clock. I lie re-cues were made by lishiiig trawlers, a member "i the crew of one which said lie heard a ami then vs the Runo rise in water and settle by head until the forepart of the ship was awash, lie added that -he remained in this position long enough enable her small boats and the trawlers pick up the survivors, JUU "i were landed at Hull.

fishing trawler Prince tor picked up Iwentj two persons in the water win? were clinging a capsized boat, I'hc trawler's saw three others drowned. The mate of ill? Victoi lowered over the of the fisherman by lines, and thus helped in the work ol rescue, The i iflice issued the following statement to-dat "The following neutral merchant vessel? are known by the Admiralty to have been destroyed tier man mines, in most cases with loss of lite among the crews: Five Danish, Dut'h. one Norwegian, une The crew acted with great gallantry, The me" from the trawl also risked their lives in rescue work those picked up bj them wort the itcward and chief rugin. er of the Rut o. John Ray, Consul at who u.i- a passenger on the Runo, wounded ou the 11 a 1 in the accident.

Mr. Ray was on Ins way hi- plac? a- American onsul Many of the passengers of the Rum, wer? reservists from on th home to ihe Russian army. When the mine beneath the manj aboard gave way to panic and jumped overboard Ilir.r such a rush foi the boats that! three were overturned. sailor the Ruim that ii ihe passengci had kept would hat be? sat ed. The German mm?" which sank the whil? I hi linet was i.eed from Hull Archangel probably intended for one of the trans? ports carrying Russian troops ovei tin Hull route on their v.a> to Qstend lo reinforce French, Uritish and Belgian armies 'Tht Wit? Luxe IN YOUR PHARYNX MAKES SMOKE TASTE BETTER White Rock Mineral Springs Co 100 BROADWAY.

N. Y. RUSSIAN TROOPS BLOCK REFUGEES Kroonland Reports Use of Trains for Russians Kept Americans in England. The Red Star liner Kroonland, which over a month ago sailed from this port with Belgian and French reservists, ar rived here yesterday from Liverpool with passengers, being in the saloon and the remainder in the secoii'l cabin. Although booked to capacity she had an abu'idance of room, British railroads failing to get travellers booked to Liverpool in time for sail? ing.

Sixty aaloon and sixty see ond cabin passengers were in Eng? land. On August Jo' ail passenger trains were withdrawn from the Knglish ran roads and were Dot restored until Au? gust 80. This done to permit forty-eight troop trains from New? castle ami Aberdeen to to Dover and Southampton. The lied Star liner Lapland, it was learned yraterday, sisted in transporting the Rnmiai troops across the Channel. Un one trip the took more than ten thousand Cossacks from Dover to Calai-'.

The troopships from Southampton the Rui liana at Boulogne. Vanee Thompson, one of the Kroon land's pasaengers, said an entire arntv had been sent to the relief of Paris, and that it was the gen? eral belief England that a huge Rue? sian would be poured into the northern purl Franco. "The people of Knglatid." said Mr. I hompeon, not know where their troops are. They get postcards from their relatives at the front, but the postmarks reveal nothing concerning the location of the sender, nor is the writer allowed to say where he is.

The people did learn recently, how? ever, that the 10th Hussars, the Boyal Artillery, the Own Scottish Border? rs, the Grenadier Guards and the Connaughl Rangers were lighting hard in the battle at Mom. The ofl eeis had difficulty in restraining them, were the men to get at the Germans. Sis of these regiments came out well, but the Grenadier Guards, who fared so splendidly in the Boer War, badly cut up." Mr. Thompson said he bad talked with one of the prominent French gen? erals, and the latter told him that the French regarded 'be possible io of Paris a mere inciden! of the war. I ranee, he said, had no definite plan of attack, and was purely on the de? fensive.

Among other Kroonland passengers were B. II Griawold, a hanker ol Bal and his family of live; Rev. Krank P. Williams. laabel R.

Ay res, H. L. P. Barker. Mr.

an.I Mrs. Barr, Mi Edna M. Collier, William Kershaw. M. Duer Key, R.

Miller, Ralph Oi borne and Miss Helen II. Scott, BRITAIN GLORIES COMMAND OF Unchallenged as First Month Ends, Sa Official Review. (From Th? Tribun? Riirisu.l "Aashington, Seilt fl. The Bi Kmba.ssy made public thin after the follovv.ni* dupatch received to-day from the Foreign Office in relative to the military oi of the allies. "At the end of the first mont the war the command of the left unchallenged in the hand' C.reat Britain mid her allies, main German and Austrian main in their harbors under sh of their mines and batteries.

German cruisers, one auxiliary er, two and a subms and one Austrian cruiser have sunk. A German dreadnought ai cruiser have fled without fighting have taken refuge in the Dardant The loss to the British navy has I one light cruiser only. "As a of this naval premacy over troops have 1 able to cross the sea in difTc parts of the world without the of a man. The British expedit ury fores ha? been carried to Fra Colonial expeditions have been to attack the colonies Africa and the Pacific, and troops, under cover of the comb Anglo-French Mediterranean fl have been escorted from Algeria France. "The resources, of the empire ur the cover of the British fleet will fully developed and the armies in rope will be reinforced by those Australin, Canada, India and Af without ccaaing.

"German mercantile marine has 1 appeared from the ocean, while i passage apparently omitted 'every part of the outlying seas China, the Pacific and the Atlan the German shios have avoided tion with British cruisers, prefer? to make ineffectual attacks upon i armed merchant vessels to encount ing men-of-war. Although the Gern cruisers are still at large their reflations hare been small, anil tl unable to remain in any where serious attack could be rat upon British commerce. "Strong as the British nary is 'here will be an nccession strength within the next twel months of not less than ten first ell capital ships; fifteen cruiser- a twenty destroyers; this still furth increasing the margin of naval i nerioritv in shins of all classes German) who, during the same peric will adil not more than a third of th number to her fleet. "The prices of commodities risen cry lilile. There only imi wit of unemployment.

A fin amounting to over ha? bren voluntarily contributl the people to meet any distress thi may later arl le. The financia! tion is lal (. British and French armies i Fiance have fuught a series of hotl i contested engagements, in rhich the inflicted on the enemy losses in menvely greater than they have sul ifi-il. Theii fighting itrength is ur impaired. Meantime, in response the call of the government, fresh recruits have joined the Britil army voluntarily.

Many new division re elready in process of orgsnizatior and the number of recruits now en listing each day are equal to one di vision a half. The whole empir is absolutely united anil firmly re ni' to carry the war to a lUCCCStfu "Great Russian armies have invade? East Prussia and are on the point entering Central Germany. The Aus trian? have bien decisively beaten first bj the Servian- at ShabaU an? the River Drina, and afterward the Russians in Galicia. They hav? abandoned their campaign against Servia and have lost the fortified citj of Lemberg. "Outs" de ni" Europe the Japanese fleet and a force of troops are blockad? ing Tsing-Tau, in (luna.

The German colony of Togoland, in West Africa, In been surrendered to an Anglo French force, ar.d by the capture of the German armed vessel, the man. on Lake N'ya-sa. the control of the whole of Lake S'yassa has been sc? ene.I Great Britain. Trade and II the British colonies re? main undisturbed. The eolony of Sa? moa, in the Facile, has been taken by fore? rom tland." PARISIANS ARE EAGER TO FIGHT IN CITY'S DEFENCE Fiercely Patriotic, People of Paris, Even to Women.

Will Be Hard to Restrain from Firing on invad? ers Should Germans Pass Forts. lit le Tb? Paris, Sept. 6. All Ihc landmarks are on? where lo turn for the usual permissions or a pleasant conl ra it lo I he gi i eral fl and pal al) th nu and Consulate are looking after individual members of half the nationalities Kurope with cour? tes) and efficiency beyond all praise. Paris is almost empty, bul and i'-elf.

Th rough emnty strceti columna of ami blue -el d'ers pass with dusty boots, making bright 'troke of color. If a breach be made in the forti? fication! and the Germans succeed in rushing into the city, il is feared Pans will carry the into her slrcet-. The pepulalu.n a lieieelv patriotic a- the arm) ami they would contest the German advance foot by foot, even if ihr Porte Maillot were id. It would be almost ble to re-train the people, partiruiar I) the women, from sniping; and there DUKE OF WESTMINSTER AGAIN SHOWS PLUCK Louden, inci? dent is regarding the Duke ol Westminster, ho as reren'lv mentioned among tho-e braver? on the field of action had attracted attention. I lie Duke, it ia said, is as aide-de-camp to lield Marshal Sir John Krench.

He a pa? trol of Irtlans while he carry? ing orders automoible. Me pul on the utmost speed, hut numerous shot? from the Germans struck the machine and one mortally his companion, an officer. The half at? tempting In salute, and fell hark dead. The huke. seeing his rum.

pntiion collapse, rose in I he ear. sa? inted the man and uM: my i in lies the danger. sniping would be an iii'Hal ion for the enemy to shoot up the town. Don't let anybody persuade that the Pariaiani an? downhearted, though the Germans are within twenty min exprei train lervice, i he exo? dus of the average and bis fam ily is general, but the inhabitant who remains -till his of humor, which seem? to the Frenchman. Tin- novclt) of (lie hmjr is five o'clock raube." Between and Pans ha? the only performance which the eapital supplying in the way of amuaemi nt.

It consists of an rigine of Heath firing bomb? at a down ward range of 1.000 feet, hut more often from an altiMnle six or time cr? ater. In Montmartre the cafes have pu? the reel unce more. and. when they can do it. offer ipeeial facilities for seeing the per? formance from the roof.

Tou ran the citi em calmly taking their places about 1:45 o'clock any ing, armed with field direct th-m toward the northwest, whence the visitor usually makes his rirst appearance. l'util yesterday and to bis ar rival has alway: been signalled b) a violen! i-ri-hi tra! accompaniment, the 1 fort's machine The Kiffel Tower 'and all base a pot at "the beastly pig." a every our calls h-m. The other day two English Tommies hurried un to a housetop near l'rnlit Lyonnaise, knei' doirn and in the most deliberate fashion in the sight of hundreds ef boulevardiert i red awaj at the emissary of the Kai-er. whom Pierre Lot i ha? summe-1 up a- "an abominable being in whom ha- been all the blent i-he- of the Prussian DODGE AEROPLANES BY GREEN HORSES I rifjnii, 25 II I reported that i have painted a'l their whi'e aii'l gray green, HuiVi'ig them harmonise with the foil- that their movements cann.it be -een tcouting Thin plan ws' Ural adopted b) the British in the struggle with the Boers. ADVERTISEMENT.

ADVE-TlS-Ji-H-. SHOCKING FALSEHOODS SUPPORTING VACCINATION An Exposure and Refutation of Some Official Fallacies A crusade of compulsory vaccination is now being forced upon the children in all schools in this State, both public and private, and in answer to urgent calls that nave come to us from all over the State from parents, teachers, and school officer? for advice and assistance in this matter we now re? spond to this call by first exposing and refuting the chief and most dangerous medical falsehoods on which this crusade is based and will follow later with other articles treating other phases of the evil and showing how it may be legally defeated. In my former articles, published in the daily papers of New York City In last May and June, entitled "The Storv Of A Continental Lie," I showed that the whole cult and practice of General Public Vaccination particularly all Compulsory all great Intrenched evils, had originated in falsehood, has continued in falsehood, and now exists on both falsehood and concealment, falsehood as to Its absolute efficiency and certainty in protecting against smallpox, falsehood as to the necessity of general vac? cination to prevent smallpox epidemics and gross falsehood as to its perfect safety and freedom from dan? ser to human health and life. Now I do not think, as a student of this subject on all sides, that I have ever seen a grosser illustration the truth of this charge titan can be found in the special article on Vaccination published in the Bulletin "Health News" for February, I0t4, issued by the State Department of Health at Albany, N. which contains what I believe to be shocking falsehoods, fallacies and exaggerations which even a tyro in the investigation of this subject could easily refute, as I will now proceed to show.

All these fallacies have been issued with an air nf gospel truth, to instruct the public, and to try to justifv the extreme efforts of our department oflicers and medical doctors to force compulsory vaccination on every child and adult in this State as not only absolutely necessary for public health but as the only known means to prevent small? pox epidemics and as being an operation which is wholly beneficial and entirely sate and harmless to human health and life. I shall now give examples of the chief and worst of these medical falsehoods and follow with their full refutation, as a dutv clearlv due to public truth and right. First Fallacy: This Official Bulletin at Page 48 tells us concerning the alleged efiiciency and necessity of vaccination as follows: "Nothing I.ut vacinatton can save from smallpox. and general sanitation exert absolutely no influence upon its prevalence." This is about as shocking, absurd and false as it can be, and coming from our health officer is certainly not creditable to our public health service, but is so obviously absurd and untenable as to refute itself on its very face. This paragraph thus tells us, in effect, that dense human overcrowding, with personal and pub? lic tilth spread everywhere, no sanitation or isolation anywhere and every case of smallpox left loose and at large to spread bv direct contact to every child and adult and thus infect every one right and left, as in the old unsanitary times of big and frequent this, our Health Commissioner tells us, would not make a bit of difference In the spread of the disease! And, per contra, the prevention of all these vile un? sanitary conditions of barbarous times, with or without vaccination, would have no effect whatever to reduc? the disease: Second Fallacy: The next major fallacy in this State Department Bulletin relates to the alleged perfect safety vaccination, as follows.

"There Is not the risk In the process of vaccination when it is carried out with clean virus guaranteed by Inspection) and when the vaccination itself is kept clean. 'Sore arms' come from dirt getting into the vaccination, not from the vaccine itself." it the man who wrote this fallacy knows anything extensive on this subject he must know that what he Mates here is nut true. And he knows that no such thing as "clean" virus is now. or ever was, made or can be made, that is, no virus without some, or many, dangerous suppurative disease garnis of one kind or another, known or unknown, which will not be likely some time or other, in some persons, to bring about a dangerous infection of the system, with possible serious or fatal injury, and that, as a matter of tact, such Infections are occurring constantly In children and adults from the various existing brands of "clean" "in? spected" and certified virus now in use. furthermore, as to this evil being caused only by "dirt" getting into the wound, this audacious writer must also know that this dangerous or fatal Infection can and does come into the wound both directly as a "primary" infection from the virus itselt.

or as a "secondary" infection from "dirt" in or about the wound, and he must know very well, if at all competent to write on this subject for public instruction, that one kind of infection is about as common and as tata! as the other, and that both arc almost equally chargeable to the operation of vaccination itself, so that to contend other? wise is merely a COWirdl) evasion of the truth. illuitrate And prove this point from the latest and highest statistical authority in the world. I will now quote from the Keport of the Registrar General of bngland tor llM2, which is the very latest in print and has just come to hand. You will remember that 1 showed in previous articles that the Heport for 1911 tells the same story, that is. the shocking fact of more deaths of children from vaccination than from small? pox.

The new Report for 1912 now simply repeats this story for that year to doubly prove how false are ihe wild assertions made in the State Department Bulletin as to the perfect safety of vaccination. The English Report for 1912. just received, thus gives deaths from smallpox for that year Uhe lowest on record, in one of the poorest vaccinated countries? and 10 deaths from vaccination! Four of these smallpox deaths from vaccination! Four of these smallpox deaths were children under 0 years and nine of the vaccination death? were of children of the age, thus showing more than twice the number of deaths of children from vaccination as iron, smallpox! Four of these vaccination deaths are given as directly 'rom "Vaccinia" itself, that means a ill reel infection from the vlr is, and five cases are aa Indirect effects of wound infe. twu from "Pyaemia and threi from "Septicemia." Von will remember that the Fnglish for the previous deaUm nom Vaccination und deaths from Smallpox In children, the deaths from smallpox for all ages S3 ami from i ai ina ion for ages 11, cours? corresnondlnjr or similar mortellty occurs In our own country from this widely and inflicted dtseas. "Vaccinia." but such deaths are'denied anil concealed In our vital Statistics under the heads of order diseases, as I ha? repeatedly harged and proved, and I now again appeal to a public challenge of our department officials on the records on this important subject, which I have repeatedly demanded and will I rove the and statistical faoj that general vaccination In this State of New York is now mor? dangerous to public health and human life than smallpox, and now actually causes more deaths than particularly hildren, In fact, the fatalities from vaccination In our State of New York art relatively much more than those officially admitted In England because we have a dangerous wound infection common all this State m.d partti on Long Island which is not prevalent In I'ngland, Lockjaw or "Tetanus." to which the vaccination wound Is susceptible and which causes many deaths lu vaccinated children every year.

A reluctant proof of tins i given our State Keport for 1912, where four deaths from lockjaw In vaccination wounds ad lilltted, deaths from smallpox the same year being only four in number, so that Loth smallpox ami vaicina tion are th is clearl) shown to be equally fatal in some years in our State, by our own official reports: whereas the English Keport ror 1911! and the reports for many years previous show that, regularly, vaccination is more than twice as fatal for children smallpox: I therefore do not tint that I now need to say anything" further to prove that the statement as to the perfect safety o'' va? made in our State Department Bulletin is a dangerous medh.it falsehood and a serious decep? tion of the public mmd. which should be immediately corrected, and that I am performing a duty to the public bv lure exposing and correcting it. When such talse and untenable statements are issued hy highest health oftl? lal in the State, it is not to be wondered at that, not onlj the general public, but other important State departments will be sertouely misled. Hence u. are not to see the Pepartment of Education adopting and re-echoing these grave i oui to all our public houls.

as In the Ircular iseued Alben? March 1914, and addree officera throughout the state, in which errors an- freely quoted and Impressed on local trustees and boards us reason why the) should strictly enforce the eu! vaccination law in all school districts uf thi State I am surprised and grieved In this case to find the name of on esteemed Assistant Omm ssioner signed to this ein il.ir as It hlel author, who heartily co-operated ith us in draw ing and preaei tine tu the in 111" Tor the reform of the present evil law so as to admit unvacclnated children in the schools, according to ihr recommendutlon of former fommlssloner Andrew draper. In his Keport for I Ml. This vas defeated 1, the M.ine medical societies of this state which fastened this law originally upon US and which, of ourse, profit largel? euch law, i'ommissioner Draper pointed out In his Keport for 19u9, f'age II. This circular of March 20 go? beyond the error of the Department of Health where it stales in paragraph "The proper enforcement of this law is vital to the health of the people of the State." VA hat a dangerous fallacy and folly this is. when I have proved that even the present partial enforcement of vacination In Ftigland and this count'-? row regularly kills more children than smallpox! Purely it is a strange way to vitally improve the health of the peuple Of State bj deliberately inflicting on its healthy children an artiflcisl disease whi'h now actually kills more ot them than the natural disease against which it is directed as an alleged preventive! I know thai tin school age, to It, is naturally the most vital and Immune of all ages the population nd au degree? And do you Know that this age shows regularly every year only aboul five per cent of the total annual deaths from all causes although it forms about one-quarter of the whole population? See State Haiti? Kopirt for 1912.

And do know that, notwithstanding all the false smallpox ranles forcod on us vacclnators prortt so from them), smallpox. Including both epidemic and non-epidemic --ears, is illj on- of the moat insignificant of our causes of death" If v-K-eiiiatlon can be proved to be an effective protection for any prolonged pei from smallpov there might lie some hope of it? bens "vital to the health of the people of the State" If it wen forced generally upon Infants and adults, winch form three-quarters of the oii.il.itlon and are most susceptible to smallpox; hut there Is no hopo of Its ever being considered "vital" to the public health when forced on the school age, which forms only one-quarter of population and has over ten times the natural Immunity against smallpox anil all other diseases when compared to the infant and adult it therefore follows mathematically, logically and irresistibly, that, as smallpot is s-tually one of the most in significant of all our of death and as the vaccinated and unvacclnated contract and 'lie of smallpox almost i-. cases and deaths being almost always among the vacmated? and as school ag? is naturally most vital and Immune t.i smallpox and alt other dleeaaea, it is impossible that the health of the State can be affected vitally" or BS r.gards smallpox, one way or the other, whether the children or school age or not Th, facts therefore absolute proof of the entire folly of compulsory vaccination of school children and absurd theor of vaceinators lit trying to improve the health ot such children, agaiiisl rar? to which they are least subject, ami wlmh in anj case ia one of our most Insignificant causes of death, deliberatel) In? i ding all of these children with an artificial disease which t.0w kills mor? them than smallpox Tins barb.iron.-. forced us by our medical societies which profit from is not a grave medical malpractice but il Is. I believe, a medical on the people be soon recoa by our juries, Courts and and will prohibited by penal law just as surelj Smallpox ino? illation and Arm-to Arm Vaccination have been prohibited.

And I now want to say that I regard it a discredit to our lireat I'epartment of r.duratlon, win? is perhaps the highest office in our State Government, on winch we spend the freutest amount of our publl. treasure, which is Ailed by learned and abb mi at thi 11? of oui Public Kdu lational System a discredit 1 that these lrartud men should so n.isl.d by the niost shameful cur? rent and fallacies on the subject ol vaccination A little Independent down to basic fact? shoa them the dangerous tolly and stupid falsehood of most of them falls lea talned rfnl self Interested profession which profits greatly from the.s? medical practices and at th me so controls nil our machiner- I statistics that it ran easll- and conceal 'ron, in? public r.e rfii that bail or fatal of III? that from time to lime. I to public notl to theBe medl a I societlea and to th? Health i-- ci of tina and State II il Wl11 my emit of mj rights as voter ai in the powers b) under the luw, to fore th'iii to submit the death certificates on Ml? certain to full public fitinv, whereby II will be shown to the people how many rhlldr-n and adults are killed vear dlrectlj and indirectly by vaccination, whbh they are striving ho hard upon everv and adult fit) and State while the? continue to ass'-rt thai it la and harmless and is thai means known prevent smallpox pidrmb-s. Whereas, the easil) demonstrated fa? thai good sanitati-n and strict isolation with or without limited or vaccination, is all ti ,.07,.:,, thai general foi "'I and widespread va? dnatlou aeries onl. to greatlj increase di-sease la gross medical malpractice which must soon be prevented b) penal law.

10 the re.ent experience nf the town of Niagara Falls, on which man', falla? je? have uttered iroper to no-a saj few words. "Phis same health departniei i llulleiin strives to epidemic there was -lue to lack Of InatlOl, II to of -malin. I will nol deal wllh just now except topoml out some which I hese will no. ju.s and to thai ihe after their recent experience, ar. cY of i of It Ml? 1 I I.I I l.r- r.

A Um 11 barba rl I fulllltj and fatal! of all va dilation and a-e rmli er ual to that In well vaccinated battleship, thai Uieiv "i How do ymi like this which heavilv against vai mem from Niagara Kails n-li? ulous' thinh thai "hono-s are par? th? cas? o' th. poorl; laciiialed tnwn with the well vi.t.ated ship- ly ol" It, I must now again the thai all thai we make to one who freely wlshea It or believes It necesaarv or -i -o. 7i freedom for ail as now enjoi full relhgloua hal warring i and all medical statletlcal faWhoods and oll ulll. baaed Ninth St. N.

Sept. Ith. Antl-Voerlnstioi Mam "ftl.e of The 14? 'heMu'it Fit-a FresliL-nl I'orter l'ope, note, in a few days another article -ill giving.