The Province from Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada • 2

THE DAILY PROVINCE, VANCOUVER, BRITISH COLUMBIA, THURSDAY, MARCH 3,. 1927. MINISTERS DENY with a man of Carlow' character. It would be admitted at the proper time thut liquor order had been placed, but not through Carlow, th purchase being made direct from Whlteley', WOMAN GUILTY OF MANSLAUGHTER (Continual from Tf I) Birthstones for March Bloodstone or Aquamarine CourageTruthfulness We have these Birthstones In many forms ot Jewelry Such as Complete Dispensation at every one of our seven stores. CUNNINGHAM PRESCRIPTION SERVICE Is well known ns the best In Vancouver.

We will call for your prescriptions and deliver FREE OF CHARGE anywhere within the city. Week-End Specials RINGS BARP1N3 TIE PINS ETC. fir we can make tin any tpeclul design to order on short notlee. Hair Clippers Week-End Special 98c Reg. With a keen your Today a neat everyone must maintain and attractive appearance.

O. B. ALLAN LIMITED 'TA Hout of Diamonds" 480-486 Granville Street, Corner of Pender pair of hair clippers, you can hair in perfect condition. This is nn exceptional opportunity. Only a limited number on hand.

Guaranteed Alarm Clocks S1.49 lw a IV shipment or Alarm on Druid. These, are? guaranteed. Candy Special I'rp Pound 39c mad strong riceitlun'l. Vacuum Bottle and Lunch Kit Complete Slc-29 There Is willing more popular for those taldng a lunch, with them, jr on picnics, than this complete set. The case has a neat appearance; can 1 1 bo carried around; vacuum bottle Is h-'lil on springs, and there Is ampin room lor other provisions.

19c oceye Salmon ROBIN HOOD ROLLED OATS 6-lb. sacks .2 QUAKER PEARS 2s, per tin 20 NU-JELL JELLY POWDERS All flavors. Five packets for 23 BLUE RIBBON TEA Mb. packets for 65? EMPRESS LOGANBERRY JAM 4-lb. cans for 58 PURE RASPBERRY JAM 4-lb.

tins for 45t? KLONDIKE SOAP Largo bars, each 240 CHOICE PINK SALMON Four cans for 25 MALKINS BEST SWEET POTATOES Large cans 25tf TOILET PAPER Eight rolls for 25t SEEDLESS RAISINS 2 lbs. for 25 ENGLISH CUSTARD POWDER 1 lb. bags 25 PflRKHAMS fJRQCERTERIAS ilMall Order Department A Thirty Orocerterlas 41 Hastings Street West, Vancouver, B. C. VIROL s-oiincs CI 111X8 TEPSODEM TOOTH PASTE 30o TOOTH BRISK 25c FI LLER'S EARTH rr.Brcn tooth PASTE HI TAX TOOTH PASTE LAVGRIS Small site 10D A.

B. ft. A TABLETS 75o LNJUD PETROLATITT PHILLIP'S MILK OF MAGNESIA 10c FRENCH NOL'GAT BARS PYORRHOCIBE lOOIH POWDER TIIERMOOENE Pael.nne Minns LINIMENT KOLVNOS TOOTH PASTE B. WAX PAPER ROLLS 65c 40c 39c 29c 16c 39c 19c 15c 48c 5c 79c 42c 19c 35c 29c 19c 25c EAGLE BRAND MILK EPSOM SALTS 3 pound for HOSPITAL COTTON ib. roll KOTEX I'urkane CO, in, 20 WATT LIGHTS jil.no ii vi it SILTS 39c 59c 19c 69c A I klN'S MLLSIFIED C.H.OV I Oil.

shimpoo HUT ATF.n III) T. Guaranteed Delay Discussion of Proposed Amalgamation NORTH VANCOUVER, March Thi City Ratepayers' Association on night decided to hold all future meetings on the flrat Thursday In each month, commencing In April. As replies have not yet teen received to communications sent to the three North Hhore councils on amalgamation, the proposed discussion on that sub-Ject was not held at Wednesday's meeting. Woman Gave Birth to Son While on Train on Tuesday On her way from Malakwa to the Revelstok Hospital on the ('anad'an Pacific Railway, Mrs. Olson gave birth to a son on Tuesday.

Thla Is the second time within two weeks In which the stork has visited C. 1'. It. trains travelling in British Columbia. 34c $1.19 mm 69c 1 Woodbury's Facial Soai 3 cakes SOLO AT HARDWARE STORES AND PAINT OtALCRSV VB ITI AMERICA PA I NT CO.

urio mes throughout her evidence as "McRae," said that he left home on November 13 to look for work. Khe becamo worried about him and notified the police that wan missing, ltelng afraid of being left alone she borrowed a gun from a friend for protection. The gun was the same which Constable Htrong had previously recognized as the one which the accused handed to him. KOT KSAX, KAMI Or HUSBAND. McRae, ah said, was not her hus-band'a real name.

It was the name In which he married her, but hla ral name waa Clark Royalty. Hha did not know why he changed except for fear of hla father. Hh had livestock and cash to ths extent of HOfirt In Tutaka when they married. 8h told of equipping McRae and her son with an outfit and a horse to go to Canada. Her son was one of three children by her first husband.

McHae disappeared and next she heard of him he was posing as a single man In Canada. roviro RIK AT XASQUBBADal BALL. She found him at a masquerade ball and stripped the mask from his face Me threw his arms around her and promised to make amends. Khe Intended going back to Montana, but Mcf.a held her there and she bought some stock and stsrted a dairy. Her daughter helped her aell butter, milk and eggs and they establlahed a gooo business.

Mchae, witness proceeded, drew some money for the use of the team which should have been paid to witness and also kept some money which he should have paid to the teamster, and the next she heard of him war from the sheriff of Boise, Idaho. Bh took the ftpokane flyer and went to his aid. Bhe found til in In a little plain used aa a Jail, secured his release and paid hi expenaes back to Canada. Later he got in trouble over a horse and wsa arrested by the Mounted Po lice In Kdmonton. He got a three-year sentence, but witness managed to secure a parole for htm.

Ho went, about thla time, to the war. While her hubband waa away wit ness took a course In wlrelesa and telegraphy to brush up and secured work as a spare hand. McRae came to her one day whllo she waa nt school and said the house had been ransacked. Hhe afterwards accused him of taking the 1110 that was missing and extracting a promise from her that she would nut mention It again lie told her where IM of the amount was. The remainder he psld out of hla war gratuity when he left ths army, Cross-examined, Mrs.

McRae said that up to the night of November 12, her husband had only been absent from the home on Brounhton street once except for the time waa In hospital. Mr. Johnson recalled the borrowing of the revolver. "Are you familiar with arms?" "Yes "Can you shoot?" "Some." "Tou know how to fir a "Ye." "Did you become familiar with arms In Western Alberta?" "No, In Montana." I hy did you ten jjr. ledger your husband could come if be did not bring a policeman?" "I thought I might talk sense to McRae If I got him alone." "Waa the policeman there for your husnajiii a protection? "No, thero waa no need for It." "What was tho policeman there for, If not to protect your husband?" "1 do not know." "Was the revolver on the table al the head of the bed loaded?" "Yes." "Why did you bring the cartridges downstairs? "I do not remember bringing thorn down." "When did you load the gun?" "Saturday night." "You do not suggest anyono else shot your husband? "No." WOM-alT ADMITS SHOOTrNO.

"I am bound to puc tms question to you: 'Did you shoot hlmr" Witness hesitated some time befor Anally answering "Yes." "What was your reason" "When I saw him leave the house I knew it waa )ut to go with that Mrs. dmythe." "You were determined that he should not go with this Mrs. Bmythe?" "I was determined to keep my home together If I possibly could." admitted writing a letter to Mrs Smythe, telling her there would be trouble If she did not stop going with tier (Airs. Mcnae's) husband. "You had It In your mind on Novem her 17 you would stop what wer your reasons for shooting?" was worried by the scandal r.efilect and years of anuse after I had done everything I could to help him and In every other way.

Mr. Henderson produced letters to how accused's state of mind at the of the tragedy. Mrs. McRae' examination closed at this point. Mra.

Keith ef St. John, Washington a daughter of Mrs. McRae by her first iiuxtiand, was the last witness and was i.ii the stand for only two minutes to briefly of trouble between the aa cuxrd and the slain man. Mrs. McRae, who had Just returned to the dock, looked In the direction of her daughter, wiped away a few tears for the second time In the trial, tut soon returned her calm.

TOKTO, March 8 It waa offlclslly announced today that Empress Nsgako expeot to become a mother early In August. In view of the fact that the child, If a male, will be heir to the throne, the announcement was received tvlth intense Interest. The first child cf Emperor Hlrohlto and Empress Nsgako was a girl. A red hot favorite, nait footless Egg Coal the best cooking fuel on the market today. Hole sellers, Evans, Coleman Evana, tiey.

2JS8. Cunnmqliam Drug Special Week-End Sale 75c Peerless MALT EXTRACT 59c Willi every tin of this well-known Malt Extract, we will fllve, a free parkane Peerless YcaM, rnou(li for one tin of mull. Orders Given Prompt and Careful Attention LIMITED "Bob" Roger Xa 63. WINNIPEG, March 3. Hon.

Kobeit Roger today celebrated his 3rd birthday by attending a reception tendered by 2f0 member of the Winnipeg Con-survutlv Club. How She Got Rid of Rheumatism Knowing from terrible experience the sufferink caused by rheumatism, Mrs. J. K. Hurnt, who liven at SiM Iiavis Avenue, 39 Itlonminaton, 111.

Ik so thankrul at having Ileal ml herself that out of pure vrHtltude ehe In anxious to loll all othiT nufrerem Juet bow to Ret rid of their torture by a almplt way at home. lluret baa nothing to Merely cut out tills notice. niHll It to her tfh your own name and arldreea, and ahe will glmily eend you thla vain-abla Information entirely free. Write her at one before you forget. (Advt.) CARLOW CHARGES (Contlnasa from Pg 1.) Premier within half an hour of tabling the resolution, but the same courtesy was not extended to him.

On the pres. ant occasion he waa In possession of the original documents, but he would make them available at the proper time. After reviewing the contents of the affidavit, Mr. Twigg said that, If the declaration were true be believed It n9 It was Improper that officials of the government could be made ue of for the purpose of obtaining party funds. If the charge were true, then Carlow was Justified In what he said "SOMEBODY (MULTir Or BOMBTHIWa." "I do not suggest that any division of money wa to be made between them," he added, "and they can not blame me for saying that such was the case.

But I do protest agalntit this policy, aa a member of the House. If it la correct, the people of British Columbia are assisting to pay Into the party funds of the Liberals." Colonel Feck, Conservative, The Is-Ifitids, seconded the resolution. "I haw too much respect for the honor of member of this House to believe 1 am too loyal to them for that to believe that anyone ha been guilty of wrongdoing. But after all, somebody Kuilty of something." Members of the government laughed "You will have your Hlg Cheese and your Ben Selfs, and that bunch, and you must take the consequences," added Colonel I'eck. are having a royal commission, and I think we had better give the Carlow case the once-over'." Dr.

MacLean, minister of finance and education, said that the House had had before it demands for enquiries Into wrongdoing on the part of official of the government, charges made on lh responsibility of member ot the House, Involving the Speaker and mlnlKterw, and now charges of tho same nature. Involving minister, Including himself. "I am taking part In a discussion of this kind for tho first time In a period of ten years in public llfe." said Iir. Mar Lean. "The only reason for my doing so Is that my name has been linked with the charges made by the third member for Victoria, and, so far hh I am concerned, 1 can not let them ro unanswered.

I regret exceedingly that forty-seven member of this llou. who have come to the age of maturity, should have wasted the time ot the Legislature and the money of the people in muckraking. I regret exceedingly also that wo have members of (he House that can resort to that sort of thing." There were many great problems to tie solved for members, he continued Thero were problem for the solution of which they were elected by the reople. It was not Intended that they should fit ln.the449B!te, day after-Car, llstornnff to such charges. "1 am a married man, with a ald the minister, "and I can not af ford to permit charges of this kind to go unanswered.

Were I a single man, I should know how to deal with them my early days I knew something of boxing, and Of tho treatment of men In lumber camps who did not know how to behave themselves, and that Is the treatment I would have given on tho present occasion." NZVBK RZAXD SUCK VBNOHOU3 CHARGES. Continuing, after applause from the government benches had died down, the minister said he had heard charges made before, but none with so much venom In them as the present ones. He was wondering whether they were having a reflex of the aesalon of 1926 in the Dominion House of Commons. There wns a war of strategy. The present leader of the Conservatives was a member of the board of strategy.

"I am wondering whether thera havi been instructions from the leader of the Conservative party at Ottawa, In connection with the present charge," continued Dr. MacLean. "I don't know If them Is any reason for suggesting that. I understand, however, that It has been denied that the fact that the l-'aulliler charge were to be mud a was not known to the member of that party, and that only three of them were aware of them. I venture to say that three members would not tako upon themselves the responsibility of nuiklng such serious charges, unless they had Instructions.

We had, In the I02S federal election campaign, well, known men, such as Nicholson and other, who carried on a campaign of slander, but not one of them 1 In Par. Ilament today, I would Ilka that remark to sink In among members on the opposite sids of the House." "The present charges are not true, they are false, and ther la not one scintilla of truth In them, so far a I am personally concerned," he went on. "Tho last part of th resolution, calling for a commission, 1 quite gratuitous, as I am going to Insist that a searching enquiry shall made, and I am going to ask that th full penalty of the House be exacted on those responsible for them." Dr. MacLean then proceeded to analyze the charges, a they relate to Mm. He recalled the 1920 election, the first general election which he went through a a member of the government.

There was a general agreement that he was In the best position, aa a member of the party, In the matter of organlilng, as he had more time to keep touch with the various Liberal organizations, and to encourage Liberalism throughout the province. could wot Arroito TO KANDLB TURDS. "I mad It very clear," said the mln. later, "that I would do that work ah-aolutely under condition that there should be no itcti thing as me handling campaign iund. I could not afford to do that.

I have lived In th country too long I believe In Liberalism, but ther are thing that I would not stoop to The House tense with attention and interest at thla statement. It wa In th year 1922, said th minister, that Carlow had hi Inter- view with him. I ri tr that he Car. low) should get a liquor agency, and tnat the commission should go towards th campaign fund and hi alary as organizer. "Mr.

Carlow mads that statement to ni. said the minister. "I told him I would have nothing to. do with It, That wa In the year 1322. From that day till this, he ha never entered my ornce, -j no Who, a few year ago, reported him as being a prominent Conservative.

He had an associate. named Captain Harhotd, who was Lib- erai president In Vancouver, and who today president of th Conservative party In victor. continuing, the minister said that he would endorse what th attorney, general had said In the (Muthler debate about Mr. Twlgg. Ho could also say things shout Carlow.

but he would content himself with saying that It would be shown that those who fathered such charge were not any ngcis or purity. Categorically nd unennlvocably Hon. Dr. MacLean denied every part of the Carlow statement that ha4 refer. enc to nnnecir.

Titer wa not a scintilla of truth In a single atserlion the maker of House of Lords bcolen whisky. CHARACTER. MURDBRBRS." Again the minister declared that he courted Investigation of every charge. After they had been disproved he would consider what steps he could take, civilly or politically, to deal with the "character murderers" who had made them. Hon.

T. 1). Tattullo, minister of lands, followed. He said that mem bers opposite were to furiously anxious to obtain the relne of power that tney would not stop at anything that would give them office. It was not so much personal animus against the minlHters as It was a desire to attain power.

He recalled the Beaver Club ot Vic toria which had existed during the Conservative regime ome years ago. declaring that it had controlled tho appointments and contract with tho government of the day. He had been minister of lands longer than any other minister had ever held the office, he said, and he remembered the injunction of his father, "My son, you went Into this clean. I hope you come out of It cltan." The minister went on to explain the difficulties that existed between tho federal and provlnolsl government In connection with the foreshore rlghti. of British Columbia.

It was In 1922 when these matters (Continued on Pag 4, Col. 3.) TWIGG IS CALLED A "MUCKRAKER" (Con tinned from Fag 1.) Having forced the member to assume responsibility, the Premier had then started to threaten the third member for Victoria, telling him that, "God helping him, he would sea that he did answer to that responsibility." He would agre that perhaps It was the duty of the Premier to ee that responsibility was accepted for the charges, but the Premier had another duty to perform, a duty a Prime Minister of British Columbia. It was to see that Mr. Twlgg had every opportunity of proving the allegations for which he had been forced to accept responsibility, TRIT.D TO LIMIT SCOPB OT XMQUIRY- The attitude of the Premier could, however, be translated as being that he would do everything In his power to prevent the charge being proven. The first tep that the Premier had taken In this respect had been to try tn limit the scope ot the enquiry to tha Province of British Columbia, knowing that such would be to prevent half the evidence upon which the third member for Victoria relied being produced.

Mr. Twtgg had explained to the House that he relied upon evidence that would be produced in England, Scotland and France, as well as In Eastern Canada. The Premier waa at tempting to prevent that evidence being presented to a commission of enquiry, by seeking to have It limited to the province under the Publlo En quiries Act. "If honorable members vote to con fine the enquiry to British Columbia," declared the speaker, "then It means that they are voting to prevent the most Important witnesses from giving evidence. In effect It would be say.

Ing to the third member for Victoria, 'prove your charges, but we won't let you do It. Continuing. Mr. Hinehllffe said that If the amendment to the amendment which he had moved was defeated and the amendment of the Premier carried, "tha decision of the commission would he useless and would not be accepted by the people as reflecting the real truth of the story." In opening, Mr. Manson referred to the remarks of Mr.

Hinehllffe. CUSTOMARY TO TAXIS FULL RESPONSIBILITY. "I have a great respect for the pro fession tn which the honorable member for Victoria once belonged, but I can. hot understand his mental atti tude when he says that," observed the attorney-general. "He says he Is soli, cltous for the good name of the government.

Out of respect for the pro fession which he once followed I hesitate to say thst Is not true; but I don't believe that he Is one hit solid-tons about the reputation of the members on this side of the House." Mr. Manson quoted parliamentary authorities to prove that It wss customary for members making charges to take full responsibility for them a practice which had been accepted ns a necessity for all members, in Britain, he added, members had been frequently penalized severely for mak ing unrounded charges. 'Are we not reasonable, then, In asking th member for Victoria (Mr. Twlgg) to take responsibility for hi statements?" Mr. Manson demanded.

Let us look at the fact. The record of thla House containing hi charge are Bent all over British Columbia, Into very district. A 11 once atarted can never be fully overtaken, and It 1 apparent that If his statement wer untrue, that document, the record or this House containing them ar aa highly slanderous anything? could be." Referring to th argument sa to whether or not th statement of Gauthler wer contained In an affidavit, Mr. Manson said he hoped It was an affidavit, this would entail soma responsibility upon th man who signed It. "BVBRTOMB HAD HBARD ABOUT IT." Mr.

Twlgg had told the House that he had not known of th Gauthler charge up to a few days ago, Mr. Manson proceeded. This, he said, was iiirprlalng a Mr. Twlgg was not deaf PEOPLE PIES' What to Do if You Find Your self in This Condition. The sort of thing that specialists sprftk of as nervous debility Is the run-down condition caused by overwork, household cares and worries.

Thn sufferers find themselves tired, low-spirited and unable to keep their minds on anythluu. Any sudden noise hlarllcs unci mi-Is lh heart palpitating violently. They are full of groundlcsg fears, and do not sleep well at glit. The hands tremble and the legs feel as If they would give way, following ft walk or nny exertion. Tim whole rnndltlnn of such people may bo described as pitiable.

Doctoring the nerves with poisonous Hi'datlvM Is terrlbl mistake. Tim only real nerve tnnlo Is a good supplv of new rich blood, Therefore the treatment for nervousness and run-down health Is Dr. Williams' Pink Pills, which promptly Puna up ana enrich the blood. The revived appetite, the strong nerves. Improved spir-ll.

and new strength which comes Headaches from Slight Colds Laxative BROMO QUININE Tab-lets relieve the Headache by work-ins nff thfl Pnld. A Kflfa ahri Prmran Remedy. The box bears ths signature of E. W. Grove.

30c. Made in Canada. Marked Praise For Pacific Milk tV A aateat irrt Mm On the front page of ths White-horse Star on Feb. 18, there Is an account of a dinner party given In the Yukon In which Paolfle Milk Is given credit for the fine bread served bread so good it excited comment among ths fuests. Mrs.

Kerrulsh. who en-ertalned, said she had used Pa-olflo Milk In making It. Pacific Milk Bead Office. Vancouver Factories at Ladner and Abbotaford BOARD FILES BOX FILES FILING CABINETS FOLDERS CARD INDEX CABINETS RECORD CARDS GUIDE CARDS The Clarke Stuart Co. Limited stationers and rrlntrri Plats rrlntit-g and Embossing oiO SEYMOUR STREET Phone Sey.

3000 There are 0.17 parts fat In spinach. IF COUGHS AND COLDS INTERFERE WITH BUSINESS A Vtgttablt Preparation that gitti qakk uialtt without drugging tht $ytlem I eve ltWaWi The De Luxa Packac Trartr blade (60 keenest 'riaving edges.) The finest means science can tievii for a truly perfect nhsve. Quslltyisteeuarticd by the tnot careful preparation, selection and Inspection. Stop (htm kt? '''lyv The last blade kiWkt I rnust remember and every member had heard of these matters for a long time. He declared Mr.

Twlgg could not rise In Ms place and say he had not heard a good deal about these matters long before the session started. "I heard of It from on of the (Continued on Page 3, Ool. 3. LOW FEES ALWAYS High priced rfcjallstt of the highest skill sTve the pitlents la tills practice at the lowest cost. Tha size of the practice makes this advantage possible.

It' Is this superior, low cost service which has made Torlo Optical Co. what It la first In size In ths West, and caused removal of ths office to larger, finer quarters. But fees still remain ths lowest. Toric Optical Co. Nolet New Address 118 Hastings Street West (Directly Oppnslie Woodward's Main Service Faulty equipment often causes the poor heating results many people ex periencc.

Choked flues and leaky dampers and drafts will waste the best fuel you can buy. The Ideal Household Fuel If you don't get the results you should, phone, and let our combustion engineer investigate. Sey. 4395 Ltd. T.

ef SmJtl -C5-razor BLADES I. Wf i VXXi-i-e regarding himself, he repeated. alter a course or tne.e piliS win ne- 'fiv'ZNo 1 He did not think anyone hsd ever light every sufferer. suggested thst he was inssr.e, he said, You can gt these pills from any eamor Coal Co GiixeTTE SArtry razor or Canada, limited, montrial I "J4; F)7. self to mentally affected If he ever a bot from The Pr.

Williams' Mdl- gglCrQ'fe-Q 1, a vunsldered discussing ny such matten cilia DrocLvllle, Ont. (Advt) aw.