The Record from Hackensack, New Jersey on June 5, 1980 · 10
Get access to this page with a Free Trial

A Publisher Extra Newspaper

The Record from Hackensack, New Jersey · 10

Hackensack, New Jersey
Issue Date:
Thursday, June 5, 1980
Start Free Trial

A 10 THE RECORD, THURSDAY, JUNE 5. 1980 BERGENPASSAICHUDSON COUNTIES, NEW JERSEY Judge rules out further damages in asbestos case Los Angeles Times News Service LOS ANGELES - Former Long Beach Naval Shipyard worker Richard J. Ho-gard, who last week won $1.2 million in a precedent-setting case that could affect thousands of asbestos workers, cannot collect additional punitive damages from two asbestos manufacturers, a judge has ruled. Superior Court Judge Earl F. Riley's decision yesterday ended the six-week trial and cleared the way for Hogard to challenge the punitive damages ruling and for the manufacturers to appeal the jury award. The jury had voted May 27, by the bare 9-3 majority necessary in civil cases, to award Hogard $1,229,491 in compensa-1 tory damages after finding that asbestos manufacturers, Johns-Manville Corp. and Raybestos-Manhattan Inc., failed to warn the pipe insulator of the hazards of working with their products. Hogard, 40, of St. James, Mo., contends that his 10 years of working with asbestos insulation materials caused him to get asbestosis, an irreversible scarring that causes the lungs to shrink and inhibits breathing. In dismissing the jurors yesterday, Riley said he had decided that punitive damages were unwarranted because of three major reasons: Hogard's lawyer, Robert B. Steinberg, planned to base much of his case for punitive damages on manufacturers' memos from the 1940s, indicating that they knew of asbestos hazards and did nothing to protect workers. California's product liability law, under which the case was tried, was established in 1963, and Hogard only began working at the shipyard in 1965. Therefore, Riley said using earlier evidence was "illogical, improper and simply unfair." Secondly, he sid, the manufacturers simply sold asbestos-containing products the U.S. Navy, designed to meet Navy specifications, and to equate meeting those specifications with the fraud, malice, willful misconduct or concealment necessary to award punitive damages would be "totally inequitable." Thirdly, the judge said, any purported fraud, malice, willful misconduct, or concealment must be directed specifically at the plaintiff. It would be improper to award punitive damages to Hogard, first exposed to asbestos in 1965, he said, because of any wrongdoing that occurred against other asbestos workers in the 1930s and 1940s. Asbestos phased out of products Manufacturers had phased asbestos out of their insulating products completely by 1972, and thus established during the trial that they voluntarily placed warn ing labels on their products in 1964. Hogard left the shipyard on disability pension in 1975 after a doctor advised him to get away from asbestos, so he no longer works with their products. Still elated and a little dazed by his huge verdict last week, Hogard said he was not upset by yesterday s ruling. Steinberg said the $1.2-miIlion award was the highest in the country so far among asbestos cases that have involved a single injured worker, although higher awards have been granted to families of workers who died. Over 1,000 cases are pending More than 1,000 cases are pending In the court here, and numerous other simi lar cases have been filed elsewhere, in cluding many in U.S, District Court in Newark. Steinberg said Hogard's victory could influence them, perhaps by forestalling trials on grounds that the issues have already been litigated, and by set ting guidelines for settlements. Steinberg said he is inclined to appeal KHey s decision, and plans to seek punitive damages in the more than 100 simi lar cases he is handling for other asbestos workers. "We think the conduct of the defen dants can be fairly characterized as con scious disregard for the safety of people who had to work with their products," Steinberg said. "They chose not only to ignore it but to consciously disregard it, and that is the test for punitive damages in California. Johns-Manville attorney Fulton Haight and Raybestos lawyer John Norby believed they were partially vindicated by Riley's ruling that punitive damages were improper. They said they will seek a new trial and ask Riley to alter the jury s verdict. pop. bob aoldstein the men's store in rutherford FATHER'S DAY IS JUNE 15th J i t w FARAH Slacks for Father's Day, and the other 365 days from$18 t Iff v : ' k w Undecided? Givt Dad a Bob Goldstein Gift Certificate bob qoldstein 56 park avenue, rutherford, n.. 935-5058 OPEN DAILY TO 6 . THURSDAY & FRIDAY TO 9 $30 Off on Atari video computer system (regular price) 'jftii fcv tey ti'f"-i fc--r-wf HSR iwanaTOmrnrmW ffiffiitii-YrMtt wlMmtrtiWBIaMi I LJ 1 I n I w so 4k J The color video game system that lets you play games with realistic sound while you sharpen your mental and physical coordination. System comes complete with TV power adapters, joystick and paddle controls and combat cartridge which features tank and plane battles. Regularly 189.99 . . Sale 159.99 Other cartridges available: Backgammon, Regularly 39.99 Sale 31 .99 Video Chess, Regularly 39.99 Sale 31 .99 Human Cannonball, Regularly 19.99 . . .Sale 16.99 Skydiver, Regularly 19.99 Sale 16.99 Football, Regularly 19.99 Sale 16.99 Casino, Regularly 24.99 '. Sale 1 9.99 Adventure, Regularly 29.99. Sale 24.99 Superman, Regularly 24.99 Sale 19.99 Advanced Electronic Equipment (714). Add 3 for delivery. PHONE A&S 9 AM TO 9 PM-7 DAYS A WEEK. Call Central N.J (201) 494-1600. Northern N.J. (201) 967 1600 Add local sales tax C O D orders filled on 25 or more. Abraham and Straus Brooklyn Queens Hempstead Manhasset Babylon Huntington Smith Haven Monmouth Paramus Woodbndge 20to 25 off on Sanyo watches (regular prices) ,., j4.-s, ty:rs' V .75 C $; WmmM U )) ' A R A. Sanyo chronograph melody alarm watch Calendar shows month, date, day of week Stop watch functions Melody alarm plays "Old Suzannah'-Light lets you see time in dark Stylish flexible metal wrist band Regularly 59 99 Sale 44.99 B. Sanyo runners chronograph watch with alarm With sporty plastic case and wrist band for comfort and durability during active play i 'Calendar displays year, month, date and day of week Clock displays time in hours, minutes and seconds Stop watch functions (startstart stoplap time), dual time and night light Regularly 39 99 Sale 28.99 and calculators for Dad and grad i (,- . . . -..oil h 4 s 1 , SANYO -. Ikhmm-: 1 1 I c.x reis T J ' I I ioc wit ct 11 ' v-'' ' Z ; 8 f ' 9 x ' iyff'JV-':;.l.W. SANYO tkhtum 0 -. OZal CZ.i) CZ!3 J LJ L L.J L...4J ? f ) fi r 5 1 "5 I $kt.J 1 nnn " x , v N S S 1 L .J ! rT" -f J J . O w D E C. Sanyo electronic j clockcalculator with memory ; 8-digit blue liquid crystal display with 10.000 3 hour battery s Regularly 19 99 Sale 15.99 D. Sanyo ultra-thin credit card calculator with memory Memoryguard protection. Automatic power-off Regularly 16 99 Sale 13.49 E. Sanyo wallet calculator with 6500 hours of operating time Independent memory; 8 digit display Regularly 14.99 Sale 11.99 Calculators (206) Watches (714) Add '3 for delivery PHONE A&S 9 AM TO 9 PM-7 DAYS A WEEK. Call Central N.J (201) 494-1500. Northern N J (201)967-1600 Aod toca' sa es tax COD order filled on '5 or mof Abraham and Straus 6'oc v Queers Hecs'efld Va'-Asse' Ba? v- -re" S-,t-s- Vr-T' pa-a""s VJto3t"c; ...especially for Father's Day.

What members have found on this page

Get access to

  • The largest online newspaper archive
  • 20,900+ newspapers from the 1700s–2000s
  • Millions of additional pages added every month

Publisher Extra Newspapers

  • Exclusive licensed content from premium publishers like the The Record
  • Archives through last month
  • Continually updated

Try it free