The Courier News from Blytheville, Arkansas on February 20, 1968 · Page 6
Get access to this page with a Free Trial

The Courier News from Blytheville, Arkansas · Page 6

Publication:
Location:
Blytheville, Arkansas
Issue Date:
Tuesday, February 20, 1968
Page:
Page 6
Start Free Trial
Cancel

P»ff Twa?t - Blylhtvlllt (Art.) Courier Kewg - Tu«d«y, Ftbru»iy », H» Does ^Wayward Press' Poison Juror's Mind? (Second of a scries.) By UOGEK DOUGHTY NBA Slaff Correspondent NEW YORK - (NEA) Those who oppose the Roardon Reporl are iond of quoting former U. S. Supreme Court Justice Tom Clark, who once said, "The criminal law has readied such a degrading stage that good lawyers shun it." Those who favor (he proposals point to men like Edward Bennett Williams in order lo refute Justice Clark's generalization. "Frankly," says good lawyer Williams, "I haven't read the Beardon Report, but I have some definite ideas about the relationship of the press and the bar." Supporters of the Reardon Rein fact, Williams who has de- P°rl cite several cases where fended such luminaries as the late Sen. Joseph McCarthy, Jim my Hoffa, Adam Clayton Powel and Bobby Baker, has written a book on the subject. In the book, titled "One Man's Freedom," Williams essentially sums up the case for the lawyers who back the report he Jurnself has not read. "If our system Is to continue to use trial by jury," writes Williams, "the minds of the jurors must be kept free from outside influences. A chemist would not make a test wi test tubes contaminated b the actions of the press have resulted in overturned murder convictions. The Sam Sheppard case is one example. Williams notes the case of Leslie Irvin, overturned by the Supreme Court in 1961. ".Irvin," writes Williams "was arrested near Evansville, Ind., on April 8, 1955. Soon afterward the prosecutor in that county and the Evansville po- ice issued press releases slat waste materials. The minds o the jurors are the test lubes o the judicial system. They mus be kept clean of extraneous ma tcr if justice is to be done That's why civilized society re moved trials from the marke place, surrounded them wit safeguards and brought them under the most careful judicia scrutiny. Justice requires tha jurors make their decisions sole ly on the facts properly pre sented to them. Ways must be found to biock those wlio wouic put before them material which does not belong there. Only then can we guarantee the constitutional right to a fair trial." Or, as professor David L. Shapiro of the Harvard Law School and the reporter for the American Bar Association's Advisory Committee on Fair Trial and Free Press puls it, "Dissemination of pretrial information has posed a threat from the time of Aaron Burr to that of Richard Speck. Just how much damage lias been caused by ill- ing that he had confessed to six murders which had occurred in the Evansville area. Newspapers headlined the story and radio and television stations carried extensive newscasts about it. In the following days, more news stories were written about Irvin. These revealed the details of his life, including accounts of the crimes he had committed when he was a juvenile 20 years before the crime in question was perpetrated. Headlines announced that le had been identified in a po- ice line-up, that he had faced a lie-detector test, that he had ieen placed at (he scene of he crime. Other stories said lie ad confessed to 24 burglaries, timed personal opinions is impossible to guess." nd one story related the prom, se of the sheriff to devote his fe (o securing Irvin's convic- on. Ho was described as a confessed slayer of six' and ic 'mad dog killer.' " The publicity in (he Irvin case esulted in 2C8 of 430 prospec- ve jurors saying they had al- ady'inade up their minds Irn was guilty. Irvin was convicted and sentenced to death but the Supreme Court overturned the conviction and ordered a new trial, noting that two-thirds of the prospective jurors polled before the trial admitted (hey already believed lr- vin was guilty. As Justice Paul C. Reardon of the Massachusetts Supreme Court and author of the Reardon Report observes, "There is a large number of cases in which substantial danger of an unfair trial is crealed because potentially prejudiced information has reached the eyes and ears of Ihe triers of fact." If the ABA approves the rcc- ommendalions of the report, the court will be in a position to make it tough on newsmen who violate the rules. In a speech lo the University of San Diego Law School Jus- lice Reardon made it clear that he's in favor of restricting lawyers and police from disclosure of an accused's prior criminal record, the existence and contents of any confessions, failure of the accused to make any statement, the performance of any tests and examinations, information surrounding prospective witnesses, the possibility of a guilty plea by the accused, and the defendant's guilt or innocence, or other matters relating to the merits of the case. As for the "wayward press," Reardon stated, "we also recommend a limited use of the contempt power against a person who, knowing that a criminal trial by jury is in progress or that a jury is being selected, disseminates information rela- livc to the defendant or the issues of the case that goes beyond the public record of the court if the statement is reasonably calculated to affect tin, outcome of the trial and ser iously threatens to have such an effect, or makes such a state ment with the expectation that it will be so disseminated, 01 against a person who knowingly violates a valid judicial order not to disseminate until t h e trial's completion or other disposition of (he case certain spe- ificd information." What about the public's right lo know? "The public has the right to know the truth," says Reardon. 'However, this righl does not extend to irresponsible reporting, to prejudicial statements by prosecutors and police, or to hcrcsay or rumor." "The press," says one New York lawyer, "is crying be- cause the reporter and his editor won't have the final say as to what (he people will know aboul a crime. Well, Ihe reporters and the editors had lhat responsibility for years and they proved Ihey couldn't handle it." (NEXT: Those Opposed.) WARNING ORDER IN THE CHANCERY COURT, CH1CKASAWBA DISTRICT, MISSISSIPPI COUNTY, ARKANSAS Everett Dean Waggoner, plaintiff ,„., vs - . No. 17525 Wilma June Waggoner, defendant The defendant, Wilma June TRIAL LAWYER Edward Bennett Williams believes juries must be shir-H^ "extraneous matter" if justice is to be done and trial by jury To continue Waggoner, is hereby warned to appear within thirty days in the court named in the caption hereof and answer the complaint of the plaintiff, Everett Dean Waggoner. . . Dated this 12th day of February, 1968, at 2:00 o'clock P.M.. Ed B. Cook, Atty. Percy A. Wright, Atty. Ad Litem GERALDINE LISTON, Clerk. By Betty Coats, D. C. 2-13, 20, 27 3-5 Quick Quiz Q—Is it true that the hippopotamus sweats blood? A—There is no foundation for this belief. During warm weather, the hippo's skin does secrete a reddish, oily liquid to make the skin more resistant to water. But this secretion is not blood, although it resembles blood in general appearance. Q—Does dew fall from the sky? A—Dew forms; it does not fall from the clouds. It is water eondensH onto object* near the ground. ^ Q —What flower is said to wake the robin's song? J A—This legend is told of the trillium, which is popularly called "wake robin." i For Young Families THE CENTENNIAL POLICY For a 25-year old father, this policy — together with a special income feature — can guarantee enough Initial pro- lection to pay his widow $40,000 over the years! Cosl is only $16.50 a month. CALL ME TODAY: MILES E. LEWIS PHONE PO 2-2504 Metropolitan Life 1 CVSlifiANCE COMPANY Astrological * Forecast * By CARROLL RJGHTER> To determine your toreeast, not. McNaught Synmcat. IM. paragraph opposite dates whlcb ,-, , . . , ,,,.,,,. include vour birth Aa,u Get mlo such outlets thai bring WFDNES1) \Y • VOU " le 8 rcalcst a m ° ll n ' °f GENERAL TENDENCIES: V ^'f' makfe - vo , u ."^ h , a PA line dav and evening to use |)y ' ™, ynl "' fmes ta e " s , ^ Ihe vitaliW and the menial ; vard - Show your cos,est He that quickness released to let those y ™ f™ mdced ^tionale. Be about see that you are on the; ' , ' beam and able'lo forge ahe;:d! VIRGO (Aug. 22 to Sept. 22) swiftly towards the new and thej Bn sllre to P lease kln onc e y°» philosophical ideas lhat are so ;havc finished the duties to vital lo your well being. Gel in i ivhich . you are committed. Make touch with those at a dislance >' 01 "' llollse » lore comfortable. for support. Bo very precise and direct with T SUPPOrl ***.' r* "-*-'••' *• «n« viii^i-i >vn.u AIRES (Mar. 21 io Apr. 19) I an advisor .V°" l™st. Get right You can gel ahead much faster j rcsll " s if you are more alert to ncwi LIBRA (Sept. 23 lo Oct. 22 situations and persons around]A good day for meetings tha you. Study into those new ideas I mean a great deal lo your busi you have lhat could prove lo bej ncss operations, and cement ...... very profitable and practical, belter relations with others Be wise. Contact all (hose with whom TAURUS (Apr. 20 lo May 20)! 5'ou want lo be allied in the '-- ' ' ' '--" '- days ahead. Be clever. SCORPIO (Oct. 23 to Nov. 21) Put through those ethical ideas Plan how to cement better relations with partners asking for what is yours and owning up to what you owe them. Once | thai can add much lo your pres- business is cleared up, devote lent abundance. Listen to what your lime to mate. Have a de-jan expert has to suggest. You lightlul evening together. |will find lhat you will then be GEMINI (May 21 to June 21) able to accomplish more with Ideal day to talk over future operations with associates and how to produce more in the days ahead. Then dine togethe and celebrate. Make this a very worthwhile and profitable day and evening. MOON CHILDREN (June 22 to July 21) With all those duties staring you in the face, you had better get busy with the assistance of talented coworkers. Consult with advisors who can be relied upon, even for small matters. Be active. LEO (July 22 to Aug. 21)| relative ease. SAGITTARIUS (Nov. 22 to Dec. 21) You have wonderful ideas and the ability to carry through with them in a most practical way, so get busy. There are many persons who are anxious to meet you. Do not disappoint (hem; dress in fine style. CAPRICORN (Dec. 22 to Jan. 20) Show that you are a practical person and rid yourself of responsibilities in jig time. Get 'our life operating more salis- actorily in the days ahead. Go lo an expert for the data you have wanted. AQUARIUS (Jan. 21 to Feb. 19) Your gregarious nature needs full expressions so be out early calling on this one and (hal one, especially persons of' prominence. You understand your personal aims precisely now. Take right steps to gain them. PISCES (Feb. 20 to Mar. 20) Show higher-ups that you know and understand their aims and, gain prestige, good will. Much benefit comes from delving into some civic affair. Show others that you have great ability and savoir faire. IF VOUR CHILD IS BORN TODAY ... he, or she, will be one of those fascinating young people to whom everything and everyone is interesting and much success can come from dealing with foreigners, living in other countries, etc. Send lo college, since (here is logical reasoning in this extra ordinary mind. Stress the va ious philosophies. By George • v W iiiiniiiiinHiiiiiniiiiiiiniiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiu What's for Lunch? BLYTHEVILLE WEDNESDAY Chicken Spaghetti Vegetable Salad Milk Hot Rolls GOSNELL Wednesday Irish Stew Crackers June Peas Devil Food Cake Bread Butler Milk LUXORA Wednesday Vegetable Soup with Crackers Toasted Cheese Sandwich Fudge Cako Milk KIIWIIIIIINIIIIIINIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIili Biythevil!e r s Otobing SHOP DOWNTOWN BLYIHEVILLE FOR GREATER SAVINGS EVERYDAY WEDNESDAY'S OUTSTANDING BLYTHEYIUE DOWNTOWN MERCHANTS

What members have found on this page

Get access to Newspapers.com

  • The largest online newspaper archive
  • 8,800+ newspapers from the 1700s–2000s
  • Millions of additional pages added every month

Try it free