New-York Tribune from New York, New York • Page 13

In Wonterful Rally Quakers Smash Way to Victory. OUTCLASSED AT THE START Team Suddcnly Reaches Form and Gair.s Steadily, Winning in Final Minutes. to Th- Trtbane 1 Fhiladelphla, Nov. 9. football team BBderWeat un ordaal of flre ia atectaculai battle artth Mlchlgaa on Franklln thls afternoon aad emciged, though atairrad and batterad, a grba vaetor by a acora of to B.

fred and lnaten I i the early stages, they fought back. Where the ha.l aUppiag thrvugh a pgper llne, aecr ins la 8, they auddenly fooad them Felvea bucklna a defei oc that was as rigid aad inl'exlble a wall of Btebl The tjuahcr backa icame Qollatba, who tote BBd fought down i Bal As the Pennaytt nt, arhola atmoa and when in Marahail, a atrjngi ajoorteri t.i.i.o ofl tha cOBteat wlth a that BMBflt Vlet" IT rald tn exefted th ong that belter-aheltei "Ti to the ci.i Iron lo ci vea I btew. Irj tbl lorta I Istory of nnsyl hai theie been such a i to-day. in a frac iicn oi hojr a had ladl crlmlnate ten'i came to itself and to rleti irrtagton, Mtada, Marahali ami a ad i thay ba lly 1 in thi mon i t.e man, Bghtlag with ualiy of poarbi and purpoaa thut v.is Baarvalli ua As ti played ta uie j. riodi ag dmrt Um Weeteraere, bi Bytvaala could have baatea team ln the la The eleven thal "Hurry i'p" Teot brourl.t to Franklln Pleld waa prol nd aa any Mtchlgan haa v.

were gotug rlght lt ptrong, reaourcaf corablnailoB. i on I piedae ln attack, practl Iro in defeace. Pi tteraon the i i a 'he on whl le i. i ivith Thompaon, the an.l J.mmy Cl of i ralg, of Olymi ic i BM, hfe ol the teuin TlWC ai.d tifl they halted the Pacn haks ta th lr aad win tin.y ahUag tne ball there was Bljghty llttil rtop ll vta after I team had rone lo pU-cea BBd WB -lep by Btap to the unj i thM I a battle of Whaa Patuteon wa obflgad to quit after ai inJL.iy.in a tha oi. Crali TaompaoB tr.ed earry Um bul Um odee agauaal them too mu The gaane v.

mmb than flv i lta Brat ra Penn trled a klckofl to the bafl prao licaUy ta midtitid on tba fhst play. A taf trylng tba Quaker Uae Thompaon i Mereer on his owa B-yatd Uaa, who ia.1 it baoh Bva yarda, pintcd and Ctaig sot the ball OB eVyard Uaa. Hohbag the Wolverlnee to ihe 8a-yard mark. Wheri I BBO i i mi ut tor i toucBdowad batwaen tting taa bail to Pean'a l-yard aaerh ii. four pktyi Huab waBtovar ta a rnaea 11 ly i nci Patureoa'e Lrave the verlnea 1 potota i.tB Bfteea-yaYd run Peaa'a iarK agala tbe (foakara on the clef r.siv un 1 when foi arouaa rad I tar Raebel -nd Tbompa had pleked op four yarda the bafl vaa ClOBB to Bfl'l Thtrnpsor.

W8Bt IhrOUgb centr- foT tn. i ounted the I TI at waa matters ttood at tbe nd of th- rtst parloti it was the aaane in i nd perlOd, Thompson gettlng anoth-: tOUChdOWB after an unlnteiTupteO marc UM Iircl aad le tenn Th, -i. with the score 21 to against them, tbe Quakers began to play, Wlth er.l- tw i minutes to play Mtoda Bl fi'war' paaa to Jourdet from Michlgan's na Jourdet got twenty-iive jarrts ot the play and Penn was Ofl Uie MleblgBB'a goal. Marcar made cne stab at ratterson, but a aaoond t'rlve ln the same spot found an openlng nnd the Quaker captaln rammed fw a MtJCIHlowa. MInds made good by aftkbaj thi gonl from a dlfficult at.P'.e Fight ng deaperately, Pcnn began ItB rgle in the necond half.

After tba kath-r i. Dg for a tlme BXrl II oa tneir own BVyafd lln. etarf-d i Berlea of apeetacular i BBfl and KOt BSHBIllW II yanls. and ajBTTiBl witched off on a I Bd raa for thlrtv rafda, puttlng the ball on hnabagaa'a 33-yard Uaa. Mereer pot an other ynrds.

and a forward pa-s. hBflda to ToUBg, put the ball on Mlobl Kan'a 24-yard llne. A ike paas forma tlon and a llne plunge by Mereer addV fourteen more. On three irMM Mi made seven yards. and then eraahed trrrotigh for a touchdown, from which Mlrds kicVed the aal In the fourth quarter Penn kept drlving bBetugaa baek foot.

Tbompaoa ly punurm from behlnd hls goal Hn Mt rcer Itae, Mereer got two yarda through oeatra, bm a fcrward paaa not tonijletcd. Mii.Ca trled aaother. ahoaJai the ball lrom Maehlgaa'a CO-yard Pne to Jourdet, x.aitlng on thi gVyard mark. Jottrdot cauahl the bal'. ani dodg.

hls way throufch to a louchciowu. that brought taa to 21 io who aad falled to mlaa a alngle al all waa taoked on to tie the acora, but tba angle wa anarp and he intoaed. o.i.y two mlnuBM te iv and hflcbigan atUI aeemed i the ar. oxehangi ol punta alicilgax ball an lu own 30-yard lltl i liy a. a toal lioin was low.

TuompAon a couplo c.f llne ano th purit. d. MacshaU o.t ban un Itae ar.d k. off for the wotvexlne goui One a.an uter ancl itnallv. wHh a char flekl.

daahed acroea for tba de It the most apoC tacu.ar i. of the day, eornp lumt.il 8 goal off the victory anu nui.iiru.ry follow 1 Mich'iian I.eM er.il tackle c.ia ar.Saughton. .1 eft gaard.Qulnn Siinpson.Cantra. Pa.tpn.oa tackle.potitlua Joueml. Rlght end.lian.n i Thompaon 1 'Ji.

Mer Marsbail (jO.il* troin IS) Minn? lUtutlona- Pannsylvaala: ''rmndler for Kelllhar for Wi i Helimao Har Marnhall for Craig. for Mi afli oghton. rh gan Buahnell for Paturaon, for llirton. H. Langfon' Trfnltv.

J. Theoi' c.frri-tosn Mearl llaes frmell, Hwsrthmore. Tlmu of "arloaa? Kifit.i, mhiutaa cach. Nffl in a rout Carlisle Indians Take the Measure of Cadets. THORPE IN EVERY PLAY On Attaek and Defenco He Is in Thick of Banished from Field.

Te'errtp'i to The Trlbune. 1 Weet Point. Xov. The Carlisle Ind? ians. the amoothaat and most powerfnl football tenm that has been seen on Army Flt 1 1 in many a long day, outplayed and ited the Army by the acore of 27 to 6 here thla afternoon.

There was never a rm ment when the Army had even a flght ing chance to win the game. although it BCOred the 11: st touchdown In the aecond quarter Twlce the Army got the ball Ofl by game tlght on lts OWB one yard line, and twice more held unt.l Car Hs-ie trled forward paaaaa over the goal line. re brok. ii Lip. Tha team- were keyed up to the last notch, and the lust for battle found an outbroah in two uafortunate occurrences which Biarred aa otberwlaa well played i tne iirst half Powell, the indian fullbacl waa ln colhslon wlth Herrlck, and wai banished frotn the game and his dtaed twenty aavea yards, one half tht dlotance to the goal line.

That lenaltj Bbaped the way for the only touchi i.vri which the Army acored. On i iff wh.ch o't-m-d tne aecond half re was put off the tlelJ for deliber runnlng acroaa tbe BeM and jump Quyon. The Army Waa penalzed Ifl yarda and waa roundly hli mJ. ptain Jitn Thorpe, the world's great Bthlete, and rated as one of fuotbaii ptayera ta all time. i- tha i ai of tha game.

Hla runnlng itha ball waa a revelatton. Martlng he snot tnrough the Une, ering tacklers to ull s.des (f him. was juet before tarbled or bit that Tborpa dtaptayed his bardaat and more tnan noa lt took half n.ui to drag him to eurth. Not the ba.l was the vulue Borpa to b.s team ahowu, out whea for plungea tatO the line Thvrpa charged in, and rlpplag great holea In tha defeace ba made it poaalbla Ior the other baeka to eraab throagb, Hla aptral punta travelled high and far, and l. had no troubte ln outpunting the mi to Bfti a yarda oa the ex naa Lteet feat, bowever, came Booond haif opeaed.

He on. of Keyes'a pttBBllni klcks. ii and vered lt, and ran zlg tbrougb the entire Army team Ihe goal llne, forty-flve yards dis lant Tbe referea called the ball back. Bl he had not btaWB his whiatle, Bnd that the ball was sc Thorpo'a i mit tit lor naught. Runnlng Tborpa a cleee aecond, how came Arcaea, who tora through the Army Um ahnoal al wlll, and appeared to t.ike apedal dettght Bttpptag by tne Ihuaky Devore lor many yarda ut a Bttp.

Hla keenneaa ta ptektaa his epentaga was ahnost uacaany. Three hard earned tou hdowaa his part ta the battle. Tha ahlfttag, and dazzling at tack ol the Oartlale men had the Cadeta bordertag a panlc. After a few mln i play nonc Of the Army men ad to know Just where the baU waa 10 bad it. The old uhBJ trOBO, with elther Thorpe or Arcasa carrying tn ball from right fonaatloo, worked w.iii clockllke regutartty for long The Indians gave thelr runnerf Inter forcact that haa aaMom booB aaaaHed in any galha ever played here.

and cer vor boob Burpaaaei Fre or Tborpa wouM (or tbe i Bd Wlth five men groupad arotind runnlng ut a apoed that dadad aay i.m. baeka or opea piays-it all nojulfed the aeooadary defenct to t-top the attaek ln most playa. Tne forwai I paaa trted hegeeaUy. jD.it arlth only mdMrereat buccbbb 1 -iia, trk t.i an by toi the ovet goal line. 'out with the Army Becondary defeace lying ta wait fnr just i ch a play.

thd ball bdt the ground. on both orcasions lt was fourth down. and .1 haada Oo three other lona, howi vor, tha agaa game waa worked Bucceaafully. Twaoa Arcaaa took tbe paaa from Weleb for gaad gains. lt rematned lot Thorpe, beweveri ta make the beet catch of the wbear game, and with tha (titlre Aimy bAckfleld waitlng th ball, he kaaped up an.i puHad lt down ror a efaar gata af thirty rarda Tha Army was unable to get thelr 008800 Bway Wltll any BUCCB08 Bf all.

DovON had a mlserable tlmo. AaMe from being banished for his quaB tional a play, Ouyaa, tha ladtao, aat BO bndly 'bat DOWOIU never i a chaaee. After a acorokaa first partod, the cadets mai thelr only chaaea to do anything, by the of Keycs made the 80800. The indlana look Devore'a poor kick-off on tho line and. after a BOrtaB of plays in which both Bldaa had the ball, Thorp-J bmka looea for twenty-ntna yards, and a line smashing attaek bronght lt? down to twe-yard llne, where Berele adnped ror touchdown Thorpe klcked the Boored twic.

in ihe talrd rourth quarter Coffln trled tffnunt out from behlnd hla own goal. bul hehall Mi tne goal poeta and the tadjane tork the ball oo tbe IS-yerd line. wheaea ln fOUT plays. lino-up fOlsOWS: kaeOT). Rawley Jonea pun.r i t.

Devora V.uIiu' J.r Powell touchd. v.i.s Thorpa, -t i Powell: Bergle for rm. kar; mi ft? Oarlow; Jartow for Ble Hueal foi Herrlck; dlleaple for ro. Hobbai rl for Jonea; llegs foi (JiUenpie. Carabee; WUIlama for wtema.

Bn Keyei Befaree Judga aWaoa, .1,, nr lt .1 Mr. Tylrr. ITln. eton. Ttme of I pcrtods of llfteen nilnutee CRESCENTS MEEJ DEFEAT Belmont Cricket Olub Wins in One-Sided Soccer Game.

The CreseentB and the Belmont Cricket Club, of Phlladelphla, met ln a aoeeer mateh yetnerday ln whlch the latter, hcld era of tha Cuscent Chatlenge Cup. won hundily by a score of 5 goalB to 0. in Jurles recelved ln the games wlth Yale t.nd BUma Mand had aerved temporarily to McCUIland. O. JefferB and Jack aaa, al the Cneeenl toam.

Tho Phiia delphaane aen at the top ot thelr form. Tho play of Bottomley. centre forward in tho helmont llne-up. waa thejaaaaUon cf the afternoon, and he acored no leaa an f( ur of the five pointa. i Tne Une-up followa; JIM TIIORPE (x), OF CAKLISLE, TBYING TO PENETRATE WEST POINT CENTRE.

IfflS IN CHILD'S PlAY Toy with New York University in Farcical Contest. ATTACK GETS NO TEST Princetonians Play Good and Bad Ball in for Pendlcton. TaaagrapB to Tritiun- Prlacatoa, n. BToe. foot? ball which raagad from the achool type to chnmplonship Quallty, PrlBcaton BflOWed New York I'nlv.

rslty under hero to-day by tbe score of to 0. The Tlg-rs had thlnga all thelr own way from atart to flnlsh. but at tlm-s BBOWed a BUTBrla ingly weak BttBOk and -eneral of play. "Hobey" R.ker, De Wltl an.i 8B Ular were the hrlKhr sturs of th- aft BOOB arid tore through the vlvtors' llne aa lf lt bad been made of papcr. Captaln PaBdlatoo waa not in to-daya llne-up and enjoyed a eompiete rest.

Thls ia the flrat game th.it "Tol" lo start In alnce he BBtered OOllege, ta Ix.gan waa another of the veterans had a day off, and H. WaBai araa Ii At lr-ws's ploco at left BBd. playad rlgbt aad, and he plagad it bo perfeetlea, He waa ta avarj play aad down tba Bald uader kleka UghUUag lf hlB knee botbared hlm any eouM not be seen UM Uflea Tr- luafi Was BflOthei llvely Ipptl ahowad whai he could do at rlght fOI a whlle, WhOB PeBfleld Wlthdl At the osaalag af tha yaaae Prtocatoa'i game ahowed at lta WOTBt 1 aa rhangf af ar.d aevi i att-mpls at llne piunglng. "Hol a) I U1 .1 a drop fr.mi Um but the ball waat wlde ol tba i KlaaUy WaBar aucoaadod ln ama throagb tackle tbe Brat hard ean I touoadowa, Aft- lta -t Um Tlgei got and rolled up two dowaa before th- auai andi Faker aad dld bmbi ol of Um epoi.elhie foi a tahy fork'a only chance to BOOI in the aaooad pertod, when um rtaltora h.jld the ball ln PrtacatOO'a terrltory. Kmlth dropped back for a try al but his klck wilh burrlad and went the left "Stew' F.aker gave tbe attacb a UMTOttgh Kout ln thla I BpUl double BBaBM and i ut lariy BueoaaBful auaiterbaeh run an md BBd were uaed.

DeWitt, araoaa ajataa throagb the line (an- aaay aa-day, waa lesponsibic for prtocaton'8 fourth score. Waller got loaaa 'or an algbty-yard run for down and II liakcr folgBWed thla up with a Bfty-yard daah tttfougb a bioban fleid. brtogtog tba Tbpara arltbta atiiking dlatar.tc agala The flrnt half aaded with the Prlaoaton 10, Haw York Fnlverslty 0. fn the second half New York Fnlverslty came back rlearly weakcr, ind It wua merely a rjueatlon of how blg a BBBfa Prtoeatea should elect to run up. 11.

Waller played a fast, hea.lv game at left end In thla perlod. Karlo arltb hla conslatent llne plunglng, added BttU another tou.hdown to eredlt befora the thlrd miarter The i I to be taklng thlngs easy In UM Iatter part or the onenlded QOBtaat BBd Werr pont.iit wlth final fally hy "Hnhfj" Dabar. brlnglng the totnl to aigbl tOUCB downs. Aa a contest In prcp.iration for satur.iay'a battle with Yale, the game was decldedly dlsappolntlna. New York's defence was too weak to give Frlnceton's nttack a real t-st.

f'ti the defence, wlth the exreptlon of the erxls, the Tlgera' seetned to ba loafing There was no need for them to Hhow DBBOh epeadj and they Bttj were slow ln charging and caieaBBj 81 tackllng. A week af practi.e will do lot for the team, but tt will have to be Btrenuous week to whip them Into i haui ploaablp form. The llne-up followa: Prlnceton (64). Poaltlon N. Y.

(0) E.Dut.htr Ballln T. Wl. i. Bhaak TVi Swarl .11. V.

IVnflald T. York Wurbt K. Kapiin H. iwker Iluntl-y tl f.aker H. B.

Wallar H. frutth De Wltl Waller i5). H. Jink. iDj, De Wltt.

Ooals from relowns-- Bakal (0) Hul.stltutlona: 1'rlnceton foi I swart for Uluethcnthai, Tn nk nuin for PenflnM, lor BT, Hak- Trenkman for Wltt. New for Kai-lln McCay for VeaMry, Haldh- ror Ttioan H. ('ostelio. Umi lr? Bf Murphy, Brown Hm.l UMMBBan T. Kht.y, Oeeraetowa.

Time---ivri(Kis of aala utrs each. TIGERS' RUNNERS VICTORS Columbia Team Humbled in An? nual 'Oroes-Country Run. Telegraph to Tha Tribune. 1 Prlncaton. N.

Nov. took Columbia into camp here to-day ln a 'croBB-eountry run by the acore of 22 to 4.1. The Blue and White runnera eam- down fr, jui.aletown confldrnt of victory. but the work of Htlckney, W. Doty anS Cap tHin 8 Beil, who aacured second.

thlrd und fourth places raapaoUvaly, proved tor, much for the vlsltor-. iteichard of Columbia. captured flrat r.lace to the tlme of 36 minutes 3 aeeond-c Ivifh a atrong northweat wlnd blowtag the runners ln the laat two mllea of the race. thls waa consldered falrl) cOOdtlBM. The courae meaaures about vardf over six mlb-fl.

Ti.e nen to flnlah ta Mfth. Blxth. aev elghth and nlnth places. rearxcUve fy Evana. Columbia; M.

Brown, Prtaeateo C. Street. "-IMnceton- D. Oyod Jrln? PrlBcetoa. and B.

Colby, dolumbia. I College and School Football Games Yalc's scorlng maehlne BhOWOd thnt lt was sttll for Irom being at top Bpeod, for while tbe Blue defeated Brown, tt waa bj tha all too narrow margin Of points. With many of the tlrst strintr men out of game. Harvard BtrOggtad through to a ftetory over Vand. tb.lt but Nat-h viiie lads dtsplayed plenty of nght Tha vTeet Potat Cadeta trled in vata to drive the ladlaaa from Corllala back an tho reeorvatlon, and aren scalped in most b-PIOOBIVI BtyaB by Olea Warm r's men.

Cornell waa Bubjected to dofeat agaln, this time by Dartmouth, whftl Prtncoton Bmothered tho Hoe Tork etevea. i I superior hrand of the gfaBt game. BOOOd OUt in a frei -for-all scor Ing bea ta I'tuiadciphiu. The aaotoorlc carcer of ahvaxahaon by Lahlgh. arlUle Marrland Arsde 7 .0 0 3 I .47 Bt UBBIi 7 liantnoiith he iXu Nerthweeterfl PrtiMetnii Uronsln ArfcanaBB 7 Peanaylraala 17? MBrBlgaa ohi.i 7 vtiMUmn 7 gaayea 0 I 0 Hrraruae 7 Keafekr Bteta.

..81 llaawrw 0 A-' -HanTford 0 perOWa a (iniiinm Mtehlgu Inion.20 I Mrjtinla 18? rrirtaaiar De paew.21?ito?e Potj. 0 "Pelr" si 11001. I- -vilT' 7 Mnn.il Tralnlna VUtt Ulnton "IVrVrtown. femaaeree lt? Bteyriaaaa Ji.i, 0 llunlnvlrk 0 i.rL 0 tdelphl High. UI 0 0 Taft J-Ot, 8 aad Mar.

I PaohakUl 8 Mnhleeaarg.bbBIbI-i inammri Fmdham Prep .11 V.ur.,..*" MorrMeWU 1 'fw -MlddlrlHirr (1 ful.i Pnneelim tib? 9 ,1,,, sa HlddleHary "lV.n, Pely Hanard Irad 7 Ire td Exeter Defeateci by Fast End Runs in Qridiroti Battle. Aadov 1 aa I Aj foot? ball battk I came Aadovei a Ua lt waa a preay iaa uiai feai irea, eaoej 1 al Umbi wi a i od of the ardb ury, gaa won the a jj Tn. ra waa a phm lld forw I Baekto, raa Bftoan I aeroaa Thh waa tba aalj i on ol ui II i appaaad la tba I Boothel I Um baat puater aa I Baa breaki i hy i kbrl ofl aad raa Itwaaty raim Tbta was tbe aaat 11 rj lag Bm baU bl Baeti durlag tl v.i.,.1 aaaa. Qalgb fui tarrtbly, however, and hu value to tha toam i al tala am Taa Aadovar baelrJIeld waa l'eht. Bad tha Bxi haavy.

The Bxeter de aai. bul BBTaaoa a ia abaotatol) i ia. kIbi i in offen Aadovei raa laed Ui lta Ughl Ibackfldd agalral latatar'a haavy Baa prevall aad trled nlne Umaa for Igaala from tbe Bald. Maaa waa aaecaaa Ti.e aada oa beth Maaaa were fast. Itarray, BartrJa, CMruld aad craaereh, who aaeeaeded bha, ptayed arafl foi andawer, and Oasey atarrai for aanaaw, Thi Bae-ap faUowa i i Baldrtdae.m,:li' Bad iotfil.uk Ca I fi iiBlfharh Blngham Rjghl Halfbai k.

Kellej Qatglae Kewi ddrldae. dle MTbmpam Oould foi ll111 seal for Boltoa, Churcta llock for Caaey. NVlBt of ivln. l.lnt.-Miiiun Ol.X -1 wi TAFT ELEVEN VICTORIOUS Defeats St. Paul's by One Point on Garden City Gridiron.

The Tafl School elevetl, af W'atcrtown, won Btabbornly oaotaatad victory ov.r tbe St. Paul's School, of (larden city. on tbe tottar'a fi.id. yeaterday, by a of 7 to The New BBgtaad team waa surprlsed by ihe Btrangth of Um Ht. PaulB etaven, which outplayed II ta the ftaal pertod.

Tafl broughl Into cxccution the Phlft and although lt PTOVOd v.iluable nt HreCflt Paul'a Bnally atoppad Um play. Tba ltoa-up faUowa: St Psul's Tafl (T) Mitebeil.I- rtani11 WoOdbUTB o. gelrl SSrr T. fayr I. Taft 3 i.nw,r H.

H.Mw.atf Tuuchilowns -I'owrr. M'tslf Oaata fro-n ThefPe, Im. -Klle HstK-r, uluinl.ta of pi rteda Ten BtoMtol TALENT FOR S0CIAL8. A liat of high claea entertainera will be found on the muaicaJ page. thls I Victor by CIcso Margin Over Fast Wesleyan Team.

i i I thla pi to Wtat) ondltlona wi qtu al fumbllng onlj Pj mtama obtataed i tlrst period iirrd WOB tlM id goal in tha laat ajuarb r. ama back aitb Bplaadld Bght Ing r.plnt and I I tOUChdOWfl dUTtag tha laat two 8 I was tha taam of the two, bul ta tment of forward tl purple waa terced to yteM tha i BxhlMtion bj men bt th. moat erltlcal contaai of the m.ii. wns j- itlafqactory. acored at the opening of the bewll i Bt of the Micha.

i kh ked ofl fo: tha purpti land Keti.it; returned tha ball to the mark. ofoaleyaa famblod the ond play and Turner rebovered for "'IMIatns. LeWt8 08 the aecond play BBOt through right ta. kh for a touchdown after cieverty aiiiiaailiig his way through a 1..:, an I avading several tacklera baal ki.k. .1 tha gooi tha bagtanlng of the last quarter imilama apeaad aa invincibie attaek Turaer and Laaia aatda down after tirst down, but vreatoyafl beM aa the il i.

ir.ruk and tOOObdOUm WOa UBPOBH abta afsohoel dropped back and. with Ihe HQBlBtanOa Ol put the bnH sqiiaielv between tht posis from the yard llne for the fln.tl score. aroaleyaa raiaa back stmng. B-icon. by "kllful dlreetloa 8f the forward BBBB, Btaoad the ball on the 7-yard llne bofon tha onalaught of the red and black waa tereed to halt by the vymtama bi b.

The purple arot the ball and Btartod raah it back, bul Huanawatl rumbled and Weslev nrain BBOd the forward BBM effectlvely. it took only aevea playa for to go tMrty-flva yards fox a toueh lown Bacoa took the ball over and klcked 'he gool Tba llne-up followa i PealUoa. WOstayea vir.ii Nourai T. Glllle Young Hewtetl Korpby Mlehael.B.O..... Bernhard Watker T.

Eustta Lawta Baooa Teolaa lirls.oll.H. H. U. Petumu Turner B. Kenar Touchdowna Baeaa.

ooais from MI li Buatla. Ooal froan 11 Mii'tiBei Refarea Andrewa, of Vala Cbb ptra Laiwa, af Dartmouth. Read Cook, of Vlrglnla. SmI stituten- F0r Wtlllama; Hunnawell fnr PrUrnli. perry for Young.

Pot IWrndorf for Kustts, Wllcox foi niiiies. Dralaard for Nquraa, Baah for Peti Time Of perlods- -Twolve nilnutt-s. COLUMBIA WINS AT SOCCER Cuts Down Lead of Tiger Five by Strong Team Work, gy Taaagraaoi tn rhe Princeton. N. Nov.

Columhla'a socoer teum dOfBBtod Princeton here to day by the score of 4 to 1. The Tlgers held the lead ln the llrnt half. but the vlaltors came back atrong bj the last period, oarrytBg everythlng before them. The llne-up followa: CotnaU)ta(4). Paatttea, rnnceton Ki ifal Bpencar halfhaok.Roberi l.aauardu.Left half bank.Uarvlr Hamilton.Hight half.Wlaaati Kvatis.Cntre half.I.loytl Uaft half.I.L.yil outstde.

Soyll Kuhn itislda.Htewarl hhauhnlt.I.eft Inslde.M< tmi i i ii.i.Cf ntra gollef nutslda.Hc. 1, Bhauhelt. ihn, C.iluuloun. I. t'mplre? Huoah, of Phltadal BhU.

Time of mlnutea. Finds Stuyvesant No Match on the Gridiron. SCORES IN EVERY PERIOD Hagemeyer, Brown and Freer Cross Line for Touchdowns Kicks Field Goal. The TTtrh BOhOOl of ComBMTee won ns pIbbbbiI from Btuyvaaaat niffh. sehoors football team in a oaa atded pame at Ami rteaa igue Parb yaata I iy oa The acora waa -i ta a.

the K'ant rlght halfhu-k. WB8 a Hb a aebal tutata imeree atbv a Bad to tomed vtgar. v-v-r. when to atrlka a talUng bhrw, aad they have yet to srore iowb on a Gemmerca Tbe tatarmtaalon betwaea the first and lOCfH red by a 1'vely I in whic'. aavaral i.nts arare br'ken, the City to raatora order.

This dtverrloo i Btuyveaant -I leadlag a tba ajrldtroa Cemmarce tied to Ha mrter, the I araa and a neat -yard llne hy Hou I rd In the flrat pertod the hno ir ti Bl two ta waj ov-r to tho h'1 U. i ko Brawa. IfcOull MrOsker I' n.KMcnardt rtwr I BV. All I UromeTV, (Te Kanaervck; Rattaar for Da Boer, Tamra tor Dlcklci ralB 'o UBaamBB Dai toraMa rhna ot gama aUnataa aaeh, TIGER AND YALEjWBS TIE Both Teams Kick Goals from the Field in Fast Game. bj arapa te Tas 1 rll baa PrtoOOtOB, J.t Nov.

PYlnceton aad Tala euba battled aat to a tta to football here- to-day. It WBa fBBt h-ird gaaaa from atart te Balahi with the Ttajara dototj moat af 'he forclng tbroagbout the conte-t Penaltlea aad ooaUy faaabtea praveated from aoortag in the llrst half, when they cl. outplayed tho vtottons. in the thlrd quarter a Baal reoavery.ef a fumble by Ullok and a BVyard dash by Bhea earrtad PMaaatoa within Idlataaoa Law then droppai hack. and, BtaadlBg on th" lS-yard hne, kkked the hall aquarely between the posts.

Yale'B came ln the flnal BettoB. Heynlger klcked out of DOUada ut hls own bVyBfBj line. BBd the BU 8flba were lif toaa yarda for hotaaas, Tala'a rbaanaa for aoortag looked nooe too bright. on the last down Cu-rnsey trled a desperate drop kick which ealled thlrty-tlve yard 4 through UM fOT 80088. The Prln i toa fraahmen attaok was su 1 p.rlor b) tbal of thelr opponents, but Ith ta Um BVyard aaaa ihey toekad the Baal punch.

ln the Hne Hoynlger, at left guard for Prlnc.eton, was-consplcuoua for hia BtrOBg defensive play. Uw. ln the Naaaau back Babt, and Qenaanaf, tbe Yak cub fuUbaek, both ebaarai briuiancy carrytog tba ball. I.lne-up and smmmary: FTta-JtoaW. Taeljla.Cooroy ll.ynitl'-r.Left ay RKht TBChle.Hurnett t'W) Halfbuck.l.'owlas Haltback.

Kullback.Ouernsey QUIeepla for Payne; Hli, a for 1 llW Bheaj I.ov. for BWi ftl.ldl" for l.ova. for KohVrli Uoals fron. field -Prlneeton. I.aw, yui, l.

iiftlclals: L'mplre? (BrowB). Refaree, CoateUo (Cor i.i.i.i.:tiiiii?Ktrby (QeBTgttewa). Tlme of aalvaa 11 minutes. a STUDENTS VOICE PROTEST New Manapement of Team Turns to a Olosed Corporation. A stortn of protest from Columbia stu dentB arose yesterday agalnat the actlon of the Btudeal board of repreaentatlves ln taklng the el-ctlon of athletlc man.iK-rs out of the baada of the students and put tlng lt ln charge of a speclal commlttee of manageia.

Although tlie atudent board acted dellberately on the matter, they kept trtelr dlBcusalona a aecret and the aunouncement camo aa a great aurprnce. m'm wi Bows Before Manual's Brilliant Forward Passing. DINGWALL'S WINNING GOAL Makes a Drop Kick in Final Period That Gives Victory to Brooklyn 3oys. Harmon proved hims.clf the uucromanadr of the forward pass and his BOVCefJ abled Manual Tralnlng's football eleven to emerge the victor ln the confllct with De aJlttClinton a i 15 to 13 ta a game piuyed at Daatem I'ark. Brooklyn.

The kalfbai BrBI tb8 here of the battle, for his team a greati part Of tiie time proved r-IUKgariis. The entire atieagth of Maaual'a aaaha lay In tli. phi mnienal passing curried on i.y her baok BeM, In which Harmep loomed above Hali, Tapolow and the ag groaaiva quarterback, Zoitz. At puntihg Dingwall, the captain of the Kold arwl blue, ptoved a host in himself. Boveral tlmes whOB CUatoa'a line beM iike a rock Dtagwall punttd slxty and stxty-flve yarda In rentattiwl faahlon.

For Cllnton, tha fullback, bona tho brunt of the punting. But his boot lng was not to be compared wlth the p'T foramaeaa aa Maaual'a bMO aoa did Haaren or Captali MOOCO ever approach Dtngwall'a kmgth and certalnty of nim. Cllnton played fast, atraight football tn a manr.er that taft little to be desired. The line never broke and hurled back Manu.il time an 1 again when lt WB8 on the point of scorlng. The Cllnton's tack ling was keen and aggresslve and th? pbayera went with naarrlag instinct after the ball.

Manual was so weak ln re Bpeet that its tackling was not to 80 corrv parai wtth fltntew't atill somewhero ln lts mechanism ton lacked the dccisive punch. It waa the inltlal dofOBt for the of tne red and Llack, and lt probably ellminated the team from the race for the lntersohol a.stlc championslilp honors, ln Wbleb Man? ual takes the leading only the High School Of C'ommerce between it and an uncloudtd title. Tbe cohorts of Manual had rallied fnr the match and the blg Btand BM waU half fllled with v.earers of gold and blua ItrtanttTt. Only I handful of Cllnton's followers BOOUBOed a corner of the stand and they made wheezy effort at tng Bnd BOBg. As lt was the flrst defeat for Cllnton there was a hush ut the end" tbat spoke of the agony of partisan s.irlr jin having victory enatchcl away at last moment.

CllatOB klcked off. Harmon the ball and bafng tOWBed ln his trackn by the 'juick Bsovtag advance of niack and Red. Right there Manual found that lt could do nothing agalnst Cllnton's lino. After three downa HarnaoB naled. anrt on a fumble by CUntOB got the ball.

Thtn Eetta seut a forward pam Boattag on I i on, who after twletlag throui Cllnton fcrj tha ball, fi I BB I front of the Cltnton goaL Manual maw? to push Cllntoa back a rai Harmon to 80808 the Brat I 00 i tha r.ext mlnutea v.c IrJck-off. Dingwall Bakaaai I the ai. Durtag tha balaaco of I trtor Cllnton. witn Moore, Marpky perately, i I the btaaual I raa as the quartor I Bglnnlng of Bd Lng F. M.c the 1 up tbi Bae, ard Bllly Moori I through for I'ig ta two aa i he had tne ball over t.

klcked tha Than Murpl Btada nd ook ottah, tyed and paaam BO had Ifaaual raiizcd, so that lit.ton ra down tbe BeM ahaool aa it pteaeed, phy scorlng the toUCbdsTWn. iloote mi'sod Ute goal. Cllnton Btarted ta ta dO it all ovec again, and was aaagreaatng woD when Chiiatgaa fambaad, and btc tarry dropp i on tha ball for Manual. It was costly tot CUatoa, for Eott8 and Harmon atartcd forward paaatng that carried the ball right up to Cllnton's lln and TapotoO) 1 lt over on a dOaBTod pass. Tuta Waa one of ttie best ults of work Matiual BVed, for lt was BSBCtty from the centre of the BOld to the touch? down.

Agaln Dingwall m.aaed the goal Muephy'a end ruaa, along Wlth Daa bucka by Bllly Ifoore, were niatched the passing of QoMborg, who had replaoad Zeitz, aad Hanaoa. work in this quarter, nelther team BUOOOOded lri BOorlng Zeitz went in Bgala as gunrtarbaab aa the Bnad period. Cllnton bad the ball for tlie flrst tlve llBUt? Bd ihieeieiiiMi Muiiual'a goal again. Huiiuoii na.led a punt from Wachar, und Zeiu Baartod the paaamg. man spoiied the Brat one.

but Manual to the hali. On a fuke crosa baok, Hall, Manuai's left halfback, cirrosd the U-uther to Clmton'a 6-yard line direotly before the thu. next play Dingwall droppud baok aad kaekad the BeM goaL After that MaaueJ deVOtOd itself to holding Cllnton for the (ow reaaalnlng Babaataa ot tne ga The llBB OP followa; Muriuai (U5). Pesi uon. W.

Clinmn Beeaau K. young PariMtU o.F. i-. Moara Hnai.iU Dingwall U. obU Miiiarry T.

CbrlatcaM guin.i a. Tliiotaea H. Uurphy Itull H. H. BeseruaB lliiliijon H.

H.W Slwirj repoiow b. I uletltutlona? Goldborg fur Zeitz, ior Palmer for Tapolow, foi BWrg. Ti.u.;liJowt.? fnr MjuiuhI Tralruns--Uy Karn.on and Tapolow. Toucndowna for Do Wirt ('iiMioii Hv W. Moore Muiphv.

Goala from touchdowns tor Manual Tralnlng, Ooala from tovchdowna for De cllnton- Ity tlaaren. Ooala from Beld foi Manual Tralnlr.g?Hy Dingwall. Goals frora fleld for Ite W'm cllnton, aont Referea -Dr; Way, of I'mpire-Parrler, Dartmouth. Head BhsallatynsV and Formoea a CHANCE $20,000 Will Not Qo to Reds Till He Gets Money from Murphy. Loa AngeleB, Nov.

wlll not stl'r from my ranch ln Glendora until I ara pald 130,000 tash," Krank ChaBOa BV clalmed to-day whcn told of the deal whereby he had been tranaferred to CkOJ clnnjtl by Charley Murphy, of the Chl cago Natlonal club. "That blt about Oarry Herrmann pay ing tor me ls all boah. Murphy got myrh more than tltat, and I want before 1 go to the Clnclnnatl Reds," he added. (Sjaaoa declarcd Murphy had ated Joe Tlnker ahabbily. "Tinker Is one oi the best ball playera llvtng," he aald, "and he ought to have hla chanca.

phy did not give lt to him.".