The New York Times from New York, New York • Page 31

I SPORTING SECTION. i SPORTING SECTION. i i i i i dpJQJJERS TXNDAY. OCTOBER 22. 1911.

WEST POINT YALE AGAIN IN FOOTBALL BATTLE -V I r' itX mm hi. mm i. i in rurt ittmtn-y mi i -au-E. JT vssstisSv 1 i 1 oartwG civ; nruz ir. i I 1 1 i r.

I t'-W--- -Jl Ili11 'I'll 'Ir. iip Vsl ill! I 1 "ill II ifiv Ml lilU'l liiiiiii ii I ii ,1 In i 1. liilill- Hill k--, -K-czy, 1 1 1 II i li II i ryy I i-Vf -J I' iL ttSf1' VA An ff f-: -t i 1 r-i 1 ZLA. Er POINT PLOWS THROtGH MUD ANLX TVATBR 70 raCTOR Yale Humbled' Soon After Came Starts by a Touchdown and Coal Scored by Full Back Dean Field Covered with Wtfter. Sfnial la The AYar York WEST roiNT.

Oct. tnc Har-tard and Ya! fought thelrf memorable battle In the rain and In the mud at fcew HTn In 11S. have twcj been called on to rush and boot a football ever auch a fit-Id that on wtiich Yale nil th Armv nlaVK1 n-An The gridiron, with its death of mud. and ita acorea uf little lakea was not Tim. big elevens Yale Ka fray to-duy to pet a Jine on (the New Jtavcu eiiren lor tta jramt-a agamsi arid Harvard came away a l''-v bi' the nfkjY itim Yale iiiu look ndsMy trim when It! cams pa in ik-iu.

au uiinriK jti.c Kijn? ithore imii loose jl.iyirtr It ar- pvared to thi rather than the effort of j. team tryinir to ido aoriie-thing it iiirt not know how to Uo as was the case With the Yule teamj at Vtot I'oint lait Wear. Wt I'ofafB early aresstvene3a swept off ltk fret. Alniont within minpte from the itlme the ball was klckad Off Dean plat-wl a low kick over the rilnh line, and llerritt of Yale, misjiidglns the ball. Hog)iof the Army's right- end se- ourfd It.

I "is was within 44 yards of the Thl al.Tiar ell; n1 another kick forced Yale fairly well; back. Yale punted at once, but the forward. chanced into Spalding before lie could set the ball away. I Thd kirk! waa hlnoVu VTiiafnn tVi A I Army miaru. and In another Instant the cadets' side line, while across the field In the second period Hyatt galloped along for nearly forty yards, two Yale ends, a tackle and a back, getting their hands on him but falling to bring him down.

Spalding's chase of Gillevpie was the nervtvracker of the day, the race bringing the Yale men as welt as the cadets to their feet. As an incident it was very similar to Charley Brewer's chase of Suter of Prinoeton in the last game that the Tigers and Harvard played at Nas-rau a race In which no other players took part, and one that ended with a df-perate tackle almost at the goal line. The summary: West Point. i Positions. Ollk-spee.

Howley. enJ yore Arnold Weyalid. Hogej. Centre Tale. Vrancl Scully.

Lor Ketcham Paul. P'rry. Wa rrea Avery. W. Rlcht Howe.

Uallauer. nainon Hi-att. Quarter back Merrtit Ufn-lict. Left half back. Dronbe Deaa, Mo Donald half.

back. Andenton Full back Tiuchi1oti Dvan. from touchdown- Dean: Refrea -U. I Fults. Brown.

mplr I'i B. Williams. VntveniUr of Pennsylvania. Flejd Jude J. tn, Williams.

Linesman F4 A. Glllender. University of Pennnylvania-Tlmer-Four twelve-minute periods. 1 Xl: OEVTTT I Urmy agreeil sorry a ull though, the nail Watt In thn atm nf fiihArt mnlMI wnat Dotnered laie. to-aay.

nowcvcr, tor rusb. Tale had other troubles. Within three of he atait of the game, the Army had recovered one kick, punted again, blocked Yjale's return, and had pounded Us way qver twenty-lire jards of mud for the fiHt touchdown that has been made agaliifet the New Haven team this Fall. The toueiidowu I and the gfal that followed gave tha West Pointers si points and tor tlie refraining, forty-five militate of play Yale, was unable to even tie the. game.

Yale Insisted on playing tlie game this The Army coach (was anxious that tho game should be called off. localise he ft a red for his players on such a slippery Yale, however, could Hot remain at the Point uatll Monday. and waa anxious not to loie the YVext rowA. date. Accordingly thn to play and to-night Is noli ui it aio.

As game of football Snatch between Yale and thie Army was toot very much. Some will jiay that the eadets were better able to kep their feet an were the 1 ale. men. 'because thy anew what the conditions the fieid oum be an, accArdtngly had tremendous yises on their shoes: but lv any event, DARTMOUTH EASY VICTOR. It iwaa then first down for the Army on Yale's l-J-yard line, The shift: was brought rnto splendid execution at: once.

On one play Benedict swept through Yale's right wing for h. iZl was an eaSy victor over William, to-day. on the shnrt side of. the rush line whilajthe final score standing 3 to 5. The laies forwards were all tledlup trying visitors su-ored thnlr nnl v.

touchdown In Williams Crosses Hanover Goal Line, First Time In Eight HANOVER. N. Dartmouth to bolster the boles that were being ripped open on the other side. i In thla short series of plays West Point presented an attack that was better than anything tYale had all the Yale's Interference was well formed when It but was- easily broken. The team did not make a first down distance from scrimmage In the entire game, while the Armyjiln the second lialf invaded the Yale side 'of the field for more than yartlK, and finally tried for a field foil.

Only once in the game did jYale come any wherejj near scoring on West Point. This wasiiln the second perlort. when a short kick wont to JJ trrlt on the ArmVs -Wyarrt line. Two plays gaified hardly thive yards, and then Yale lr a field 'goat! Spalding ami Mrrjtt Were bark. buj when tlie kick gdt away i nlockei oy Arnold of the jArmy.

who drove thci hall back on the bonnd toWrt the Yale toal. tiillesnle an end. wis hot after the jball and picked It Up .1 There waa ho one near him. and a totieh- and stumble.r In the mud soj often that he was ove rtaken by SpaldlnR.j who threw tne Arm runner only when the bna4 eriod. ball bad beenv carried to the thirty-yard line by successive then followed an offside kick, and the ball was eaiillv carried over the goal line by Ualy.

In the third period "Vfllr iams tried a' place kick, but failed. Dartmouth made a sensational goal In the third and' final periods when the ball fwas carried by continual rushes front thd ten- aid line down to within a short uistancti of Williams's goal In the third and went across on the first playi.tt the opening of the final period. Rloe's touchdown wis the first touch-Jow scored bv Wiihams on the local field, In eight years The line-up: fartmouth. Paiyt Klcki ntJmon Rennett Rndthorn. reacnea point two yaraa iram tne aie acit into the shadow of itai goal mil line Thj nlav tdni i.a.

mA missing a tw toucnuown, beautiful; smothered by Yale, but toi vor hadsbeen holding-where. after th.e SPTua fifteen yards' penalty. Dean jtrled fir a Point tnlaeued. a.d the West. roaly but th.

klck was Rooked.) In th. iT. n'" inverting thtrl period the. Army Mad another ,1 i wl 5 it. I mvr willing to the -YiU hvi had lta hMt ruah llnA In Ter.

nd tQ cJimH k.h aitirnool VuhluR pt itiere was or let-up in the rainj HOWe was not In the ln-un. all alx.ut the field the mild was Inched haV'don much better should Hundreds of young women, in na dnf I adequate nasus clad for auca a stormy! The New Haven ends were very uncer-at all i fternoon on the rain-soaked i ''n dwn the field, mlsaing. Dean ifend bleachers Jid likeU It. After the teatnl onrmore than half thelclcks. West nmis tiieic inree of Morey lo.lly Substitutes: tn the minutes 1 jook a or a lust-lungd cadet; tell which player wa which." but Je game was full of corned v.

even if Jne was of a oualiiv suitable for tie conditions under which the game wa4 rlay-d. i Two teams could 'not have planned a am more similar than Yale and the Army to-iiv. Poth team used jortn of the Minnesota shift tit tho ati "'a. ar.d exce-t for a fak or two. iih.

eise. Also eacn kh-ked the bait tirut punla. while lVan got r.at in SAtting Wwy with 1 drivfs that bothered Yl "'y-. anu piaytnp; It cleverly tho WeM "ointt.rs were much keener than their Yales Ki -kes ofteu drove bail down the field farther. The frmJr conatantly blocke.1 the kicks, anj own backs were punting the interior down-the-field work ti-wT nds served to beat Yale at the ami'' Stn wa S1 tne ruahinf Taa YaJe man who went! to the Acad- tliem against six men tried for Yale, muwi iimitr in me open iteia play The A in tact, appeared a teani that hadfbeen brought up this game to tiellverS Just such a punth.

as it r.iowcd It. could lif It. when there camej the chance to make path to the Yale goal line. West IT-Inf -was much morn standing out as the tiact. oC the game.

There was some-splendid kicking KreemanjSof Yale drove out isome beau- away some ile just as Y'ale'st de-very loose. wlthia an wo of them Position. Williams. I-ff end Vlnal Left tackle Hewitt Lft puard Prlndle Onire i. Under Rlaht guard Right tactile Walker Rishl en.l Rice Quarterback Ift half back Rirh' halfback Fullback Dartmouth Farnum for Whlt- more, Whltmore for tflbson.

Esteo for nennett. Maraeaon ana Hivm for Dana. McCullourh for Hoban. Wllliama Krlle for Fixh. Lewis for Chamberlain, Touchdowns Rarends.

3. Daly. Rlrtj Goals from touchdowns Englehorn, S. fmplre Mr. Andrews of Tale.

Referee Mr. Tufts of Known. Field Judge Mr. of Exeisr. Head 4inesman Mr.

McOrath of Boston College. Time Four twelve-minute periods. Colby Defeats Bates," 14 to 0. LBTWISTON. Oct- 21.

Colby defeated Bates, 1 to 0. to-uay' In a drlxsltng rain. In tha first period Fraser drop-kicked a goal from the 25-yard In th second Bates lost the bail at the 40-wrd Hoe and. Oood earned It over, for a touchdown. Fraser made a touchdown; in tte lat erlod.

Vermont Easy for Nlalne. OKOXO. Oct. 21,1 Contrary to expectations: I'ntverslt of Maine won' easily from of Vtrmont -to-day. II BROWN OUTCLASSES PENNSY.

I New England Collegians Show Supe--. rlority Throughout the Game. PHILADEPHIA. Oct. 21.

Without the semblance of a fluke the Brown tTnlversl-ty football team defeated Pennsylvania this afternoon by the score of 0 to a Although the winning touchdown was not scored vntll the fourth period, there was hardly a minute In which' the Philadelphia team was not outplayed by the New Knglanders. Not once durinjr the entire contest did the Quakers) menace the Brown IgoaL 'while the Providence team was always carrying the flsht to the Pennsylvanlana'. The fourth period was only fire rnlnutes old when Brown had vania's line. Just before the third period ended Brown had taken the ball to Pennsylvania's, one-yard line through a succession of1 clever forward passes and end runs- With only a yara IUIIS. UI1IJ had to surrender the ball on downs.

Aner two exchanges of kicks Brown got the ball on Pennsylvania's and from this point marched "tra5.hil down the field for the touchdown. Sprackltng and Tenney did most or tne Browns' ground galninU- Tenney carried the ball from the twen. iv.v.nl linm tn the flve-vard line on a for me line ui om and then with one tre- I nSmpiin.V.V.V Rirtt tVkl. rndotun' the score. Ashbaugn Kica halfback i.Wsllace CORNELL'S FORM STILL POOR ithacans Have Not Improved In Past Week, but They Beat W.

J. Special to Tktsra TimtsA ITHACA. N. 21-CornelI beat Washington and Jefferson this afternoon by the score of 0 to 0, but It was hard to see where the Ithacans had mad much improvement as the result of the week's train-ng and practice. Penalties aggregating 7u yards, some of them directly responsible for the loss of touchdowns; over, running of kicks, weak playing byj Krog-stad In the first half, and stupid mixing up of signals marred Cornell's playing, and the team came nowhere near doing, Itself Jv.stlce: Barring some good gains around Krogstad, And occasionally around Champaign and mad dash for a touchdown was only thwarted on the 2-yard line.

The visitors were not dangerous, and in the second half they wilted and hobbled before Cornell's pounding. The Ithacana. however, seemed Impotent to grasp this opportunity properly. After Butler had kicked a field goal from the line early In the first period Hawkins, by two fine runs, took the ball to the l-yard line. He then snoiled his own rood work by trying to crawl across the line after he had been downed on the a-yard line.

Cornell was set back and lost a chance to score. Offside work and hurdling by Butler and a fumble by Hawkins put the Ithacans out of a fine chance In the third period, but the worst exhibition of Indifferent work came In the last period, when Collins and McCormlck advanced the ball through the line for 40 yards to the 5-yard line, where a mix-up of signals between Butler and Kvrlch lost the ball. i The Cornell team Is very far from getting together, as this game showed. Washington and Jefferson has a fast back field, which caused plenty of trouble, and once Whitehill threw a big scare Into the crowd by-picking up an onside kick which Guyer should have covered Guyer also missed the tackle, as did I Butler. Whitehill going to the 2-yard line before he was thrown out of bounds.

Here Cornell threw the visitors The line-up: Cornell. Position. and J. Left end McClure Krocstad Left tackle O'Rourke Left ruard Whyte. Centre PmllB -i i.Haamb TIbblns, (Oapt.) MIDDIES HOLD TIGERS TO A SCORELESS TIE ON ANNAPOLIS FIELD Navy's Line Shows Superiority Over! Tigers Great Punting Duel.

Between Dalton for Middies and De Witt for Princeton. 1 Rla-ht iroard -the Hrewn back, waa the of the contest His playing was always am be r.ir, his teammates with consum- mate Judgment, but he played a wonderful game himself. Mercer and Played the best game for Philadelphia. The -line-up Pennsylvania. Dillon.

Wollert. FT.deiaen. Young, Marshall an I rieia jud Mctnhi. Academy, Position. Ift end Tft tackle Left guard Centre Rlsht a-uard Rlcht tackke p.inht end Ouarter back Icrt naif back Right half back Foil back A.

H. Fhanx. Yale. Brown. Adama Kratx Kulp Oelb Marble Jones Umpire J.

c. Head Hawklna Rlaht half back .1 -Xay lor Fullback Wnitehlll Oasis from field Hutler. 2. Referee Mr. Coo-ney of Princeton.

Umpire Mr. Okerson of Le-hlBh. Field Mr. Decamp of Williams. Head Uninan Llac OiUmore of West Point.

Substitutes: Cornell Fttmeon for Outer. Trits for Stlmson. Collins for O'Connor, McCormlck for Hawkins. Unerhll! for Hill. For Washington and Jefferson Holden for MeCbire.

Taylor for Cunnlna-ham. tloodwln for Tibblna. Moody for Taylor, Time of periods Fifteen and twelve minutest WANT TAFT TO SEE. GAME. -1 Pennsylvania Plans Visit by Presldeirt to Army-Navy Contest, PHILADELPHIA.

Oct. 21. A special 1 1 PnnsyU-anl-t-Mlnds tor Vtt. Thayer tor Harrlnrton. V-lett and Tenney To.

a'-ToucHdewn-Tenney. Tune of mlcutes each. li Came. 21. Wesleyan PncVmsub.mu- effort will be made to have President mont at no time carried the ball fa Into Maine territory.

Maine scored on two field goals by Khcperd a towlalwa by Parker, made on line i.iavs after a suecescion of forward pa'es. and a touchdown by Rernheisel. which followed a kick-fumbled by Vermont. much asfthey did last, year ferae fo( her kickers was una ai.nt every kick came inch of hieing blocked. And were one to pen tne m-av for a v.

down an the other to reouS almost as' miuuKJr.u ruinj-iiva-yira aavancf lor the Army to Yale's two-yard line, The fiajd was too slipper for many brilliant plays to be made. Once Merrltt of Yale made a sensaUonai ra down the 9 ltk: fUOiblCll 1 Oct. 2L Holy Cross 1 Cross Scores 6 Points. Ms defeated the Massachusetts Agricultural Col- lege eleven, ft to 0, to-Jay on a ficM so wet and sUppery that fast I work wss Until the final period Holy Cross super! urttv In very de partment of the game was i evl.l.at bir when tha Una! blew tna Wesleyan Wins Earlv tttt rprm- t. ly from I ValvtTmity won! from Turts here to-day.

10 to ver-'i makln two touvtuloans In the first two periods In the first period Wesleyan scored on two forward Passes, and is a fair catch and a line pluge. fnearard naaa. nva the second score, in tne the ball wss in Tufts' terri tory moat of tha time- Wesleyan. Position. Riahe end suard Hanunond.

Murphy. enire Parkinson Pern hard McCarthy Haeon Lacarren. tackle Ieft end back. Tufts. Uaw IVnnftt Richardson Towsl- Merrill Jameson Kiel HI -n 1 i.t Taft attend the annual football game be tween the Army; and Navy on imnitiin Field In this city? on Nov.

The President of the United States always receives invitationj for himself and fasnily and smy friends he desires to bring- along, bat official business usually prevents the President from coming to the game. The University of which has charge of the distribution of tickets. Is taking unusual precautions to prevent any of them from falling into the hands of -peculators." Franklin Field seats about 'JTiAt persons, and tre tickets will be divided equally amonJ the Army. V.vy. nnd university.

Pennsylvania k. the proceeds given to the orpamx-ations tar the relief of de-J pende-nt widows ami orpnaui oiucera and enlisted irnn of botb army apd navy Haverford Game Canceled. PHILADELPHIA. Oct. football game that waa to bars been piayea.ai iiaver- Prtneotoa.

Whlta Phillips Wilson Rhjetbenthal 7.1... browa Wight Maker Sawyer DaWItt Weeks did good work while in the game, honors being very often between these two, who were having a desperate fight for the final occupancy of the position in centre. 1 Princeton had somewhat the better of the playing in the first quarter. In the second and third the balance did not Incline either way, while the closing period undoubtedly yielded great honor to the Midshipmen. It was then that the effect of Dalton's punting and the better work of the Navv line waa manifest, and the visitors were fighting for life most of the time, particularly in the last five minutes.

Hart, last year's Captain, got in the llne-un In the third Quarter. CThe Navy team came through the game In excellent ahape. and Dalton and Brown, about whom mere was mum account of recent injuries, played through out. The line-up: Navy. Position.

Lft and Brown Left tackle Klifter Left guard Centre Hwe Rtirht guard Redman ftlsht tackla Oilcrlst Rlsht end Kuwall. Qnarter bark Dalton Left half back McRavy Right half back u.vU, VuU bark fanrilatun. Umpl Mr. Terry. Ualvemlty of Pennsylvania.

Klald Juds Frederick Murphy. Tale. Tlma of w-teraTwelva minutes owh. Hubstltutes: Navy Waketnan for Elmer. Elmer Wak-maa.

Weetns for Ingram, inrram for Waems, Wmi for lnsrm. Princeton 11 lap for White. Hart for Phillips. MO'ormWk for Wilson. Wilson for.

McCormlck. Duff for lirown. Fare foe Pendleton. Pendleton for Fare, Panflald fee DoWltt. DaWitt for Penflald.

CHICAGO PILES UP POINTS. Illinois Offers Poor Resistance In Game on Marshall Field. CHICAGO Oct University found the University ef Illinois football team easy to-day during the first half of the game, pushing the dowa-Biate players back and forth across the field almost at-will. Chicago 'won. 21 to a Three minutes after that opening whistle sounded.

Left End Bcruby of the Maroons kicked a field goal, and two minutes later he bad en opportunity for another, hut rain1 had made the bail slippery and th attack failed. Before the end of the first period Nor-gren-of Chicago had blocked an attempted punt by Illinois, and baiier, Norgren a team mate, eeooped the ball tup at the exact -centre of the field and raced to a touchdown. A oal kick Wt the aore at the end of the first period 8 0, Chicago leading. The kick-off. recovery of the ball on fumble by Woolston Illino'a, and a field goal by Scruby from the first scrimmage opened the awond period, fiaver ran clear throtfgh the Illinois team and, added a touchdown Ironi th fifty-yard line, and the goal kick ended the first half.

Chicago lH. Illinois U. Krenuent cnanges in too iiismi Sficial la New York Timet ANNAPOLIS. Oct. 21.

The Naval Academy and Princeton battled without a score this afternoon, and In the closing minutes of the game, all the men of Old Nassau! were hard pressed and battling for the honor of the big four against a team not generally classed with it, but which has shown its ability many fields of rising to the occasion And cutting out the work for the best of them. Princeton's goal line was seriously menaced daring; th game, and It Was within two minutes of the close that! the mld-shlpmen had their chance. Dalton trying for a field goal from placement from Princeton's thirty-yard line. The ball was blocked by the visitors as the game ended. 1 There was little question as to the superiority of the Tigers' backfleld.

at least In I to-day's playing, and none whatever that the navy had the heavier, better. and more- aggressive forward line. Princeton also had a better i series of plays on the attack, and the wet field did not greatly detract from the leetness of its runners. i Daltott and De Witt punted very evenly In the opening period of the name, but toward the end Dalton wore the Prince-ton lan -out to some extent and gah-iod considerably -on each exchange. Tho punting duel between Dalton of the Navy and De: Witt of Princeton waa, fine football.

Hoth of them got the leather over a goodly number of the whitewash lines and both used Judgment and accuracy in thekr placing and lining the ball. WTien; comparatively close to their exponents' goal line both had the knack of lifting the. ball high- In the air so as to allow the ends and other line men plenty or time in getting down the fTeld. Frequently Dalton panted out eld nearly at the limit- of his punting distance, so as to gfve Pendleton a chance to run the ball back. It wait.

In the last quarter that Dalton gradually wore his opponents down, and the 11 kishlpman Captain began to get from five to ten yards the better of the Tiger on every exchange. This, with the fierce tackling -of tbe Navy's ends and other line men. notably the big blackball red guard Howe, forced the fighting into J'rinceton's territory, and more than once the Pr inert on la ns were In a tight i i Tha same will, be noted as the occasion when Howe came to nis tveigning niinoia. several pounds over. 200 and able to run i abfe to hold Chi-.

AWaTaaF vskn Brmnn i a i nacs.yYeooe. th. HmVerford and Dlek- i t.i was isslAral on ttw Angles -V b-J Holy Crvaa- VZ rt tZZ mvW conflUou ef tha Aid. HO yards In a fifth over ten seconds. How nlareil ail last Mar on the scrub.

having' been- siaad up as not having football in blm. This year, and this day particularly, he came to his own. Frequently leading the ends down the field, he threw his great weight like a thlrteen-lnch shell against the Princeton backs, carrying them off their feet and yards toward, their own goal. Howe's splendid tackling was the big point of to-day's game. Pendleton's occasional brilliant bursts around end being the only other 1 feature to compare with it- The quarters were much different In their general style of play, There was a great deal of kicking throughout.

lrlnceton would atart the running game whenever, the opportunity was present, and at times appeared dan- but was never able to keep tip a one series of games. Howe. Brown, and irimM, vhartHl desneiratalv and mixed the -backfleld uiO wkiie beih Icgraxn and rata away from the goal llrre until in the laat per 100, wnen ncruoj otum the line when Illinois tried a punt from behind Its own goal line. and. after blocking the punt, scooped up the ball lor touchdown The goal was kicked.

Tha line-up follows; Foattton. auirewia. Left ed Oliver fft tackla PHrno Chicago. Raoemacher Whiting Carpenter. fioettler Paine faurr p--rce Noreen Left guard Centra Rlcht guard R1tt tackla Hicht eetd Quarter back Left half hack Full back Rlht half back BelUng Davia Ralttna? gprlriter Hail RoWtS I Inn.

MarrlS for tSOSIIH. Fere f-r Pierre; lUlnole-Taompson l'r I-rlnce: Watson for P. Bltln. hr Hall. Fisher for Cheney.

Row -r BeiH-. F-f--eraa Mr. fcnow. MK-hisac. Fl'id Ju-4 ea J- r.

pmrdua. Umpire it' r. t2A rra. i art a.