The New York Times from New York, New York • Page 1

(1 "All the News That's Fit to Print" THE WEATHEn. Sho-vvers -to day, fair to-morrovr. VII 1 I i VOL. NO. 1G.76S.

YOKK, pRIDAY, OCTOBER 2, 1903. -FOURTEEN PAGES. ONE CENT Greater JTew Torlr. FUeTt'oeFe. Jersey City Aewrlt.

I TWO IK' J.4 i NEW BALFOUR APPEALS FOR FISCAL REFORM British Premier Says Free Trade Is an Empty "Name. POWER TO RETALIATE NEEDED fcnmsnje Audience 'at Sheffield Loudly Cheers the Prime Minister and Passes a Vote of Confidence in the Government LONDOX, Oct. 2. Before a mm meeting si Sheffield last night in connection with the conference of the National Union of Conservative Associations Premier Balfour delivered the speech that bad been Ion heralded as the first heavy grin to be fired la the fiscal reform campaign which Is absorbing the attention of the United Kingdom, the British colonies, and. Indeed, the whole world, which has caused the present British Cabinet trials, the result of which It is Impossible to foretell.

Mr. Balfonr, In the course of bis speech, did not even bint at the successors in the jCabinet to Mr. Chamberlain, Lord George Hamilton, and Mr. Ritchie, In 'fact, he did not mention the Ministerial resignations. Ignoring altogether that phase of the Situation on which it was expected that he would make some declaration.

Premier confined himself strictly to the tariff Question, and bis speech was to a large extent a repetition of the arguments contained in his recent pamphlet. AX AUDIENCE OP FIVE THOUSAND. Last night's meeting was held In Artillery Drill HalL which -eas the largest auditorium available. Fully 5.000 persons gatbergd in the ball long before 8 o'clock, the hour at which Mr. Balfour was announced to speak, and perhaps as many more who were unable to get in attended sn overflow meeting In Albert HalL In addition thousands who could not be accommodated at either meeting stood outside in the rain.

Joining those' inside the halls in patriotic songs and cheering the names of the party leaders. Mr. Balfour, who was accompanied by a number of prominent men. Including the Duke of Marlborough, Lord Hugh Cecil. Winston Churchill, M.

Viscount Gos-then. and F. W. Lowe, M- (Chairman of the Council of the. Union.) entered the ball a few minutes before 8 and was received enthusiastically.

The Earl of Derby presided in the absence of the Duke of Norfolk who Is indisposed. Lord Derby ln-frodoced Mr. Balfour in a brief speech. The Premier. on- rising; at 8:03" P.

Sf, was greeted wltlvjrepeated rounds of cheers. He began with the statement that. be knew the audience wanted to hear his views fiscal reform, be would deal with that subject alone, not introducing airy alien themes -What is it." the Premier asked. that has brought-this toplo into- exceptional prominence? There are those who would sttribute the importance it, has attained to that great speech delivered by a great man. Mr.

Chamberlain, in May last, but something more is required to account for phenomenon unparalleled in the expert-' ence of any man I am now addressing." Mr. Balfour attributed this prominence to the facts that the country was In eUwer touch with the colonics as a result of the late war: that representative Ministers in the colonies had brought before the empire the question of tariff reform, and that for a long time prior to the development cf the present controversy there had besn great uneasiness among aU parties as. to the condition of British trade in relation to the trade of the world. Mr. Chamberlain's speecn.

said the Premier, would not have ha 3 the effect it did if tt bad not fallen on prepared ground, and if effort to give preference to the mother country Jiad not brought out threats from at least one foreign country of retaliation. This had brought home to many minds the helplessness of Great Britain under such circumstances to meet a situation so unexpected and so dangerous. COBDEXITES' VAIN PROPHECIES. The last sixty years, continued Mr. BaV-.

four, had been filled with refutations of the t. prophecies made by the great tariff reforra- ers. He believed that the reforms of 1S44 were necessary at that time, but every yjar of the last thirty had contradicted the prophecies of the reformers. The Premier paid a tribute to Cobden. who.

be raid. bud an Ideal, but who did not foresee the eevelopment of the last half century, had made free trade an empty name ana a vain force, For fifty years England, without making a sign, had watched the wan of hostile tariffs growing up and dividing- nation from nation. "And our own colonies, our own- flesh and blood, the very sinews of the grow Ing empire." proceeded Mr. Balfour, "are building up a system of protection which, when It reaches Its logical conclusion, wiil inake It as hard to export to them as to America or the other protective countries. And during the whole.

lifetime of those I am now addressing we have done nothing whatever to hinder a state of things so ab- splutely Inconsistent with free trade as Cobden understood It. I ought to make one exception. One great and successful ef- fort was made by Cobden himself when he negotiated a commercial -treaty with France in lyjj. When I consider that treaty I ask myself whether Cobden was indeed a Detailing the history of this Mr. Balfour contended that Cobden and Glad-.

stone tn negotiating; it intended to offer of taxation, in return for wht'-h protectionist France was to make certain trading- concessions, and falling those con. cessions the taxes were to be retained. lit continued: consider that there Is absolutely no difference between retaining a tax for diplomatic purposes, which you would otherwise repeal, and Importnar a tax which you wouli otherwise not impose for carrying out the same object. I confess that 'hen 1 hear criticisms upon American and Herman policy, which caused those great industrial nations to accompany their marvelous commercial expansion with 'protective duties, which must have thrown a most heavy burden upon the consumer, I INDEX TO DEPARTMENTS. Commercial World.

Page 11. Amusements. Page 7. Arrivals at HoteU, Page 8. Business Troubles.

Page 5. Court Calendars. Page Insurance potes. Page 12. Uptl Notes -Page 14.

Marine Intelligence and Foreign Mails. Jew Corporations. Page IL ii Estate. Page li 1. tf-itcd 11.

Weather Report. Page 12. Yesterday's Fires-Pago feel that they have a retort to whtch I at least have no reply. They may well say that although protectionist they have es- tabltshed permanent free trade within the limits of their own countries, where everything which can hamper production or limit the increase of I wealth has been abolished by their patriotism and foresight, and they may well ask us whether we in the BriUsh Empire can point to a similar picture, and wbether our vaunted free trade includes these great self-governing colonies which we proudly boast are Jo be the great buttresses of our; empire in the future. i "Free trade ir Indeed an empty name and a vain force it it is a fact that: foreign nations are setting themselves td divert our Industries, exclude lour manufactures, and limit the international play of supply and demand.

-ill ''There has beenj a development of whtch Cobden and his contemporaries never dreamed the development of the system under protection. The phenomenon is so new that I dare scarce venture to prophesy what development it is likely to take, but you may be absolutely sure that In the alliance of trusts and tariffs there Is a danger to the capital and enterprise of this country which acts and reacts net mainly upon the -capitalist, for he is at liberty to go to those i regions where his industry will be looked after, butj it will tail with Its heavlestj weight upon the artisan and the labor classes, which are Incapable of protecting their Interests against such a calamity, NO CURE, 1 PALLIATION. Now. If have hWy described the dangers and evils 'we suffer, y.ou are entitled to ask ma whether I know of a cure. My answer will be disappointing.

1 knov, of no cure, but I do! know of a palliation. The ill bas gone too You will jnot get the 'great commercial nations of the world to abandon protection, tear that you will not get the great; self-governlng colonies to retrace, the steps which we without remonstrance permitted them to take I am here, therefore, to! recommend a palliation which I believe to be still possible, i Cobdea hoped and believed in free trade throughout the world. What, in fact, we have got to deal I with! is a world; where International commercial relations are regulated entirely I treaty. Is It common sense that we. the greatest commercial nation, should come forward and say, We want to arrange treaties with you, but we have nothing to give you, nothing to withhold from you.

We ithrow ourselves upon your mercy and consideration. Please remember how good we i are to your commerce, bow we throw no impediment in its way, and how we do- all we can for you, and please don't forget us when you are making your next treaty Laughter.) Are the negotiations between nations which have to deal with duties upon! manufactured goods different from otheB negotiations carried on for ether purposes? Did any man ever, bear- of successful negotiations without a nation having something to give which In case of necessity it might withhold My fundamental and essential request to you to-night, to which the rest of my speech is subsidiary and accidental, is that the people of this country ishould give to Its Government that freedom! of negotiation of which we have been deprived, not by force of circumstances or by flm pressure of foreign powers, but by: something I can only describe as our own pedantry and self-conceit. "i Proceeding to deal with the question asked as to how the freedom he desired was to be used, Mr. Balfour thought that the question was rather unreasonable. No Minister, he remarked, could say hqw the navy was going ta be used in a few! years hence.

One could i only, say It was 'necessary to have a great navy In case of meed, my continued th Premier. it Is equally necessary that this country should have command of these instruments of negotiation for which I am leading. The German States Illustrate ow a fiscal union preceded and strengthened a political union, but so far as -our colonies are concerned we have been content to see fiscal divisions growing up which no man of sober judgment can contemplate without -1 FOOD TAX IMPRACTICABLE. Mr.) Balfour was a most important and difficult branch of tbe problem. Though he believed jtbatj-the eyUs fthe taxation of food bad been exaggerated beyond what reason land logic justified, still he thought that public opinion was not yet ripe for the taxaUoi of (food.

Therefore, as an adviser of algiit party, was bound to tell them! pSalnli that It was outside the limits of practical politics. He was not anticipating generii tariff war. but he considered might inform any foreign country that we. thought was treating us with outrageous unfairness that Unless they modified their policy we should take certain steps with regard to certain articles exported by thran." I i Concerning the question as to whether it was intended to reverse the verdict in the great case of Free (Trade Vs. Protection of 1846.

Mr. Balfour said hU answer, was that the controversy jof 1846 was of no Interest to the present generation and "as utterly Inappropriate i to 1903, "Our fought the battle in view of the actual situation. I ask 'the naUon to-dar to follow their example and not be misled by-rtusty debates. The second question is: Do! you desire to reverse and alter the fundamental fiscal tradition which has prevailed Jtor two gentrations? My answer is: "Yes, I do Loud cheers. The Premier said he proposed to ask the country to reverse, annul, and altogether delete from Its maxims of public conduct that it must never impose taxauoa except for revenue, In his Judgment the country ought never ito have stood self-deprived of that liberty, and it should tpub-ficly resume in the face of Europe and the world the liberty of which It deprived Itself the liberty which every other country In the world possessed and of which no fcoun-try would deprive iltself.

the liberty of negotiating and also of having something to negotiate with. To the next -question, why they should want to resume this liberty, seeing; how well the country had prospered without it, the Premier said he vojild reply: "My object is to mitigate to the upmost the 'injury done us by hostile tariffs. I The proposed remedy Willi not be complete seven If tried in Its integrity, because I believe the country will not tolerate a tax on food; but undoubtedly it wlU be useful." i vc- via tfs.il. mH ie had been asked to give a lead, and the request -was reasomible. and the request -was reasonitbie.

howeveri unworthy of his Wirty, I it, and ioi long as he held (that ie meant! to lead. He had given A leaaer. must lead nA.lltMt ll this great quesuon wmcoi and he was firmly convinced that the policy which he now recommended wad not only in harmony with England's best traditions. nd not only (found a precedent In the statements of her greatest but was also the best which the country, dependent solely as It was upon Us commercial and manufacturing position, cpuld adopt. In that faith and in that belief he recommended it to their favorable consideration.

Vr Baifour sat down amid loud and prolonged cheers. A vote Of confidence Ins the Ministery was adopted unanimously. The -Premier afterward addressed the overflow meeting. i I LONDON PRESS I DISSATISFIED. Conservative and Radical Papers Critl- else -the Premier's Speech for Different Reasons.

LOXDOX. Oct. i-Ht is evident that Mr, ukxrr- sueech bas utte failed to Sat IStr the press of either party. The burden cf an the editorial comment this morning 'is that In spite of "the i enthusiasm evoked at Sheffield the Speech leaves the qses tlon exactly where; it was left -by the Premier's recent pamphlet! The greatest jiis-appomtment Is expressed on. all sides! at Mr Balfour's failure, to touch on the Cabinet crisis or.

explain tbe outlines of Shis proposed policy. Conservative organs like The Standard and The Morning Post concur In the view that. Mr. Balfour poslUon is impossible, mA that while Mr Chamberlain had adopted leaderlike standpoint Mr. as no defined policy.

I 1 The Standard wants the Premier's proposal thrown nto the shape ol a worfcjng Scheme It says that bis plans may be mocnt or extremely dangerous, whfU it istW I Imix-sibleTto say whether or hot he repudiates Chamberlain's proposal 1 TbeXMoTning Pot Issy. that a llcyi of negottatloft 'tjrom which the colonle jire excluded is nlmple reaction. Great Britain cannot retaliate Without reorganising per fa riff, and that Ui impossible without considering the queaUon of olonlal preference. Black Whit to Amerlcwi an-fyouU find you 10 the same SAFETY IN RIYER TUNNELS i. fennsylv ania Road Deuces on Me Hod of Construction.

YVIil Have (Concrete Sidewalks Level with Car! Windows Great' Under- firounll Station Bids Adver- tlsed For. After anomhs of consultation between Eminent engineers of thlsi and other cities, Uie Pennsylvania Ballroad Company finally 4as decided Lpon the methods by which It Will build Its tunnels under the North and Vast Rivera knd ManhatUn Island. Tlao conss-uctlon beneath the 4 North $iver of two jsinglS cast-iron wibes. entering this city at tie foot of ivest Thlrti-second Btreet, anid running Vnder thai Street. They wlU be buUfby tbe shield process tbe same now used in donstrucUngI the tunnel of the Mew York a)nd Jersey I Railroad Company's tunnel between Morton Street, this borough, and fifteenth.

jStteet, (Jersey City. .1 tb cast- iron lUDesjwiu built in sections behind ahlelds. as tile shields are pressed forward. and inside itlle cast iron will be ia Unlng of Concrete, (Among th many precautions 'arranged no make theltunnel as safe as possible will qe two concrete sidewalks built inside the cubes on I level with Via rait windows and the plar provide that the tubes must Be roomy en mgh to allow ample width for tfriese walks. The object of the Walks is to provide exM for passehgers in case Of accl- qent, From the car windows It wul be an easy step to the avenues of safetjr.

and it is calculated tHat the two walks Will contain Room sufficient to provide a way of err ess tjo as many lassengers as can be accommodated iritbln tbe ears. The walkwjay escapes are but in incident the genlral plan of providing saf e- Evry car. It Is claimed. wlU be re-proof, j. The tunnel itself wfll be fire proof.

The ftlgnal system will be the most perfect knotfn. The HghUng power will be separate froii that; which furnishes operating fdrce, land there are to be numerous hydrants an- hose! bossies read to be put Into Immedldte use In the event of fire. (The principal difference between th Pennaylvahil tunnel under the North River 4nd that of the New Yorlr-Jn1 Jermev Jkallroad CoAipanyj will be that the former ill have jaitiflcial foundations. The soil beneath tbel river i is soft, and the tube Will not be I laid deep enough to reach a riatural rM bed. Hence thej will rest MPon what are known as screw pile loun- datlons.

made of, iron. These screw piles of metal areJ well known to engineers, and used pi4st frequently in constructing undations ror Ughthousea Tbe reason the Pennsylvania tunnel has have artificial foundations is that its great electrit locomotives, weighing some- thing: like Lt00 tons, are too heavy, in the ofl the engineers, to I pentnit of judgment flowing the! tubes to rest in the natural ilL In th case of! the New I York and xsey- RaUrfcad tunnel, where tk-olley cars ily are tolbe operated. 'It was decided ttoat there Would not be enough) weight la wo tium ovcnniau snruucuu tions. I ri-r" Under the East River the railroad's tunnel will consist lof four cast-iron tubes, con structed similarly to those under! the North River, exceit that artificial foundations Will be uanlessary. The bed of the East River baa tie rock needed to uphold the tithes in saf i ty.

The four tubew will come tb the surf ice near the Intersection of Thompson A venue, i Long Island! City, and the present 1 racks of the Long Island Railroad. Two the four tubes will go under Manhattan stand by way of Thirty-sec- ana street, ana tne outer two Deneatn Thirty-third I (The great underground station In -this city will ex tend from Seventh! to Ninta Avenue, end from Thirty-first to Thirty-third Street. The plans just completed provide that lit hall be about forty feet below the street l4vel. From the streets to the waiting room level, twenty feet Mown, will be driveway of ample width knd genile decline. The re will be! numerous elevators for freight und passengers, and the designers of tl waiting rooms, restaurants, ticket office baggage rooms, and other portions of (the station have made their plans under instructions to.

spare no detail that would (make the establishment the most complete, as well as tne most artistic at its kind hi the world. I Although entirely underground, the sta. tlon will be he largest In the world in re-sjpeet to pot width, length, and trackage. If the Rapid Transit Commission's plan of building a Bioadway tunnel between Forty-second Stre and Union Square ever is adopted, the -e wtll be some sort) of underground conn s-ctlon running frond the sub way station pi tieraia uquare to; tne Penn aX-lvania Railroad Station. The power to be used in the tunnel, as required by both the States of New York ejnd Newt Jer ey, will be entirely electricity, iied throug i electric locomotives.

In the Hacxensaca ueaaows win oa a station, vfhere the tr Uns will exchange their steam tgines for he electric ones. The arrange-nts for tY change will be made so that timet of he stop will be not more than minute. On Long Island there will be a similar langlng station in, the yards near Thomp ion Avenue. (Having d- ermlned upon its plans, the Pennsylvania aaverusea ror Dias yesterday. The wtSrk will be done in I thre tions.

and tae contractors are required to present their sealed bids before noon of Dec. 15 1 at the office of the company, K5 Cedar Streei The bond required will be lb per cent, kf the amount of the bid. The aupfli nary company organised td tnilld the tur net is called the Pennsylvania, New York, nd New Long Island Railroad Company, tie President of which Is A Jf (iussatt, heB of the Pennsylvania system sind the! Directors of; which coincide practically with I those of the parent corpora tion, owirai nm tunnel wurn COnaHtS the borittg under Brgen Hill and the new jersey portion lot tne INorin Rlvor. Section ia Ui ces in the 'New York portion dt the North River and the excavations as fkr as the i lain station beneath Manhattan Island, including the station. Section 3i Is thei tun iel east of the station la this oorougn; anci unuer fcaat iilver and uong jianaiity, I fjlR.

MORGAN LOSES OVERCOAT. Garmert Mlsterlbusly Disappears from Protestant Episcopal Convention In Chjircht of the' Heavenly rtsstr i Somebody, somewhere about this "is wearing; an fcvercoat belonging to J. pier- pont Morgan When the financier tore himself away trc his worldly interests for two whole days devote himself to the annual convention the Protestant Episcopal Church in ti ls diocese, which on Wednesday selected the Rev.i Dr. David H. Oreer 1 be Bishop Coadjutor, to Bishop Potter, he did it 'o cor tpletely that he not alone' put steamships, allroads, and stocks! out cf his rilnd, but a so omitted to make a precise mental note where be had dtspbsed of bis oiercoat wh -n he took bis plac4 with the other lay tr embers tn tbe Chuj-ch of the Heavenly nt, where the session was held.

Wben be left the church be tbok up an cA-vrt'oat wl ich he thought wks his and smarted for ils automobile. Thjs garment fitted so 11 that it was ndt until he reached into a pocket for a handkcrchl.if arid brought out one that was not his that he suspectt- -anything wrongJ Further search revea a well-chewed tdothpick. (Mr. Morgn i sent for the Sexton. A thorough search was made, but there wae no trace of Mi.

Morgan's overcoat, and he stood wistfully in the rapidly thinning crowd jot da egataav some of whbm paused to aid In the search. The new. Bishop Coadjutor was waiting to ride away with Mr. Morgan, and as nobody claimed the coat he. had on Mr.

Morgan at last entered the machine by Lr. Greer's side and started oft Later a continued search of the pockets revealed 'the name of the owner of that overcoat, and It was restored yesterday, but It was no case of fair exchange, for Mr. Morgan's was still missing at a late hour last night. The overcoat was buti Mr. Morgan, mindful of the surroundings amid which he lost it, bas by no means abandoned hope cf seeing It again tn the near future.

I SOUTHERN FIRMS ARE EMBARRASSED. Middendorf Co. of Baltimore and John L. Williams 8on of Richmond f-' Ask Indulgence. BALTIMORE.

Oct. i. a persistent rumor pervaded! the financial district here to-day that'J. William Middendorf Co. of this city and (John L.

Williams 4 Son of Richmond, were embarrassed. Those in Interest at first declined to discuss the matter, but late to-nlaht. after a conference which lasted several hours, gave out the following statements: i "In view. of the extraordinary and unexpected financial Situation' now exlsUng in New York. Messrs.

Williams gon of Richmond. and J. William Middendorf tt of Baltimore, have found ft necessary to ask temporary indul-sTZr of their creditors. Lv Tne undersigned have, at the request of these two firms, consented to act as an advisory committee to examine into their con. "on and promptly report an appropriate plan of extension.

The committee will proceed to the Immediate performance of. this duty. In the meanwhile, they, believe it to be to the Interest of all concerned that -no legal or other steps be taken by Individual creditors to complicate the situation, but that the present status shall in all resists be maintained fcr common protection and benefit. i i The Shove firms eatlrnat that their assets Inventoried -t current quotations, their liabilities by a very large amount, which will be naturally augmented by tbe restoration of normal conditions. "In view of the official relatione of Mr.

J. 8. Williams and Mr. J. Wj Middendorf with the Seaboard Air Line they desire to state that neither firm, nor any.

member thereof, is indebted to that company, and that the i Seaboard Air Una Railway will be In no wise affected by tbe action of their respective firms in this matter." 1 This -statement is signed by Douglas TL Thomas. Douglas H. Gordon, Robert Davidson, John Ramsay, Eugene Levering, all of Baltimore; Eppa Hunton Richmond. and Frank O. Brlggs.

Trenton, N. J. i John. Skelton Williams, who was in Baltimore to-night, raid that the action taken was occasioned by the inability of the two firms mentioned above to collect large sums of money due them, and to realise on securities in the present disturbed money, markets. "The value of my firm's assets." said Mr.

Wlllams. is greatly in excess of all liabilities of. every kind, and the present difficulties will be only temporary. None of the companies la which my firm and Mr. Middendorf's are largely interested, or with which members of these firms are officially connected, will be affected In any way by the action taken today.

All of the properties held by us are in excellent and healthy condition, and the outlook for them, without exception, is bright and thoroughly satisfactory." i INTER VIEW. AUGERS GEEILOS. Bitterness Caoaed by the ISBDMed Vleys.of Prof, Small of Chicago. SPttial 0 Th AT Oct. A Barlin cablegram printed here to-day says: Considerable been aroused here by a Chicago cablegram In the Tageblatt quoting Prof.

Albion W. Small of tbe University of Chicago as saying that Germany Is determined to provoke war with the United States. The Tageblatt also prints a statement from a correspondent, saying that Prof. Small has evidently been misquoted, as when be was here in -September he expressed sentiments In direct contradiction to those now attributed to him." i Tbe cablegram goes en to say that Prof. Small's alleged remarks, which are reproduced all over the empire to-day.

are particularly untimely, coming as they do on the same day on iwhich Prof. Theodor Mominaea bas stirred the Kaiser's people by his appeal for a friendly understanding with Great Britain, 4o which, many of the leading newspapers assert, millions of Germans are ready to subscribe. When seen to-day. Prof. Small admitted that he had given an interview in which the possibility of war between tbe United States and Germany, but be added: i i The interview I gave out was published In substantially my own language, but the inference was edited Into it that I regarded war with Germany as Inevitable.

This is certainly not the fact, because I have not the slightest idea that the situation as I diagnosed it is at all obscure to the majority of our Congreesmon. My prediction Is that our naval policy will continue to be such as to mske the absurdity of a war between Germany and the United Slates perfectly evident to tbe Jingoes of both nations' -i SETTLEMENT WORK ROMANCE. Mils Robblns and J. H. Chase Met on the Lower East Side tnd Were maiiivu, j.

Sfttiat Ntw Ytrk Ttswa, i MOUNT IVY, N. Yu Oct. L-MIsg Eia-beth D. Bobbins, who for eleven years; has been connected with the College Settlement in Rivington New York City, and John H. Chase, bead worker of the Maxwell Settlement in Brooklyn, were married to-day In the Summer borne of the College Settlement In the heart of the Ramapo HlUs at this the event being the culmination of a romance of the neighborhood social work on the lower, east aide of the metropolis.

i The ceremony was performed by the rector of a nearby Protestant Episcopal Church beneath a bower of Autumn foliage In the large west room of the house, in toe presence of about thirty-five relatives of the contracting parties. Mr. and Mrs. Chase left for their bridal tour in a buggy in which they will drive about the State for a fortnight before returning to the scene of their labors. Mrs.

Chase is the daughter of the Ute Edward G. Robblns of Hartford, Conn. She and Mr. Chase had often heard of each other through their respective efforts toward social education in the tenements, but i first met unexpectedly about a year ago When the remarkable success of the Summer home and the growth of the Settlement in Brooklyn bad attracted wide attention. 1 HEINZEu IS RESTRAINED.

v- SHcUil Tk Ntw York Timu. I BUTTE. Oct. I. On the application of the Boston and Montana Company Judge Clancy to-day granted a temporary restraining order to' prevent the employes of.

the United Copper Company and Augustus Ilelnse from Interfering with the workings of tbe Boston and Montana Company In the controverted Pennsylvania It -was shown" to the court that Helnse's men had penetrated to the Pennsylvania through the Rarus mrne. Judge Clancy issued a temporary restraining order to show cause, and set the bearing for Thereupon the employes' of the United Copier Company began filling the workings of the Pennsylvania with steam and powder smoke, and did various other things to prevent the Boston and Montana miners from working. Ilelnse bss also applied for a restraining order directed against tbe Boston and Montana on the ground that the latter company has interfered with the working of the Rarus. entering through the Pennsylvania. Right hours' sail through tne Dreamland of Irving.

duaaen imtk 7 4-uv Ad. 1 GROUT'S N1IIE HISSED BY CITIZENS UNIONISTS Conventions Nominate Sulzberger, Bischoff, and Trautmann. GtORGE DECLINES TO RUN Reading cf Letter from Him Deno Uno- ma the Controller's Shameless Act of Treason Evokes Loud Applause.7 Hisses at thei mention of Controller rout name and loud applause for a Re nunciation of, the Controller by. Henry George distinguished Manhattan Bor ough Convention of the, Cltlsens' Union neia last nlgbt in Cooper Union. The (de nunciation was Included a letter sen to William A.

Coakley by Mr. Geora-e. Who declared that bis name must-not be pre sented as a nominee for the Bofough Presi-dencv bjitA Km ta uunuuui (U iuui the same ticket with Grout. Mr. Coakley read tbe and he had to pause -after almost every sentence while the delegates cheered or hissed, (.

A fight had been exepcted over the nomination -Of a candidate for Borough' President, but Mr. George's action caused (the convention to end in perfect' harmony, nd Cyrus L. Sulzberger, the choice of, tbe Fusion Conference Committee, was named unanimously. the County Convention, which preceded that of the borough, Justice Henry Bischoff wee renominated unanimously for Supreme Court Justice-in jthe vi a ul Sat g.IMA IMIUU A QUf mann was raUfled fori Sherift-, Messrs. Sulzberger, Bischoff, arid Trautmann: already have been nominated formally by the Republican conventions, j-, Both the meeting were called to order by Charles Strong as R.

Fulton who. read the report of the Conference Committee favoring the three candidates, received the usual ovation from his followers, who rone and cheered him to the echo. He moved the acceptance of the conferrees' report, and then there were speeches seconding the different nominations. i Justice' BIschofr name came up first. Everett P.

Wheeler, in seconding the said: i He bas served wltb great distinction and ability for fourteen His absolute: integrity and impartiality deserve the recognition- which all political partieti are giving in ratifying his A. P. W. Seaman, after praising, the Justice, said he-hoped the policy electing judicial officers without regard to party would be applied some day to all publio officials, Eugene Frayer made a laudatory seconding speech, and then the unanimous vote was oast for the Justice. 4 Mr.

Trau tmann's nomination, was' Seconded by Guatav H. Schwab, who described the candidate as a man enjoying the confidence of all who knew him, both among his many associates in the business world and among his fellow-America cltlsens of German descent." 1 It was when Mr. Bulsbergers name came up for a vote nd after the first seconding speech had been. made by Jatnes B. Butler, thtt Mr.

Coakley took the orra arui read the letter be had received fiom Henry-George declining nomination. Mr. Coakley Ih a sub-committeeman of the Cltuena' Union, and it Was he who had the advisabUlty; of having Mr. George, on toe ticaoi. iam tetter wav part, as I would not accept any place on a ticket biar-lag the name of Edward U.

Grout. Any InflJ-eocs that I. may have will be used te tnaurs ithe taction, of Mr. jLow and the defeat of a then whe opeoly aod Is the Ught. or blimUy, because cannot see.

Ia putting himself in a position of having, for tbe sake of an off los. sold himself to lha enemies of real Democracy and dir. While the rank and flla of th Democratic 'organisation are as good clUsvns as any In th community, the leadership of the is now la tha hands ot a contntetors' trust, whose profits by the misuse ot government la the past have been so enormous aa to make the graft that protected vice has yielded sera insignificant. The most powerful factors la the contractors trust are and have been Charles p. Murphy and Daniel McUahon, now the most potential factors In Tammaay Hail.

An Investigation of the relations of these men and their associates to Ithe Murphy Dock Board was undertaken by iths Commissioners of Accounts under Mr. Dow. tfhe chief Investigator, Mr. Russell, declared months aQJiet the Investigation (revealed scandalous favoritism and Indirect robbery of the people la transactions Involving not thousands, but literally millions of dollars. i Blnce making- this report Mr.

Russell has abandoned the Puslon cause and gone to the support of those whom he accused. Mr. George refers to the further inquiry undertaken by. Mr. Grout -into the matter of the leasing of choice dock property, and the report made during Mr.

Grout's absence abroad exonerating the Murphy Board. When 'the worthlessness of lbs investigation, owing to I the character ot the man appointed to make It, had been exposed, he says Mr. Grout's deputy ordered a new Investigation, which was and the result handed to Mr. Grout "Why," asks Mr. George, "has it hot been made public?" He continues: I can draw but one conclusion from what seems to me to be the shameless act of treason ot which Mr.

Grout has been guilty. As a raadi-dais of the Fusion forces against Tammany Mr. Grout intended to do hi full duty to the public by. disclosing the cvrrapt relations ot tbe Tammany Dock Board. The cunning and trickery of Murphy have prevented this re-, suit by- the bribe of a nomination to Mr.

Ureut. The supreme Issue of this campaign Is to keep the gratters out of the City Government. Decent citlsens must unite tor this purpose. At the first hostile i mention of Mr. Grout's name there- was an outburst I of mingled cheering and hisses.

R. Fulton Cutting half rose in his seat, looked around at bis shouting followers, and smiled broadly, city Chamberlain E. R. Gould and-Gustav U. Schwab applauded along with the rest, and Everett P.

Wheeler appeared very pleased with the sentiments expressed around him. i Julius Henry Cohen, one of the district leaders, during the reading of the letter, rose to a question of privilege. He saldi Mr. Chairman, I claim that It is not proper in a borough convention td question the fitness ot any candidate already nominated for a city office by this (organisation." This was greeted with hisses and shouts of Sit down! and Choke it offl The Chairman replied promptly: Under the circumstances I rule that the point of privilege la not well taken." Mr. Coakley supplemented his reading! by saying that he and the rest ot Mr.

George's followers were glad, now to second Mn Sulzberger's nomination, but be suggested that "in case of any future deliberations looking toward changes In the ticket the City Committee should consider the advisability of placing under the Cltlsens' Union emblem the name of a man close to the laboring classes, who would aid us to Victory at the polls." Mr Cohen. Coroner Goldenkrans, and Julius Biumberg also seconded tbe nomination, and after the, vote had been taken the conventioned adjourned. GRUBER HITS CITIZENS'. UNION. Republicans Nominate Bennett for Justice of 12th District Municipal Court Kremer.

Chosen in 13th District The names of Grout and Forn.es were hissed last night at the Republican Convention which nomlnatediW. S. Bennett ror Justice of the new Twelfth District Municipal Court. During he speechraaktng Leader Abraham Grulier declared the action of Grout and -Femes to be he basest political treachery" he ever heard of. The delegates met In jColonial HalL ne Hundred and First Street and Colurcius Avenue.

Among other things Mr. Gruber said: The Cltisens' Union in the west side to be wedded to Tammany HalL a I Whose aid it Is seeking to oeieat our publican. candidates for the Judgeship and the Assembly." 1l Mr. Gruber added that in the Citizens Union Convention, which nominated Alfrd P. W.

Seaman for tbe Justiceship of the Twelfth District Municipal Court. It bad been stated that Matty Donohue, the Tammany leader, would support Mr. Seaman. He said he did. not want the "taint of the Grout-Fornes treachery Judge Bennett's renomipation for Munlci-pel Court Justice and Mr.

Gruber's remark? In the convention are regarded as settling the talk about a compromise between the Cltlsens' Union organization of the district and the Gruber It had been said that Mr. Gruber. upon being assured that the Citizens' Union would ratify Mr. Bennett's name, had agreed to arrange for the Cltisens' Union to have the Asumbly nominees of the Twenty-first and Twenty-second Districts. It became known last night, however, that such an arrangement was ail off.

as Mr. the Citizens' Union candidate tor the Justiceship, said he would not withdraw In favor of Justice Bennett. In tbe Thirteenth District the Republican convention met last night and renominated Judge Julius G. Kremer for Municipal Just- r-J -REPUBLICAN CITY CONVENTION TO RECONVENE. New Nominations -for Controller and President of this Board of Aldermen to.

be Citizens' Union Plsns. Ex-Lieut, Gov Timothy L. Chairman of the; Republican City Convention of a week lago, will send out a call reconvening the delegates at Grand Central Palace on Tuesday night, This action was decided on late last night at a conference between MJ Linn Bruce. Timothy I. Woodruff, and Edward Lauterbach, who met at the Lotoi Club.

K-rt Mr. Woodruff will again call the delegates to order and the reading of the minutes of the previous convention will be ordered. They will be 'declared inaccurate and, Incorrect on two counts, One, that they were signed by but one Secretary, George R. Manchester, whereas they should have been signed under the, law by all the Secretaries, and, in tact; all the permanent officers of the convention, and in this latter connection It will be declared that they also lack the signature of Chairman Woodruff. The other point will be that the recording df the motion toi adjourn was not properly done, and It will be made by Leader William A.

Cromble of the; Nineteenth District, who will explain thati when he moved to adjourn the Chair asked him if he meant subject to the call of the Chair or sine die," and that he thereupon specified the former. And Chairman Woodruff will declare that he adjourned the convention subject to the all of the Chair." Then It win be moved that the convention rescind the nominations of Messrs. Low, Grout, and Fornes. and make new worn! nation beginning i with the new nomination of Mayor Low and following with the nomination candidates for Controller and President of tbe Board of For these nominations five men were considered last night by the conferrees at the Lotos Club J. Edward Swanstrom, Joseph C-Hendrlx, R.

Fulton Cutting, and Julian Fairchlld for Controller, and Herman A. Mets for President of the Board of Aldermen. Ail except Mr, Cutting are Brooklyn men. j. They are independent It was said that Mr Mets probably will be named for President of the Board of and that Mr.

Swanstrom. instead of being selected; will remain as the Fusion candidate for President of Brooklyn Borough. The Executive Committee of the Citizens' Union held a long and' protracted meeting late yesterday afternoon, the matter onder discussion being the replies of Grout and Fornes to. the letter of, R. Fulton Cutting.

Practically no decision was 'The letters were gone! over, paragraph by. paragraph. and Were generally, ducussed. After the meeting, which adjourned at i2W o'clock, R- Fulton CutUng said that it had been decided to refer the whole, matter to the, Citlsens' Union City Committee, which will be called in a special meeting to-night at 8 o'clock at i the old headquarters, 34 Union Square. It is understood that the City Committee Will receive no instructions from the Executive Committee, but.

will be left entirety to decide th matter of ousting Grout and Fornes. i Mr. Cutting, when asked, said: "There is nothing that I can-give out except the meeting to-morrow night. I feel that I cannot discuss thia matter now." Mr. Cutting was arked.what he had to say regarding the statement of Mr.

Grout that the Controller believed the Citizens" Union had neither the legal nor the moral right to oust him from the Fusion ticket rOf course we have the 'right," quickly replied Mr. Cutting. "We are legally advised that way, iWe can oust any one from the ticket at any time, as we nominate by petition only, and therefore can do what we please. Mr. Grout is wrong.

can oust him If we see fit," i -RESCUED FROM OHIO MOB. OXFORD. Ohio, Oci' jl.A mob "to-night broke open the JaU and took Joseph Spivey to an elm tree one square away, on which Henry. Corbln was lynched in 1832. Spivey was-strung up and let down to pray.

A second time be was strung up and let down, and while be; was pleading for time to write his wife Deputy Sheriff Brennan and a tew assistants rushed forward, cut the rope, and dashed down the street with the prisoner.) He was rushed to tbe Jail, and baa been spirited out of town. John 8plvey. his brother, is dying with a bullet through his head. A stranger who lives at Monroe, Ohio, is also fatally i I -The trouble 'arose out of a disturbance created by John Spivey and Joseph Spivey. who came over from Kentucky with some friends and began shooting on the streets of Oxford during the progress of a fair.

The village Marshal and his deputy attempted to arrest them and were both' wounded. i- i The crowd theri pursued the 8plvey. brothers with shotguns. The men were overtaken -after Joseph bad been shot in the right side and John knocked unconscious with a stone. A stranger, who refused to give his name, was shot in the abdomen.

WAGE CHANGE AT HOMisTEAD. PITTSBURG. Oct. l.2Jotlces have been posted in the Carnegie Company mills- at Homestead announcing that there will be a readjustment In. wages on Jan.

The notices were agreed upon when the men went to work In the big plant after the big Homeitead strike in 1CJ The company then promised to deal equitably with the men as individuals ana to allow three months' notice of a change In wages, so the men could bunt other employment if they so dslred. The men argue that the company would not terminate tbe scale to raise wages and that It must be a reduction. i The converting mill at the big plant was yesterday boarded up and notice was posted that It would not reopen this year. The assistant superintendent of the mill has been released from-duty and all tbe men laid off. Several other mills are running only a single turn, i i SAYS STEIKEIIS STONED HOUSES.

Spttial Tie A'rw Ypr Thus. MINNEAPOLIS. Oct. 1 Striking flour millers are resorting to violence, according to a man who says his bouse wax stoned last r.lght snd all glass broken tut of -tfin-days. He is an! oiler la one of the mills, and when warned to quit work, refused.

The police have been jjnable to find the guilty parties, -1 Thirty-four millers brought here from Duiuth to take the places of strikers re-fus-d to go to Work this morning because they say the mill owners had misrepresents the true state of affairs, saying that there was no strike In the mlii- They returned to Duluth. after a fight for thrlr tmrKug. which, bad been taken to the 1 Several flour mills are grinding on a email scale, and the green help employed Is learning the business, so that the daily output Is rapidly increasing. i IOO.OO Pacific Coaet Points SO.DO. The Lehigh Valley connt--is with alt liaea, Vil and Lv4 ErvaJwty.

mm Sim i FOIffl ran i 3. i. J. Martin Joins in Vain with I-; Bitter Speech Is Directed at the many Leader. McClellan's Nomination Made Unanimous, but Brooklyn Men Threaten to Belt Grout imd Femes Facing not alone a threat of a bolt on the part of the Brooklyn Democracy but a re- volt within the Tammany organization, Charles F.

Murphy forced through his slate In the Democratic City Convention at Carnegie HalL which was la session until an early hour 'this morning. Congressman George B. "McClellan was nominated for Mayor. Edward M. Grout for Controller, and Charles V.

Femes for President of the Board or Aldermen. Beports that it was the InUnUoa of.i.fr. Murphy to permit Messrs, Grout and Fornes to be defeated on the floor were ex-i: plained when James: J. Martin, Chairman of the Democratic City Committee. Joined with the men from Brooklyn la opposing the nominations of Messrs Grout and Fornes.

Mr. Martin, who bad been a rival of Mr. Murphy for the Tammany leadership, declared be could not vote for the Fusion It was felt among those who-attended the convention that bis action meant that the fight of Mr. Murphy to crush the McLaughlin machine was ia be made the opportunity among bis foes in the Wigwam to overthrow bis, Mr, Murphy himself was made the target of a bitter attack. Martin W.

Llttletoiv speaking for the Brooklyn men. Invoked the names of John Kelly and Richard Cro- ker, quoted from bitter remarks made by -Mr. Grout -upon. Tacvmany, and demanded that the present leader arise and defend hla candidate. Mr.

Littleton's speech created a genuine sensation In the convention. He bad directed bis remarks directly at Mr. Murpby, ffho occupied a prominent place, pointing )is finger at tbe Tammany leader, 'as be made his bitter remarks. Mr. Littleton was followed by Mr.

Martin, who, in vigorous language, stated bis opposition to the Indorsement of Messrs. Grout and Fornes for the offices of Controller and Preeldent of the Board of Aldermen, -spectiveiy. -Daring. the 'addressee of both Littleton and Martin there was a perfect furor In the convention, and many were tt doubt as to whether Mr. Murpby was not in the way to suffer a defeat which iwould put an end to his leadership.

But the expected break did not -xome. Mr, Martin -succeeded to carrying osJy five votes with him from Manhattan against Messrs. and Fornes, and they were, declared -tbe choice of the convention. Motions to make their nominations were bowled down by the Brookiycltes in each case. I The Brooklyn delegation presented the -name of Judge William J.

Gaynor as their choice for Mayor, but when they were da- sated, they bowed gracefully to the inevitable. Ex -Bridge Commissioner John L. -Shea moving to make the nomination of Mr. McClellan unanimous in a speech whtch indicated that whatever the bitterness there had been in the WUioughby Street organi- saUons antagonism to McClellan's candidacy was not as deep as bad been sup- The Brooklyn organisation proposed Julian D. Fairchlld for Controller, as against Mr.

Grout, and Herman A. Mets for President of tbe Board of Aldermen, as against Mr. STORY OF THE Great Crowd's Wild Struggle' Before the Hall Was OpenedPolice Un- able to Cope with Situation, For more than an hour before the doors -of Carnegie Hall were opened crdwds filled Seventh Avenue, Fifty -sixth and Fifty-seventh Streets, and tried to get In. Notts ot the doors was opened until 7:13, and the police arrangements were Inadequate ito cope with the great crowd. Tbe Fifty-sixth Street entrance bad been designated as tbe press entrance, but no one bearing press or stage tickets could get lu, aud those who made complaint to Inspector Walsh, who was In command, were threatened with having their beads clubbed oft for their temerity.

One hundred policemen were on hand, but bad a hard time to keep things right, when their superior finally gave orders to cpeij the doors. At the Fifty-seventh Street entrance several people were badly trampled, while at tbe Fifty-sixth Street door, which, was opened an hour and a quarter late, tbe git-nation was absolutely dangerous, Later inquiry brought to light the fact that Police Commissioner Greene had been notlfWl on the telephone in the afternoon about the arrangements, but tbe reason for the police Inefficiency was not disclosed. In many instances the police refused to recognize press tickets, and one reporter had to gtt in through a cellar window at ttr paying ft to a policeman. HAD TO CALL MORE POLICE. By o'clock, however, the street crowds bad bees disposed of and the bulk of the people had been seated.

Before this, bow-ever, more police bad to be summoned, as Inspector Weizb confessed himself unable to handle the crowd with the men at fits command. In the utter confusion which reigned for a time men and women were crushed and many were so roughly handled that they i presented a much battered appearance when they finally got into tbe haL i AS soon as tae aoora wm opcimu me mu began rapidly to fill, and in tlve minute the toomoHt of the four balconlM wj crowded, and In a few minute more tbe one under was packed with a double row standing behind tne last row ot seats, im boxes In the two balconies beneath were filled aore leisurely, end there were many ladles among the occupants. Admission to the orchestra seats wys given at and the tlelegavee who were assigned to them were soon on hand. The first anneunccment of the evening was made by Senator Thomas F. Grady.

There must be no smoking," he deciirrd from the stage, and his announcement rji-parntly was not appreciated by he occupants of the top gaiiery. At the band atrock wp "The Bariner." everybody stsnOing up, The first call for a hand was ma3e by a ton-gallery Tsin, who shouted out. Tfcr-e cr.era for TammanyiX and the it-s rvaponild ith vigor. 1ttn sometw ey caged, "Three cheeru for George il. Ho Clailan! but the response was so Teeb and sx-nttered that those seated on the gtnxe exchanged irlanwa.

1 then and the aca of fa- above tl festooned g'leru-s aiaJe the scene a pictires4ue en. I- 7.