The Tennessean from Nashville, Tennessee on January 23, 1938 · Page 53
Get access to this page with a Free Trial

A Publisher Extra Newspaper

The Tennessean from Nashville, Tennessee · Page 53

Nashville, Tennessee
Issue Date:
Sunday, January 23, 1938
Page 53
Start Free Trial

;! ! I J Only Simple Country Girls, but They Fished So Skilfully in the "Lonely-Hearts" Columns of the Matrimonial Magazines the Wise Judge Sentenced Them to Five Years of Seclusion on the Farm "-V Frances Held, the 18-Year-Old Member f the Cupid Column. Quartet. Who Win MlM the Dancing Whkk She Enjoyed So Muck. "M AYBE we were Just a little bit guilty but thli punishment is awful. I don't know how we are going to be able to it and it for five yean." Miaa Ella Izelle Reid said this as ahe viewed with alarm the Court's five peration. have already thought of something which offer a ray of hope, one day a week. Why not go to church r 1 - I year plan of extreme goodness Imposed True this would on three pretty Alabama sisters. With out any vacation or even a day off from this unmitigated good behavior, they must stay in or hear their lonely farmhouse home way off on R. F. D. route 2 out of Athens, Alabama. One littfe slip from grace and the fair culprit may be sent to serve her two-year suspended sentence In prison. The offense for which Ella Izelle, 27 years old and her three sisters. Prances Reid, 18, Mrs. F. S. Reid Barley, 32, and Mary E. Reid, 21, were "Just a little bit guilty," consisted of using Uncle Sam's mails to defraud lovesick men in various parts of the country for four years by means of fake marriage proposals. Mary escaped the fate of the other three by entering an insane asylum at Tuscaloosa before the trial. But one of the neighbors remarked: "Maybe she was just a little bit that way before those G-men came pestering around and proved it on her." Her three sisters are afraid that they, too, will lose their minds, if they really have to be "so terrible good" as Judge John McDuffle at Huntsvllle, Alabama, said they must be for all those dreary years. Here are some of the discouraging restrictions which the young women must face. Under no circumstances are they permitted to leave Limestone County, without written permission of the United States District Attorney. Ella Izelle promptly Informed him that she had a nice Job in Detroit but that assertion did not get her anything but a faint smile nor anywhere but back on the farm. There is plenty of fun to be had in that county for such attractive girls but, living as they do, more than a mile from the nearest neighbor, they have to go out and get it and this, too, is forbidden. They must not appear in public, which means no dances and all three are "dance crazy." They must not go to the movies because this is also construed as a public appearance and they are forbidden to have "dates." However, young men may call at the farm, as long as they behave properly. This is some consolation to the two single sisters but not very much. It is always a question what proportion of times a young man should take a girl out to dance, movies or dinner, to the times he visits her house at no expense to himself. In this case there la no question. The lucky boys get a five-year moratorium on their part of the obligation and everyone knows what follows moratoriums. The chief advantage of dances, corn-husking parties and such things is that new men will see the girls all dressed up and their eyes afire with excitement and ask to be introduced, thus causing desirable competition for swains who might otherwise not appreciate their value. Necessity being aa usual, the mother of invention, the girls, in des- ,be a public appearance but to curb such a desire for spiritual uplift, would be interfering with one's right to worship, and probably unconstitutional. The stay - at home edict falls moat heavily on Frances who is only 18, just entering the five gayest, most irresponsible runabout years of a woman's life. Frances must spend them sewing, knittlnghoelng potatoes, tending the geese, chickens and cows. "What a life!" laments the girl, pointing at their humble, frame house. "We don't know whether to call it the convent or the reformatory. I'll be an old maid of 23, if I live through it Girls of tender age are supposed to obtain their parents' consent before marrying. In this case Frances 'and even Ella who is not so tender, will probably have to get the consent of the District Attorney, Suppose the young man who wants to marry one of them lives in another county or State and wishes to take his bride where he earns his living. Win the court permit her to escape from its jurisdiction or will the husband only have a chance to visit his wife week-ends for the first five years of their wedded life? Of course some shiftless husbands would be only too yrlad to live that long in the wife's home. Even worse seems to be the predicament in which the oldest sister, Mrs. Barley finds herself. She already had a husband on the place and could not have married any of the lovelorn men she bamboozled, without committing bigamy. One would think that she would be guiltier than Frances who started in on the racket when not quite 14, but all the sisters agreed that they were equally to blame so the court gave them all the same medicine. Mr. Barley presumably did not know of his wife's correspondence flirtations or he too would be under five year sentence to stay home and behave himself. Since he is an Innocent party there Is some question of his constitutional rights as a husband. It is quite possible that if Mr. Barley could move Into another State, get himself a nice job and demand that the wife of his bosom come to his home there, the ' United States Supreme Court would rule that no man, even a lower court Judge has the power to keep them apart. However, Mr. Barley has not taken any noticeable steps In that direction. When asked what he thinks of the situation he usually replies: "It will be hard to bear, but the Judge knows best." Some of Mr. Barley's friends are mean enough to suggest that it is not hard for him to bear, in fact they make Ella Izelle Reid, Eldest of the Unmarried Sisters, Who Admitted "Maybe We Were Just a Utile Bit Guilty." out that ' he is getting the best break a husband possibly could have. What other man with a p retty healthy wife, only 32 years old, can go about his business, serenely knowing Just where his wife is? He knows she must be at home attending to it and to his child because she hasn't anything more interesting to do, instead of running around, heaven knows where and with whom. Mr. Barley hasn't any business at the moment but he goes around serenely, Just the same. This alone would put him in a class of specially-privileged husbands, but that is not all. Most husbands must take their wives out reasonably often or be guilty of cruelty and liable to divorce and alimony. Mr. Barley is exempt because he cannot take his wife to any public place without exposing her to that two years in prison and perhaps himself be liable to a charge of contempt of court. He is a law-abiding citzen and would not think of such a thing. At the same time there are no restrictions against his going where he pleases and the fact that his wife cannot be with him to see what he is up to is her fault and misfortune, not his. Of course she might take a quick peek In the door of dance hall or movie Just long enough to see if he is with someone -she disapproves and not be ifuilty of a public appearance provided she does not make a public scene. However, there la nothing to prevent Mr. Barley when he steps out, from stepping: Into the next county where Mrs. Barley dares not follow. What other husband has a wife whose jurisdiction is limited to Just one county t Her two younger sisters, being spinsters, have the privilege of entertaining such boy friends as may choose to call but Mrs. Barley has not. For a married woman, unchaperoned male callers, except ' the doctor and Judge John McDuffle, of Huntsvllle, Who Imposed the Unusual Penalty. minister, would not be r e s p e c table and anything not r e s p ect-able is distinctly a viola-tlon of the probation. It might be con- V there 1$ Plenty of Fun to Be Had in the County, but the Girh Would Have to Go Out to Find It. The Judge Says They May Not Enjoy Them-selvei Publicly, So They Must Live for Five Yeart as Though Their lonely Home Wat Covered by a Cage. f i t The Lonely Farmhouse on the Rural Route Near Athens, Alabama, Wales Has Become Virtually a Prison. ' Ail! Mary Reid, Who Escaped the Odd Fire-Tear Penalty Because at the Time the 8iaters Were Indicted She Went to the Insane Asylum, strued as going even beyond that. If Mrs. Barley should neglect their child, a son of school age, or be cruel to any of the farm animals, she would hardly be the 100 good girl she la expected to be. Conceivably it might get her into trouble to be cruel to her own hus band. Her only boy friends muat be that husband aad her son to whom she must be good for the next five years or else. Therefore the future looks quite as black to her as to her younger sisters. For nearly four years the postmaster at Athens wondered why four sisters who lived in a tumble down house on a neglected farm ' and never traveled, should have such a heavy mail from all parts of the country and even Europe. He did not know that the letters the girls sent contained photographs but their correspondents sent large ones sometimes also packages of various sixes and money orders which were cashed at ''the Post Office. One day he mentioned the fact to a post office inspector who thought t queer enough to start the government detectives investigating. , . They visited some of the correspondents and found each fondly cherishing a picture of one of the four girls and the delusion that he was going to marry her as soon as a few difficulties, mostly financial, were straightened out. The poor girls invariably needed a new dress or shoes or a payment on the "fllyver," or bus fare before they could come to the arms of the waiting lover. The sum wheedled out of any one victim always was small, apparently never as much as $100. Therefore when, after the ' money was sent, there were delays due to sickness, pare n t a 1 opposition, etc., until finally the dupe gave up, he thought the girl had just changed her mind. Had she been a fraud, he felt sure she would have tried to get more. Having frankly told at the start that she was very poor the victim knew there was no chance of getting his money or other gifts back. Though the four conspirators made no big killings there was, a steady stream of small ones which paid better than farming and was much less laborious. Had it not been for the postmaster's curiosity the girls might have kept on collecting their bachelor tax for the rest of their lives. Getting names of "suckers" was the easiest part of It. In 1933 the girls received a free copy of a magazine called "Cupid's International Messen- . ger" which specializes In husband-and-wife-wanted advertisements. The girls saw such interesting offers as the following: "Love-sick young man, age 20, height 5-9, healthy, good-looking art student, wishes to marry some rich girl or one with home and means who could help me in my art career... or else would like to meet a woman older than me, who, seeking companionship, would love andhelp me; am sincere." Or: "Here I am all alone, for some one to call me their own. Kind-hearted 0 193. by American Weekly, Inc. Great Britain Rights Reserre. man. age 41, weight 165. Height 5-10, affectionate and fond of home life. Don't use tobacco or liquor. I want to hear from any lady that Is true-hearted and has kind and loving disposition and is willing to make happiness1 in home for. always. . ." The girls answered the advertisements and though not very good spellers, their letters plus their pictures got the money. The following is a letter Mary Ellen Reid wrote (before she went to Tuscaloosa) to her picture boy friend Leo Derrick m Ohio. "Dearest Leo: Today I got your sweet letter and you can amagian how proud I was to hear from you speak in the kind way of me being sick. I appreciate it dear I feel some better with my cold but my back and side is bothering me this evening. "I gave Mrs. Barley the money order and she said she hated to take it but Mr. Barley again layed off and they ' couldn't get no cash now. And they would repay you when they get to Bellingham. "Well you once made me mad as you spoke as If you doubted my word, but I have forgot it but don't do it any more. Leo I could not give you up as I love you truly. I will close dear and lie down. I'm sick. Will write more next time. Love Mary Ellen," Ella Izelle touched Mr. Winfield 8. Dean of Alexandria, Virginia, for ,a pair of slippers and two dresses as follows: , "How's my darling Winfield? Well Winfield, I think I had rather have a pair of white slippers. I wear 6V4 D or a 7 in B width. I like a low Cuban heel, in a sports wear. 1 Just look through a catalogue and saw two cheap everyday dressea If you are not able to buy It, you can leave it off. Love Ella." The Government did not have to use Its witnesses and letters because Mary retired to an institution and the other three sisters pleaded "Nolo Contendere." This means, "I dont want to dispute the charge" and, though not precisely a confession, la only about a hair from it. The Judge then gave them two year sentences, suspended during five years of behavior that must be almost angelic. Buch probation may seem harsh but Uncle Sam must be stern about two things, counterfeiting and fraudulent use of the malls. It is the only way to control those otherwise easy crimes. 11 !i ! 1 1 i i

What members have found on this page

Get access to

  • The largest online newspaper archive
  • 18,100+ newspapers from the 1700s–2000s
  • Millions of additional pages added every month

Publisher Extra Newspapers

  • Exclusive licensed content from premium publishers like the The Tennessean
  • Archives through last month
  • Continually updated

Try it free