The News Journal from Wilmington, Delaware on October 24, 1999 · Page 17
Get access to this page with a Free Trial

A Publisher Extra Newspaper

The News Journal from Wilmington, Delaware · Page 17

Wilmington, Delaware
Issue Date:
Sunday, October 24, 1999
Page 17
Start Free Trial

Broken TPUSt: A special report OCT. 24, 1999 SUNDAY NEWS JOURNAL A17 ndians want to control their economic de stiny Judge has ordered $500 million in trust accounts to be settled by U.S. By PAULINE ARRILLAGA Associated Press HEART BUTTE, Mont. -Josephine Spotted Bear Wildgun knows nothing of courtrooms. She is 75 years old with a sixth-grade education. When a stranger strikes up a conversation, she giggles, flashing a gap-toothed grin, and burrows her chin in her chest. She lives a simple life in a peaceful place far from Washington, D.C., and the legal battle between American Indians and the federal government over mismanagement of Indian trust accounts. But what she does know is that she is a landowner and has little to show for it. "Somebody else is getting rich on it," she says. A federal judge this month ordered a mediator to help negotiate the settling of 300,000 trust accounts worth more than $500 million. The decision came in a 1996 class-action lawsuit against the Interior Department and its Bureau of Indian Affairs. The lawsuit, the largest class-action ever brought by Indians, made headlines after the judge this year held Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt and then-Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin in contempt for "egregious misconduct" in failing to hand over documents to the plaintiffs. Beneath all the courtroom rhetoric lies a tragic tale of history, deceit and survival. It is the story of people like Josephine Spotted Bear Wildgun, and places like Heart Butte. Heart Butte, Mont. On the southern edge of the Blackfeet Indian Reservation in northern Montana, a mountain shaped like a heart rises above golden plains where cattle and horses graze. It is the anchor of a community called Heart Butte. Heart Butte doesn't have much. There are three churches, Baptist, Methodist and Roman Catholic, a school, a senior citizens center, the health department, a post office and a volunteer fire department. Its only grocery store and gas station closed years ago. Now the closest are a 30- minute drive across the reservation. The only recent development, besides a new sanctuary for the Catholic church, is the row of federally subsidized houses that greets visitors on their way into town. Welfare is the primary source of income for the 800 or so people who live here. A block off the main road, around the corner from the subsidized housing, Wildgun lives with her daughter-in-law and grandchild in a three-bedroom plywood house the color of dirt. Wildgun lives on $374 a month in Supplemental Security Income and whatever money her son can send home. When her husband died five years ago, she had to borrow $500 to pay for the funeral. "When I get money," she explains, "I've got my phone, my lights and gas. Those three I pay for. Other things, even groceries, are harder to afford. It's difficult to conceive that this woman who struggles to buy. food owns an interest in 8,718 acres of land, some leased for grazing, most for oil and gas exploration. A computer printout of all her holdings unfurls to almost 6 feet in length. For this she also receives income. The checks arrive sporadically, every four to six months. Every once in a while they're as high as $200 or $300. More often they're for much less: $36.75 in September 1998; another, in July 1998, for all of $2.82. "I'm sure there's a lot of money she should be getting," her daughter-in-law, Diana, says as she tickles her baby girl on the floor of the cramped living room. "I think they're cheating her really big." "They" are the Interior Department and the Bureau of Indian Affairs, which for more than 100 years have managed Indian trust accounts consisting of lease revenue, court settlements and royalties from the sale of petroleum, timber and other resources off 11 million acres of land. In addition to the 300,000 individual Indian accounts that are part of the lawsuit, the government oversees 1,500 accounts worth more than $2.5 billion for 338 tribes. The trust accounts date back to 1887, when Congress carved up Indian reservations and distributed 'K': i is1'" ' ---n, liliill liiiiililHI ItIf APRAY OZMAN Josephine Spotted Bear Wildgun, in her home on the Blackfeet Indian Reservation near Heart Butte, Mont., lives on $374 a month in Supplemental Security Income even though she holds interest in nearly 9,000 acres of land. "In any Indian community it's just been something that we grew up with, our parents questioning and wondering why they were not getting paid." Elouise Cobell, a Blackfeet member the land to tribal members in 160-, 80- or 40-acre parcels. Leftover land was declared surplus and sold to non-Indians, resulting in the eventual loss of 90 million acres. The intent of the allotment law, known as the Dawes Act, was to assimilate Indians into white society by dissolving tribalism and forcing them to become independent farmers, while at the same time opening up large tracts of reservation land to white farmers. "At the heart of it was the idea . . . that once the Indians became citizens and no longer dependent on the government, then the so-called 'Indian problem' would disappear," says L.G, Moses, professor of American Indian history at Oklahoma State University. "The only real result you got out of the Dawes Act was the loss of land accompanied by an assault on Indian cultural values." By the early 1900s, the Dawes Act had proved a failure. Indians' land sat idle, while their white neighbors longed to use the acreage. By 1910 the government began leasing Indian property to white farmers for grazing. Oil exploration began soon after, and so did the problems. There was no accounts receivable system to determine whether Indians were being paid, and when Indian landowners died, there generally were no wills. That meant the land was divided among hundreds or thousands of heirs, creating a record-keeping night mare. Because of a lack of oversight, many Indians suspect oil companies and others have underre-ported what they've taken from the land and gotten away with it for years. "In any Indian community it's just been something that we grew up with, our parents questioning and wondering why they were not getting paid," says Elouise Cobell, a Blackfeet member and the lead plaintiff in the class-action lawsuit. The problems gained little notice until the 1980s, when people such as Cobell began complaining to Congress and numerous audits documented the severity of the problem: Records had mmamm been lost or ruined; auditors couldn't locate 50,000 account holders whose trusts totaled almost $50 million. One account with no name was worth $1 million. The government has long admitted the trust funds are in disarray, and recently installed a $60 million computer system to manage the accounts better. Indians want a complete overhaul of the system and contend the government owes account holders at least $10 billion misplaced because of poor record-keeping. "What we hear all the time is, 'Oh, most of these accounts only have $25 or 'x' amount,' " Cobell says. "What does $25 mean to a family? Maybe she's able to cook a meal and share that with her family for once. That $25 stretches out to be much more than 25 bucks." The Bureau of Indian Affairs estimates there are 7,700 Blackfeet with trust accounts, although Cobell says the number is closer to all the 14,700 enrolled tribal members, of whom about two-thirds live on the reservation, amid a 70 percent unemployment rate. Here, where the average monthly income for a family of four is just $600, restitution could provide a fresh start for many, Blackfeet leaders say. It could also mean attaining what the government tried to manufacture so long ago: economic independence. "We could start buying our land back ... work the land ourselves," says Blackfeet Treasurer Joe Ger-vais. "If we do it ourselves, we prove that we can succeed. We take control of dur own destiny." Deluxe Oil Furnance Line sjjjg jl I III"; 4 -Mi T 1W Reliable comfort year after year all in one great package. financing Available - Limited time only 90 days same as cash through dealer with approved credit Protection Plus - Extended Service Contracts-free for limited time 91599 thur 1 11599 through participating Ruud dealers only IMMmMMffJw Wilmington 656-5110 Newcastle 323-1596 AFFORDABLE heating & air conditioning, inc. Newcastle 328-9220 HUTS, CRMTS & FLLlAlS FREE SILK FLOWER AnnAiirmr uiitu tuc PURCHASE OF SUPPLIES! HtUJilJfY "& WJULUE EWEHY PHY 2 oz. Apple Barrel Acrylic Paint ea. Value 86( Ready-To-Finish Birdhouse or Stools Tfea Reg. $5.88 Hones Sweatshirt Assorted Colors S-U-L-XL $ 5 ea. 2XL-3X1 $9.99 Daisy Kingdom Doll Clothes 99 $6 12" Reg. $7.99 i an $0.99 10 u Reg. $9.99 I pound Candy Melts 17 Flavored colors 1 .79 ea. Reg. $1.99 Seasonal Flags I 3" X 6" Scented Pillar ndles $1.50 I ea. Reg. $1.99 Gas Match Lighter $1.49 1 ea. Reg. $1.99 Pkg of 25 Mini B2P9 Glue cry sticks V 68' Poles S Brockets Available Reg. $1 .24 Silver-look Wire Candle Holder $4 ea. Fits 6" x 6" Candle LdzillZ T ZiftSSIyMwiiiiS ti hi w nZ'i ill Gel Roller Pens Assorted Colors lo chose horn! ,1s Reg. $1 ea ram; 2 100 Pag 1 I" Photo Album In Am ea. Reg. $3.88 1 1 Paper Eager Scissors x SQ.79 ea. Reg. $4.49 I Mini Value Pack Photo Albums Paper $0 79 $1 mm ea. 1 ea. Dresi It Up Buttons $ l ii I ea. Reg. $1.99 32" x 40" Mat Board $99 n ir ea. Reg. $4.29 Special Selection Art Pads tire B eo. RUSTfeOLEUM Painter's Touch Paint 12 Ounces $1 .99 I ea. Reg. $2.44 Your Choice Tote or Apron $1.99 I ea. Reg. $2.88 25 yard Tulle Rolls $1.99 I ea. Reg. $3.88 m f i lit mum 36" Dragon $0.99 JSm ea. Special Selection 18" Seasonal Clothes Pin Wood Shapes Remdqer lil Ii 2$Q $0.99 for ea Reg. $1 .99 ea Reg. $3.99 Door Chip Boxes Sleigh 2 Sizes to choose from! $7 88'. Reg. $4.88 eo Value $2.79 Wood Shapes Reg 25( ea 1 Snowman or Santa on a Stake w $1.99 Reg. $5.99 mum 16" X 20" Fuzzy Poster $0.99 Ma ea. Pokeman Golden Books $0.99 Mm ea. Reg. $3.99 New! We have Power Bead Bracelets $1.50 I ea. Dover Books or Sandylion Stickers as? m m ea. Dried Holiday Bouquet $C.99 mw ea. Ivy Garland 4h $4.99 1 ea. Holly Bush 661 Reg. 99C 9' Fall Leaf Garland 3 ea. Reg. $3.99 Electric or Battery Operated Brass Candles Pine-Uke 26" Holiday Wreath $4.99 II ea. Reg. $5.99 Wreath Hangers 77 1 ea 300 Counl link M Seasonal SWesMaife $1.79 $Q.99 I ea. eo. Replacement Bulbs 2 for $1 WE Will NOT BE UNDERSOLD! Just bring any current competitor's craft ad to our registers and we will beat their advertised price by 10. off sales are restricted from offer e honor all competitors coupons for individual item savings. Excludes custom framing coupons. 1 off sales do not include clearance items SALE BEGINS THURSDAY OCTOBER 21 ST; ENDS WEDNESDAY OCTOBER 27TH STOP IN AND PICK UP A COPY OF THIS MONTH'S CALENDAR OF CRAFT CLASSES! Wilmington Kirkwood Plaza Center Kirkwood Highway (302) 994-9016 Man Set 9.30 9.30; Sun 10 6 Broomall PA Broomall Plaza West Chester Pike (Rt 3) (610) 353-1117 Mon-Sal 9:30 9 30,Sun 10-6 Downingtown Brandywine Square Lancaster Avenue (610)8733150 Mon-Sat 9 9, Sun 10 6 , Dover, DE The Centre at Dover N. Dupont Hwy (Rt 13) (302) 674-9870 Man-Sat 9:30-9; Sun 10-6

What members have found on this page

Get access to

  • The largest online newspaper archive
  • 18,200+ newspapers from the 1700s–2000s
  • Millions of additional pages added every month

Publisher Extra Newspapers

  • Exclusive licensed content from premium publishers like the The News Journal
  • Archives through last month
  • Continually updated

Try it free