The Sun from New York, New York • Page 28

8 THE SUN, SUNDAY, DECEMBER 20, 1914. PUBLIC TO BLAME FOR BAD SINGING AT THE OPERA Shouting and Shrieking Tones of Singers at Recent Performance of "Die Wal-kuere" Audience Applaud Faults The Difficulty of Singing a iVJorart Opera Concerts--Recitals---Notc of Music Events 6 THE WEEK Metropolitan Opera Home. MONDAY "La Traviata," Mme. Hempel; Messrs. Botta and Atnato.

WEDNESDAY "Alda," Mmes. Destinn and Ober; Messrs. Martlnelli, Amato and Didur. THURSDAY "Manon," Miss Farrar; Messrs. Caruso and Seottl.

FRIDAY, 2:30 P. M. "Haensel und Gretel," Mmes. Schumann and Matt-feld; Messrs. Goritz and Relss.

Ballet divertissements. m. "Tannhaeuser," Mmes. Gadski and Matzenauer; Messrs. Urlus, Weil and Braun.

SATURDAY, 2 P. M. "Carmen," Miss Farrar, Miss Bori; Messrs. Caruso, AmMo and Rothier. CONCERTS OF THE WEEK.

SUNDAY People's Symphony Society, Carnegie Hall, 3:15 P. M. Symphony Society, Aeolian Hall, 3 P. M. Opera concert.

Metropolitan Opera House, 8:30 P. M. TUESDAY Kneisel Quartet, Aeolian Hall. 8:15 P. M.

SATURDAY Concert by United Swedish Singing Societies, Carnegie Hall, 8:15 P. M. nr w. J. linxnKntnx.

-j-UIKHlS ls nltognther too much bad I sinirtntr at the opera. I Unfortunately this condition Is likely to continue because the majority of those who -support operatic performances In this town do not make the effort to detect the dirforetieo between good hinging and ball. Any person with a sensitive ear must be 1 nf Ii.l- amazru lo near mi; immune plause which follow mere Uiwllng und screaming at the Metropolitan Opera House. Singers who depart from the pitch at the Ilrst measure of a number and who never return to It. who produce strident and shrieking tones, who op.lt phrases into fragments und whose stertorous breathing can be heard in lh furthest parts of the theatre receive vigorous approval.

Just its If had done something beautiful. Naturally this Is alt very dtscoursglns to tho sincere singers who try to do things well. They Inevitably question themselves: "What Is the use of mudy-ng and laboring for Improvement? Who Is going to know when 1 do better?" The answer to this Is that the reword of merit In lyric art Is as certain as anything can be in this world. The arraignment of the Indolent part of the public which stands above 1 a correct one. Nevertheless the public as a whole, tickle, unreasoning.

Inexplicable and moving, as were, by some sort of blind Instinct, will turn the right about when a truly great artist up-pears and will applaud his art. Let any one lack over the, records of the past Whoso names stand out prominently? I.llh I.ehmann. Hmll Fischer, Jean and Edouard de Heszke. Nordlca. Calve, Sembrlch.

Plancon and some others of similar note. These ar-tlsts woro tho favorites of the public in their time. Who re-calls with Isatetl breath Ceppl. Oogny. Perotti.

Imbart de la Tour and a few more of that kind? Of what violinists and pianists does the world tnlk? Let the earnest singer have no fear. He will reap his reward. Hut none the less It Is a pity that tho doings at tho opera cannot be brought under tho control of a sterner public demand. It Is a pity that most of the habitues of the house hear only opera singers. They listen to them on Saturday, and on Monday morning Immediately after breakfast they hasten to one of Mr.

Bagby's muslcales to hear some of them again. And before long they will ho running Just as speedily to the Hotel Biltmore muslcales to hear them yet again. About what can be and is sometimes accomplished In the realm of pure sing- I nf nnnm fntimi.aTllls nn.i,.nL.. And I UteaaS ic thot. tK" Vaismodlol mnv.ment nntl tempestuous tie-1 clamatory disturbances that the beauty of a clean, fluent, elegant delivery, accompanied by a manifestation of cultured imagination and refined taste, might wholly esoapo their capacity for r-jrrecdatlon.

If overfed oporaeroers would iro frequently to the recitals of midh mistresses of the recital form of art as Mme. Sembrlch, Mme. Culp. Miss Ger-hardt. Mr.

VerreTirath and others accepted as song aingers they would without doubt oeaso to encourage the indolence and vocal recklessness of some of the opera singers. There ls first of all too much Uellcrw-Ing on the Metropolitan stage. Every time ft Blngcr takes a note in hts upper register and sings It at the top of his lungs without consideration of correctness of its Intonation or Its tonal quality he receives a vast quantity of np-plaiuia from peoplo who care nothing for beauty, but who love excitement and adore athletic feats. The outcome of this thing is thnt several singers have fjllen into the destructive habit of singing too loudly nil ithe time. And the result of Phis habit Is that there are now some singers w.lio ennnot sing piano when they try, which Is, of course, not often.

Hut the repetition of failure to achieve a real piano effect simply operates to drive these singers ti howling again, for they find that they ore In high favor when they do so. The recent performance of "Die Wal-kiKTo" contained a liberal amount of shouting, and even creaming. While It is true that Mme. Ilntcnti-hiUlc was a gnltletl unperson ition anil that It hail soma episodes of genuine nohlllty, as in the death announcement, It Is equally true thnt her Initial utterances wore very saddening. Not only Ol sho sing the "Ho-Jo-to-ho" call most strltlulnntly but she missed her high 11 by a good hcmltnne.

Mr. Hr.iun harked Ohroiigh some of the scenes of U'olail in amost angry and unvocil milliner: hut this perhnp.i was due to hU acceptance of the liiiyreutli tradition. eMail-llshed not by Richard hut by Siegfried Wagner, it narrated by persons who attended some of the rehearsals of the "Ring" In the lait days when Mnie. Wagner was active. In their direction ttiat the estimable widow when explaining Mage business or phrasing or What not always appealed to young PlegfrlPd: "That I lie way your father had It tlfine, was it not Of i nirM.

rtiegfiietl linew nil about It. for i the time, of production nf tht 'Ring" he wan ii yearn old. Mr, nrnun follows thn recent custom OF OPERA. of nrnklng U'ofan a peevish old man. There is very little of the koiI in this personaice, anj one cannot understand how he kept power In WnlhaHa.

"He live from everlatttinir to ever lasting, rules over oil his realm and Kovern.s all Krent nntl says Har In the "Younger Kcldu." Of course he yields to the deinnnd of Krlcka, but not because she Is a naK-Kltiff spouse. Yet this Is what the great scene, tho most pregnant scene in "Die Walknere" seems to mean as It Is now customarily enacted. The truth Is that Wotan yields to what he recoRiilzes as eternal law, which stands above nil gods. He had hoped to evade It. but that hypo Is destroyed by I'rlcka's penetration of the subterfuge.

The polcnant question "Va.s verlanjrst D11?" which the tortured god finally puts to tho representative of domestic virtue Is one of profound Krlef, almost despair. It is not the petulant outcry of nn angry husband at scoldlnc wife. Hut since Coslmx and the young Siegfried approve of this reading, who are we In tho country of tho Houyhnhma to lift our voices In. opposition? Perhaps tho worst fate that befalls the opera singer Is to be compelled to appear In a Mozart opera. Sad disclosures are then made.

Inquiring people often say, "What do musicians mean when they assert that It Is difficult to ting Mozart? It wounds perfectly simple." Precisely. That Is Just what Is tho matter with It. It Is perfectly simple. There Is no possible manner of delivering It except to sing It. The melody of Mozart Is of the clearest outline.

Its progressions are. fluent and Its phrases neatly balanced. It does not leap about through wide Intervals. It does not admit of ad libitum treatment. It cannot be declaimed In tho stylo of recltit-tlvo.

It must be sung by tho voice Just as It would bo played on a violin. There Ls nothing else to be done with It. Now. slnco producing smooth, opulent, beautiful and sustained tons Is Just what the majority of opera lingers cannot do. Mozart betrays them, It Is much easier to shout, to sing In a half parlando.

to declaim, to he what most people regard as "dramatic" than It Is to sing, and do nothing but sing. Those who attended the recent performances of "Dla Zauberfloete" could have had little difficulty In discerning the shortcomings of wveral in the cast. There are some old operas of much melodic beauty which might be made to Interest present day operngoers were, It not for their resemblance to Mozart's works In this one Item. They have to to do with them. And FO Mr.

d0'-, not t0 r- vlve them. I. unfortunate that the singer, of Metropolitan company do not know that there nre, Home real connoisseurs of singing among the subscribers. There are enough of them to make really good singing worth while. It ls well to re-member tho good words of Francisco Tosl: "One who Blngs with a desire of nuln- Ing honor ar.d credit cannot sing 111, and In time will sing better: and one who thinks on nothing but gain Is In the ready way to remain Ignorant METROPOLITAN OPERA HOUSE.

"La Traviata" wilt open the Metro-polltan opera season's sixth week tomorrow night with Mmes. Hempel, Kgener and Mottfeld and Messr.s. liotta, Amato, Ananlan, Hesehlgllan, Uada and Iiegue. Mr. Polacro will conduct.

"Alda" next Wednesday evening with Mmes, Destinn, Ober and Kparkes and Messrs. Martlnelli, Amato. Didur, Rossi and Hida, Mr. TocanlnI conducting. Mas-cnefs "Manon" net Thursday evening w.ih Mis and Mines.

nuclH'Iie. HuMjii and and Messrs. Carii-u, Seoul, Rothier, De He-Roslna (iulli. Rlthaid Ilagem.iii will caniiii conducting. und (iretel" Hlitl ballet divertissements a a spetlal Christmas day matinee (at o'clock).

The opera will be sum; by Mines. Schumann, Matifeld, flairlson, Iiraslau and Robe-son and Messrs. Oorltz and Relss. The ballet divertissements will be led by Roslna (ialll, Richard llageman wlil conduct. "Tannhaeiisei" next Friday evening with Mines.

fJatNki and Matzenauer and Messrs. Frlus, Well, llrniin, Althouse, Hloch, Srliegel and I'tllaton, Mr. Hcita conducting. "Carmen" at next Saturday's matinee with -Miss Farrar ami Misses Hurl, Hras-lau and Harrison ami Messrs. Caruso, Amito, HothlT, It.ttlii, Relss mid Dt-frci-e, Toscanini conducting.

Fi Kreisier, the eminent Austrian will be a feature of to-night's "opera concert." Mine. Frances Altla and rihur Middletnn will Mug. Thn orchestra will be directed by Richard llageman. "The M.mlc Flute" will be sung on Saturday even.iig at the ItrooKljn Academy of Music by Mines Destino, Hem-pel anil Si Iiiiiuiiiiii ami Mcis, Sem. bach, (infills and Witlierspin i.

"Parsifal" will given on New Year's nrtcrnoon at the Motrnpnlltan opera House beginning at 1 o'clock. (pF -vinLWm WiHViiZ79EEH I ni ii lH' I offers II IKV. i I lus-rs ror spring luouuriioii. MIfHKiM CONCERTS, RECITALS, NOTES OF MUSIC. The People's Society, with I'raiiz X.

Arens, conductor, lll give its tlrt concert ot the piesent season this afternoon at Carnegie Hall. Mantle I'owoll. the eminent A ritan vloiiiit, will be the soloit She play first movement of the lieetlinven violin romerto and Salnt- naenss "lutrodtlt Ion ami llnniln c.inrlr. ciosa. llio orchestra immtiers will lip iiommark "Spring" overture, Tschalkow l.y ratnetlf- syniphtmy, the nlr foi string orchestra from Ilath's nli.

in aim i.igars I'oinu nntl flrrnm.t.r.r- march. Ofslp fisbrllonitsrh. the Ittitislan planl-t, "in up me soioii wiin lie svnuihonr So. clety of New Vork. Walter Umirosch, con.

tltictor. this nfternoon nt Aeolian Hull -M. Onbrilowltsch will play ItachinanlnoflV concerto No, 2, for piano with orchestra I he complote proem mme is as follnw. Symphony in minor, Salnt-Ssens, concerto for piano with orrhotra, No. Itach iimninotT "llierla." Dehussv 'lli oml series of ehcht afternoon con-certs cieu by rhn Symphony Soeletv ni New ork.

Wither l)amrnch. cnntltictor in nan, win beitin .1 and roniinue on the following tlates January III. at io An unusually attractive list of soloists will be presented during this herles of concerts. ii. iiiuon rni7.

ureisier, llofmatin, Kerrucclo Ilusonl. Klena Orhanlt, Uonard Ilorwlck, Kmllto dx (ioorra. Uenrirn lijir. rere, Igiuska and Arkady llourstin. The next concert of the Society In New York will ho the first of two concerts ror young people to be.

given tit Aeolian Hall. It will take place on Saturilav afternoon, when Kltlv Chp.nl.nm will apiiear in descriptive songs ami reci tations, in inn meantime the orchestra will be occupied with rehearsals, ns the concerts which were to have en given In Canada during the coming week having been cancelled on account of the war. I Harold Bauer will be tho assisting artist at the second concert of tho Kneisel (Juartet. which will be given at Aeolian Hall on Tuesday evening Ho will play the llrahms Sonata for pianoforte anil violoncello In V. minor, op, as, with Mr.

Willeko mid nsMst the mombers of the quartet and I.udwlg -Manoly, double base, In the Schubert Torel-len" quintet. Tim opening number on the programme will be the Dvorak quartet In minor, op. .14. Hans will he In his accustomed place of second violin, ns he has recently returned to this country after receiving releitke from military duty In tier-many. At the HrooUlyn Academy of MuMc on Tuesday evening Handel's "Messiah" will be given under the ntispiees of the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences.

The eoncert will be given by the llrooUin Oratorio Society, Carl Ci. Schmidt, president, and Waller Henry Hall, conductor, with a chorus of more than 5.Vi voices, large orchestras, organ and vocal u.uartt. 'I he koloisls will be Agnes Alnop Wartl, soprano. Ida (iartlner, contralto. Dan lleddoe, tenor, and Hubert Maltlaud, barytone.

'I lie iccaslon will ijerve to celebrate the twenty-fifth anniversary of the founding of the Brooklyn Oratorio Society, which had its beginning with Mr. Hull and lias Wen under his leadership continuously for a qua r-ter of a century. Tho society Is now under he general supervision of Columbia I'nl-verslty through the fact thut Hull holds the chair. as director of choral musio at the unlverfltj' Heretofore concert have been given each season III New lork and In the coming concert the unlvcrsiu will cooperate with the Institute In giving lirooklvn music lovers an opportunit" to support by tln-ir attendance tlii distinctly Brooklyn organ-lation Kitty CI1e.1tl1.ini, who han 111,1 di' the koitgs of childhood a classic delight to this generation, announces her thirtieth reclt.il In New York at the Lyceum 'iheatie on Mnndui arternoou. December Is In her programme Miss Cheatham reveals mut hlth-erto unlieiiid inateiial of great interest.

Ten now manuscript songs by Ameii. an composers (Mrs. H. II Heath, Hiiro'tl Vincent Milligau, Ddward I Loins tioti. schalkl, in aililitlnu to negio folk songs and liistorical nursery rhymes, show Miss Cheatham's at tlve.lnteiest In what her own i 01111-try is producing.

Knglanil is repretentt-d by I'redcricli Not ton and W. (Irahani liob-ertson An old i'lench Christmas carol is followed by a gtoup of chiltlren's songs from tiernuiiiy. tLric Wolffs posthumous Marcheir)and'iiianns rlpt songs bv Boheri Ivalin anil Alfred Srentlrel. Tolstoy nntl gskv lepreseut Sibelius, linlinil. Haloid Bauer's List three New oil.

te tun's, two tills season and one lasl spring, chanced to be given 011 the hhiiic date lot ihe Boston Symphony Onltslra, a fad lh.it cants! rartn, pixicct from ntn a few of the hitter's subscribers. Mr Bauer's pel rt ciliil, however, will not lie in. a Symphony duy, llio date chosen being Sunday afternoon, December Mr. Bauer has selected a programme of popular piano classics, 'including aiming other num. Iieis the Hu I hromalic I'linliisia and I'llglie, the Heethoveii Sonata, ihe Schumann eariieval and the Wagner "Bide of Hut Vnlkyiles Call I'lesch, violinisi, will give a lecilal at Carnegie, Hull on the arternoou of December The second New York recital of I'riu Kreisier will he given in Carnegie Hull Wednesday afternoon, December On January 1, In the afternoon, a I Car-negln Hall, llfrem Zlmhallst will bn heard in Ids second violin recital, 'Hie Hotel Illlimore announces series of seven I'riilavmoriiiiigmuslcales in be given dining Hut present seiiMin on the following dales January 10, rebruary I'ebruary March Muich April 0.

A mil (leialdiiin 1'iiniii, l.ucii Bonn and I'ablo Casals are the snlulsls for the (lrsl musicals Ilie Mill-is riw.tied lor he mti.s .1 le Frances Udn, soprano, Frieda 1. en. pel, praco Amato, barylnne Frit? Kreler. vlolinisi I.ticrezia Bori, sotirano John ormaek, tenor l.nimy Destinn, soprano Itlccartlo tenor l.osin Ctfllti. flaneer Allen Sli.ldi.n ltll lolph dan, pianist; Luclle Orrell.

cellist; l.eopoltl tiodovvsky, pianist; itappold, soprano, William llinshaw, barytone; Andreas da Segurola, barytone, anil I.ouls Slegel. violinist. On Jan 1: Marcella Semlire Ii will give a song recital nt Carnegie Hall This will he the rt appearance here in two seasons of the famous soprano. On Tuesday evening, December the Kneisel Ouarter will give the -cotiil concert of its subscription siies at Aeolian Hall. The sslng artist, will Harold Bauer antl I.udwlg who will take pan In tho Schtilwrt Torellen" ipiiiitei.

In addition Bauer and Mr Willeko will Play the llrahms sonata In minor, op. s. for piano and violoncello, and Hi letnain-Ing number on the piogramnie will l.e the Dvorak tpiartet in I) minor, op Kilty lie. 1 ham's annual Christinas recital will in place, a usual, on Moml.iv afternoon, I'e. ejnir nt 'I heat re.

Harold Bauer 1. 10 give a third recital in Aeolian Hull mi Sunday afierno.iti. De Klena (itrli.itdt will give her tlmi rei 11.il this season on January to at Carnegie Hall Osslp (laliriloMltseh will give a piano re. rital in Hull on Monditv Januar.v 4 Jo-ef l.tiev nine, ilnj will give an eoliaii Hall re. on sinui.i.n afleruoiiii, 11 Prominent nuioui; tl-e cnmuiL- events is tli concert lo be iven on I 4 In aniecie Hall In the aid MacHowell As'oi i.itlon of the boxe i have been subscribed for.

and evei musical I orgtiiiiAituiii in anil mound the titv lia- MTittl blinks oi seats 'Ihe Philadelphia Synu hoit' orchestra will make its onl-New Yon. ii'ipea hi licit at this rnucert, anil Will lillve lis ls.SI(. noloist Mm- IIIk.I SiuiKiti.fl', H.e ditiiu'iiislicd pianist. MUSIC 'JTiiOHERS AND PUPILS. iti uur.s g.n lirst ev i ntusirult tiielr aitr.i.

tr stinllus a. I'l West Hlghiv -tlftti sluet on Satllldi lest. About fifty guests ive. si.itcil ir a room opening out upon a Hiac.nus ii.i 1, vvllelo llltlhts n.i.d It.iUci:. sopiano, into h.iiytoi.i.

and 1 m.nue David, s. -piano, by Marlon David at the gave ihe follmvlllg pr Sriunnie "Tuf i Din Pu. nil Mis im iMoDdl unit Mr Hait i "Fi IUe l.utiobluuii)'' Si Inini in i "Do Jfn' "Irh IP Ili-e linv P.IIII.H li u.li li.s,iiiii Mr. tifu lliieliilng. 1 111 111 1 Mi "Coins tu tli Hinleit, l.nve, I ho tree "IVriH i ts Mr.

Hi. mi strrt. PII14 Salter A'dill M'v Itnin H.vvll at th Smuts uf th liritmt isles la "Niinplis und Slieidii.t iIh "There was Ilonii aim list utile Pill. 'ell llinv .4 ii ir ana vtrea IM'U Tlie Nxl Mirlct Di" MIks llsrinutile "Tn I lie Sea" ile pine' lsier Mel nly luvu. tteliusH "Pre u.le Harhiiunlnolf li.ivi.l Songi of ilia Orient pi costume "t.a BHse" i'HSrr Trlnlknwkv l.e Ml tain ll.iriiionl David.

Mln David st Hie plnno. The flr.it evening cnueert of the snvcn'h seahoii was given by the Mfe (ilee Club, W.lhur A. I.tiyster. dlieclor, nt Assenihl.v Hall, I Madison avenue, on Tuesday evening, usslslul bv Mme hunt, soprano, tieiiiiidc Ina ltolunnia, haipist, Isollnn Halve), and Joint I'lislilng nl Hie piano, Indole large and appreciative auillenrc, The club, which has been under the leadership of Mr l.uste a initiitie. ea scored by lis V.m, I sr ness.

blending ami shading, ami p.iitlcii-iarly the enunciation the render tig of tlw Ode to Miu.h. ft. Waring Sttti Ins, l.tillabv." Spioss "Kerrv Dance." Molhn "1 uv liuliii, "Sludgy Sltuo," Ambrose. "The Iitup It-the Vot." Simple Siiron," Cliristin is llvniti, "Hark the Herald Angels Sing. ai i'angeil Pv J.

I.ei'iii.in. The mUmIs as well at- the Vo iluh were lee veo The next cuiuert will b. given in ui Joepa Hie celebrated ePtt, h.t tit id favorable intpr. sstoti In Boston a sulolpt with the llostott Svin-phony (irchmtn He will teacn .11 ttis M.UIiln School to-day at A. The conceit al tlie Malkiu S.

linos, which consisted nf Maui ice Kaufman, violinist, und Mine. Tr.tubin.111 s.mring In a Joint ris-ltal, attracted a large audi-1 nee. Kntifman prove.1 once more to he an artist of rare dualities and was obliged to plav a number of encores, to the delight of tho audience. Mme, Tiauh-man sang with her usual mastery and musicianhlp. Mine Itu, kliotit at a concert or the Hanks illee itt Carnegie 11 .11 I Delllllhel4 11, a KIOUP Of MlUgx iy I to her, tltr ana "Dlcli tlieiue lla.le fiom I Himhaiisi and an ohbgaio wit'i ill.

club. "The Diovvry mil gave as encores other hongs written for h. r. Those who assembled Tuesday if'er-noon of l.ttwsel at tho Helene Malgllle American School Del Canto, 131 West Highty-seco' street, to listen to the singing of lir t.t Sloe Itle of Wilmington, IM weio tieligMcd wlili 'he rare lenity of the ting s.ngtr's and her vocal ai is expressed in the "Walt Sing VIIM t.ll VI KREISLER I. Il.s.

Stelnwa) nun I c. Wed. XH lire. at Illttrtlon MAUD POWELL niolm Tschnlltnu miOw-tm. I 'S I Nl PIIIINV I II.NI'I Ills piitli.liilUf Co iiiv nt .11.., nrnculo Hall nt tnu mllei IA 11 IIH I III lniidin, Ilee, nt kitty RHFATUAM wr- il in Silts now nn mm lyt'iiini I'lien, lint lutnv iN II l.l Niinilm Af Ilee, 37, I I'lsnn Iteeltul TT fc 1,1 IIAIIIII.II -Ei jOl.

XJ jEj 3tL P.ni;riitii niiiuli. I i.uio i Must l.iniii.iiil li'irloui oiiA ll.tn in Plnno, VII Ml Al, INNI'ltlTTION. "A Scfuol ot Slmlm Which 8.U Ihi Mindiril in Vocil Art." THE UNaUALlriED SUCCESS OF rm: iii'i. MAIGILLE American School of Bel Canto Srltntt of Vooil Aril W. 82d New York Trull Pill; al 1 nr l.y a ruplls fin villi at ani time.

LL LESSONS QIVIM PISSONAILY BY MME. MAKIIUE. riem "II. mo nnJ Juliet" and Minus liv scvul Am-ficin tutiiposers. cumpiiiilmciitH jvc: i- uoll pluyn.l l.y 1,1 titer Xulltr it newcomer tti New Yuri.

i. I.I..1. Ml. 10 M'ir. cm lld'cice Is that "possessed by Dorothy Muyn.iril, ".1 tint iiiittio lyric s'ipriiti who mis received liuinlicr of ll.tt-rruiK offers flottt tn linger fur winter ntnl pnnliirtloii.

Put Mnyii.tril however, to Blve till' e.ir lo the umllvltlitl development iff her volte At .1 (once-! given lat Siiint.i.v lit I'ubllt S. lio. i In Jersey City, iiiytrs scveial mprai.o solos weio iradi ted with brilliant effect. Mrs. Klt'lltyif pupil of Jessie li.

renner, wl h.ts a studio In the Metropolitan Opt, 1. 1 House. The tlrst of a juries of Informal musical afteiiio.ps w.ts given last Siiadty In Miss Fenner's studio. Mine. Allgette Fine' spoke on "C'ourace and Determlna-tjoli Ncees.iry to a Career." Her till, was tolloned by mi informal prog a ii ne c.f fcuigs by of Miss Ft liner's pupils, who fur several jears has oc, upled Carnegie Hal! studio.

101.1, hits removed to on the it'tth tl.op of that building, lie wMI give ii first pupils' recltnl of the t-n-sin on Wednesday even.ng. Those to l.e heard at this recital, which is tnc CIS" of a ries, are th" M.sses (itJ.li.irdt, Rlgg.ns, Stun a t. Sourt, Herts. Jilnger und IAer-It a Home, Demaicst and i netc musicnies ai semi-private and are given monthly to accustom pupils to appear before an nil-dlenfe. A special feature of Mr.

Miller's orn i his critic i l.tss on Wednesday aft.iiiins. which Is free l'uplls are cr'ticlsed voice prtxluoilon. lctli.n. tIo and po s. The t-s.

ltvul piitntauip.1 Wntn.iiiJ Cult of Wt'Stfield lecently with a veiy attra- tive progi amine and were mot gracioul) received. Thee young wo'nen -1 1 hav set fo" the mse.ves a 1 tt.f work Is finished PARADOX OF THE RENT. ht.it a lot nb YY New York about liig' i tor and Low de helpless pisiple nre -qu. tl 'eir landlords not poor iv are helpless, but that gr-ai m.ddle ca-s who can look nut for trpy wan; to." remarked a N. vv .1 colilimiter.

"but I to i' 's irpinl; t.nk and the people vy.ci.d r.i HI e.i'tee..d chill llol I I.sl to belief my (ma tir ago la-t Sepienibej. i ap.ii" ineti: near ishlng a llrst class neiyuborh iod "caTra.irrr'rjiTnTjrn'KirirjriT ttTiu .7 t- IT 7- mm 1XSTRUMEXTAL I A 3 1 (nilulUt fu oltc plnrliiK 1 tliilfi-i-. mi,) ftuilnii nliu i fn. fre rri ar uti-'iit thro. teiidi' fi.mllt ity to a II iiaiiiM.vi i "iiiil ii no iuni.tn di.

ie l'niif. 1 f.ll llTf. L' I -If r. tMiin 'h nt: 1 hits futlnl lo iriirh," -r tit. Hti.t Tt I.

Ml filial RICKEY'S ORCHESTRA I UV.NI S. Kl.t, tllleilnr TRENTON, NEW JERSEY 71 LAMBERTON ST. Hell riuilie A I sil lllltll III II I sit Mill VIIIIII1IS I'VIII. Ill Nriir M.VV MIIIIC IM Muff nf 'I millers pu vi.uin. sls I nil ilm DiiPiiis M.l 'I.

Men' 'IT i id VIAI.III.I I I fllN IH.tJI NORMAN "WINTER Metropolitan Opcrii icusc Mill I. i i vi i mni it i i rtiiiinti. 1 ir I vn INl I Nll I I HI- ii Mini I'Lueti i ii.llnlS 'lit l.t4llr,uil' Itlr.l rr.itla PAUL TIETJENS Conipoii-r, Ti.uli. Jlh St. PUnlit Mini; i 01.1,1:1.1: or mi sic, 4.S 110 MMi BUCKHOUT XtVX B0GERT Trnrhrr nf 0.

IVniirr. of Slnclni: Mt-rupollt-tn Op ll'sc N. ptintir Ji'71 llrysnt VW MHt, VOCAI, HI I'tHl) VV I H1MIII, I I'll ST this iuiiki iimv HAYt. Illli KAIKs o.n INK M.VV MIIIK si I "mm It 1 mnnl IJxipi'ciwie I lur or three ,11 Itelnleil my if if" II Deem your. "A I cr WO or ll rOC Inotlt my pl'tlis wctc nil 1 compelled to tnKi1 my ruin.

a city, but I had the lease ami I for It. I vvmn't bothere bet i Ing what trouble 1 had id iod thing, 1 'ihoiight 1 co i a taker. Hut I was in tried to release at the hut It would not month of effort I put the $tI0 month, 25 per tent. In anything else In the n.ig.i'. nobody seemed to want a i.

apartments and It was i. i No npartmeht In the buiM i lees thnn JSO. nntl some mine would not go nt a Klevntor service anil all uit "This month I have I in. and I ntn free oncp more, i. explain wliv I couldn't tin.

I a the discount nntl the i class cr.v,iig aloud foi th high ills'." Ivi can ii MPTRflPni.lTaN Hill S. fjl! SI MV I'llMI'IlT TONIGHT FRITZ KREISLER 'I Mil I "-Till Mill VMM Mil. Vlllllll I I ON KN'Ttlll. It CHIC II in V. Vlnn.

nt I I nil I lia, PnMn, Amain, llttil i tend pi i Ui-tl, ni Vhls. It Ii t' Am.ito. I Tns I liiir. MS I i I ItHlie r. Necicnt i on Xliiasll.n Vlvtlnrc it! te I'rlirs 5 llaen-rl ii (Irnrl.

s. 'i Ipl-s. I'or'i 1 1 ll I llt-t lilierllsscinrnts, I'rl. nt lattnltaettsrr 4) I ill. I' II nun ill" sst.

I run-it. tic an, lltllllln UkIh te .1 IIAItUMAN PI I III till- tttl TVIIIttt: IIAI I IIIIIIVI lln'fl ir.nrr 41 st i it nf -i itln.f- it I in urn I' il v-. Si il fi a I. lit I'Jth I't'li i M.i rili Ii i'Mli Vpnlluh Vprll U.Cr.l lhe ssftlfklt fur the rirsi np GERAIDINE FARRAR LUCA BOTTA PABLO CASALS a t-nrsctil i ji the a III.M I'l l. inn III.

IN.N lltllll IM I'I'IM II III M.I.I IIIIIA llltltl I I l.lll I tl nl Kill. 1SI. Ill Ulllll Mrt tlllVIAt mm; 1 in I.OIillVVSK IIINSIIVlV Cither eri.it srps-n I Xr, llt'llr fr.r scfl a. ml I II. vt 3 II sfl I si II vv.v ami tli ki-i t.

I Jill tt mint jnuinsi SYMPHONY Sum nf 1 1W I I It II VMItllM II Ills M'l I.II.NOIIN ill 1 Gabrilowiisch MA'S HAl iLVlAMNtll SCfli 11' Mux OOlff l.tll IVN till rm vi iii in iivi i Kit Vint 4 lint ITI Ill; II. 1 I-. Ii VESSEL (JUAHTET i Humid ll.iuir llvnrsk. rtr l.i 1 I' (tie f. Pert.

tc 1 ror I 1 I. Ml. 1 VI Mi CarnesieHall. hat. Aft.t Jan.

1st at 2:30 ZIMBALIST at mix oi i i i Man urine tit t. I Cartte'le Hull, lues. VI. JULIA Ml. I I i PI inn Mk S'i' I III Nit I 1', I Friday Mornine'Musicales iv.

DI RECTORY OF NEW YORK'S LE D1G OCAl KV 1 1 INST1TUTK OF Mt.SU Ihe II. nf .1 1 1 An KnJoued Sthocl liontD" students Mit.t uni it ii put cm 1 i i 1 1 1 1 1 rnlicnMve p.iis.cii slims I Kiiilimeil aim ie i tn, in lei nf viniild pi. ii "seiri t.ll I II I l.irruinlll Vi 1 Ross David Music S-Jscs VI III It III Hiss VI VIII. VI, II, ItlHV VHI SDN NI) Mlis, IIHU I VOICC PRODUCTION SlnKlne In All Its Urnnchra 49 WKST 85 11 1 STK! Ii n-phone Ml'-. 1 lie.

I'll. l.i HI NP sp I. I iii.isiudiis. left nit i' i WILBUR I IIVSTCQsiBhi A. LJiuii.ii.! tn i i BCvir.tii I'ottatrvatori MAlllll I l.t CI 'III.

1 I Mill. Jli, 'ill. t'Mrnl, IlIT a. iu a. 1 iiui- I.

IL leuc Josephine Mildtnberj Mill. I VV oler It'll I'lH sIIN VII) I I It I em Iter nf sincmc iiriii'iiie 1111 hvrritii.ws. si niiws sr.w toinv cirv. 1 1.