Globe-Gazette from Mason City, Iowa on October 1, 1949 · Page 9
Get access to this page with a Free Trial

A Publisher Extra Newspaper

Globe-Gazette from Mason City, Iowa · Page 9

Mason City, Iowa
Issue Date:
Saturday, October 1, 1949
Page 9
Start Free Trial

Medicine-Education Analogy Fallacious, Says Economist of Chicasro—Proponents of socialized medicine who point to the role of government in education in support of their stand are drawmg an unwarranted analogy according to Frank G. Dickinson! Ph. D., director of the American Medical association bureau medical economic research. Dr. Dickinson, who taught eco- ^npmics at the University of Illinois for a quarter century, said medical care in its entirety is so fundamentally different from education that there appears little or no basis for comparison. "To point out any superficial likeness is to overlook the basic function of medicine, to disregard the real role of the physician, to lose sight of the very end to be desired—better medical care for the American people," he said. "The fundamental difference between teaching and practicing .medicine arises out of the fact that the teacher is concerned with a large, fairly standardized group of persons in a class or grade while the doctor must of necessity be concerned with the individual. "The public school teacher presents subject matter which is standardized to a degree to a large class composed of children or young people of somewhat similar k intellectual development who presumably enjoy normal health. Her primary purpose is to teach her students to do things for themselves. Education lends itself to group organization. "The physician's interest must lie in the individual patient. The physician cannot administer the same treatment to a large groiip cf persons—25 boys and girls,in ' one class or grade. He must diag r nose each case separately and select the proper treatment for each patient. From infancy to old age the medical needs of an individual undergo continual change and the doctor must be able to administer medical treatment to people of all age groups. He is concerned with the differences, not the similarities in persons. "The physician, if he is to perform his work at all let alone maintain a high quality of medical care, cannot offer a standardized product. His services are not adaptable to government regulation and organization, to fixed rules and basic standards — the necessary concomitants of any national compulsory scheme. In fact, the physician would be rendered powerless to fulfill his primary obligation to his patient if condemned to such uniformity." Dr. Dickinson said the government can function efficiently in public health services involving problems of sanitation, the water- supply, food handling in public eating places, communicable diseases and similar matters which concern large groups of persons. Keep Moth Balls Away From Children Chicago — Sucking moth balls can cause severe poisoning in children, warn 2 Detroit doctors. Four cases in which 2-year-old youngsters were made acutely ill by eating moth balls of naphthalene are reported in the current Journal of the American Medical association by Drs. Wolf W. Zuel- zer and Leonard Apt of Wayne university college of medicine. The substance caused an anemic condition, they explain. All 4 children recovered completely after receiving blood transfusions and other treatment. * Now I Hear Like \ t A Girl of 20... Thanks to Be]tone's New "IHVKIBU ELECTRONIC UK" Imagine yourself hearing clearly again —even when people whisper! Imagine being able to catch every word— effortlessly, without straining —as though you had never been deaf! Now—thanks to Beltone's new "Invisible Electronic Ear"—thousands are re-capturing hearing power in a way they never dreamed of. A way that tides deafness from others—yet brings amazing new intensity and clarity of sound, even in "difficult" cases, find out about this new electronic "Miracle of Hearing" today. Come in, phone, or mail the Free-Book Coupon now. At Last! NO BUTTON IN THE EAR! Moil for Valuable FREE BOOK MONO-PAC ONE-UNIT HEARING AID BELTONE, Inc. Dept. M 517 R. U. Bide., Des Moines, Iowa l-iease send me (in plain wrapper—without cost or obligation) your FREE-BOOK on Deafness and the new "INVISIBLE ELECTRONIC EAR." Name Address , Town & State (Batteries for all makes of Hearing Aids) BELTONE HEARING SERVICE, inc. 517 R. TJ. BLDG. PHONE 2-3724 DES MOINES, IOWA AMERICA'S GRASS ROOTS "LOBBY" f*: &fe! C^l- 1 " mft &•*• I ** JE , £L NAT. ASSN. SMALL BUSINESSMEN AMERICAN LEGION Tr^ ZL]\ i\ -j i ^jr«^ ON RECORD. 1 AMERICAS GREATEST PUBUC ORGANIZATIONS ARE STANDING UP TO BE COUNTED AGAINST COMPULSORY H£AITH INSURANCE.' Better Understanding Between Press and Medical Profession DCS Moiiies, (IP) —Greater understanding between the medical profession and the press and radio was advocated at the Iowa State Medical society's first med^al-press-radio conference. A panel discussion on "mutual interests of the press,, radio and the practice of medicine" comprised the morning session. Dr. Nathaniel G. Alcock of Iowa City, president of the state medical society, said he believed the press and radio were fair and just and that in common with tie medical profession they had an understanding of the problems of human relationships. Dr. Fred Sternagel of West Des Moines, chairman of the ISMS committee on public relations, told medical men present that one of their primary jobs "is to get out and do footwork against proposals of socialized,, medicine." He invited the press and radio to speak frankly on their relationships with the medical profession. Gulf in Past Kenneth MacDonald, executive editor of the Des Moines Register and Tribune, asserted that in the past there had been a gulf between medical men, as men of science, and the press as an agency in the world of laymen. This gulf has narrowed in recent years, MacDonald said, and today the need for common understanding is greater than ever. "The development of nuclear fission has made it necessary for the layman to understand science in order that our democratic society may \visely exercise popular controls in this field," he said. MacDonald asserted that basically all that press and radio ask of the medical profession "is that you be willing to talk with our reporters when they seek information which is in the public interest." He urged increased co-operation from doctors and hospitals in providing information on legitimate news stories and on picture arrangements. Can Be Solved F. C. Grawe, editor of the Waverly Democrat and Bremer County Independent, said there arc no problems which cannot be solved by the willingness of medical mei and the press to talk together. Edward Breen, manager of Sta tion KVFD-KFMY at Fort Dodge said he was convinced there wa widespread support for the med ical profession's stand against so cialized medicine. He criticizec the government "for leavin (Schick) hospital at Clinton prac tically vacant because somebod> in Washington wanted to builc hospitals somewhere else." Breen said the prime problem of th medical profession is to provide more doctors. Dr. Donald C. Conzett of Dubuque, program chairman, said the medical profession would work toward greater co-operation with press and radio. Dr. Wayland K. Hicks of Sioux City, chairman of the ISMS co-ordinating educational committee, presided. Diabetes Week Here Oct. 70 to 76 The Cerro Gordo Medical So- iety and the Public Health Nurs- ng seryice will jointly sponsor a ree urine test for sugar as part if the observance of diabetes de- ection week, Oct. 10 to 16, it was nnounced Wednesday. The program here is a part of a national observance sponsored by :he American^Diabetes association and given approval by the American Medical association with state and county medical societies join- ng in support of the project. This is the 2nd such week sponsored by the association and the first one that has been placed on i a national basis. ' In Cerro Gordo county the county 'medical society will provide the materials and the tests will be made by the Public Health Nursing association, in charge of its director, Beulah Wiedman. Girl's Death Inspires Snake Serum Bank Mosquero, N. Mex., (U.R)—Last summer a 6-year-old girl died of a rattlesnake bite in remote Harding county. There was no rattlesnake serum at hand to treat the little girl. Three veterans organizations in Mosquero, the county seat, have taken steps to see that such a tragedy doesn't happen again. The Veterans of Foreign Wars, American Legion and Legion Auxiliary set up a snake serum bank at Mosquero. Sept. 30, 1949 7-C Cily dlobe-G»ieU«, Mu*n CMyr lb Girl Cuts 3rd Set of Teeth at Age 9 Salt Lake City, (U.R)—Dentists are marvelling over the case of 9-year-old Penny Lee Nielsen. The daughter of Mr. and Mrs. James R. Nielsen cut her 3rd set of molars this spring. Salt Lake City dentists have looked into her tiny mouth with awe for some time. Penny had her complete set of 24 baby teeth before she was one. She had her 2nd set of teeth at the age of 4. Penny says that the business of cashing in on her old teeth by tucking them under a pillow has given her more spending money than any other girl in the block. TODAY'S HOSPITAL The modern hospital enables one doctor to care for several times as many patients as if ht had to visit their homes individually. Proper Ventilation and Air-Conditioning ARE ESSENTIAL FOR GOOD HEALTH As our contribution to good health to the people of Mason City and vicinity we offer Heating and Air Conditioning Sys- tems which not only Heat and Cool your home but also Cir- culate, Humidify or Dehumidify and clean the air either by filters or electrostatic cleaners. We also offer Sterilizing Lamps Tri-Ethelene Giyoul distributors which will kill air-borne germs and destroy odors. RAY PAULEY CO., Inc. SHEET METAL CONTRACTORS 421-25 South Federal Phone 963 Bar Association Opposed to Medical Plan The American Bar association examined the Wagner bill No. 1161 in 1944 and reported unfavorable on that measure for federal regulation of medicine. Noted the bar association: "Under the medical care now provided in the United States' the highest level of health and the lowest death rate ever known under similar conditions are being maintained. "There are being developed in this country and under our system of free enterprise many plans for providing adequate medical care without paying the price for socialized medicine. These include group and hospital insurance and Blue Cross plans under principles approved 'by the medical profession. The Indigent Excepted "Of all the plans now in effect in foreign countries, none is comparable with the plan proposed by S. 1161 except the Russian system, which involves the complete socialization and regimentation of medicine. Such a pattern, if followed in this country, will inevitably produce a like result. The physician will become merely an unambitious federal employe or a politically ambitious doctor. "Contrary to assertions of the advocates of the measure, the plan covers practically the entire population of the United States except the indigent. "Within the past 20 years the center, of medical progress has moved from Germany, Austria and England, which have adopted some form of state medicine and which previously served as centers of post-graduate medical education, to the United States and we now find physicians and hospital administrators coming for guidance and inspiration to this country, where no form oC state medicine is in effect. No Appeal to Courts The bar association charged that the bill failed to safeguard the rights of patients, citizens, hos- I pitals or doctors with respect to disputes arising or rights denied | through the arbitrary or capricious action of one man. "The bill fails to provide for any appeal to any courtroom the action of the surgeon general." Laboratory on Wheels to Fight Epidemic Seattle, (U.R)—The University of Washington is .completing work on a mobile epidemic stopper. It is a portable, completely outfitted medical laboratory- The laboratory, built in a surplus army ambulance, can travel to any part of the state within a few hours in emergencies. It will be used to bring the latest equipment to local medical centers for special investigations thai used to take weeks but can i now be done, in hours. Exciting new glamor ...with Yes, you look more exciting wifh Life above and below. Because only Life Bra and Life Girdle are so cleverly tailored to fit and work together for enticing curve control with healthful freedom. Let our fitters prove this, instantly. LIFE BRAS, $1.25 TO $3.50 LIFE GIRDLES, $7.50 AND UP m combed cotton HEfUTH-TEX Sensation of the younger set in 2-ply combed cotton Icn'rt — smooth-textured and so wonderfully washable! Gripper snap fastener opening a* shoulder for dressing ease, in baby-toft solid colors and novelty stripes. Sizes I, 2, 3 Merkels-Aldens The KEY to GOOD HEALTH is SANITATION Maytag Automatic Washer HAMILTON AUTOMATIC CLOTHES DRYER SAVES HOURS —GUARDS HEALTH! SUN-E-DAY Ultra-Violet Ray Lamp. Kills airborne bacteria and gives your clothes "Synthetic Sunshine" as they are gently fluff-dried! Released ozone gives "Sunshine and Breeze" freshness. * Clothes Ready for Ironing in 15 to 25 Minutes. Your Choice of Two Models—Gas or Electric. COME IN FOR DEMONSTRATION Other than the Maytag Washer being fully automatic you will be more than pleased with these outstanding features: Completely clean washing, thorough spin-drying, scientific balance, economy through the years, safety lid, safe top loading, sealed-ln-oil power unit, famous Maytag guarantee. See this wonderful new machine at our store. HOME APPLIANCE COMPANY 201 South Federal Phone 162 • Authorized Maytag-Kelvinator Sales and Service

What members have found on this page

Get access to

  • The largest online newspaper archive
  • 11,200+ newspapers from the 1700s–2000s
  • Millions of additional pages added every month

Publisher Extra Newspapers

  • Exclusive licensed content from premium publishers like the Globe-Gazette
  • Archives through last month
  • Continually updated

Try it free