Carrol Daily Times Herald from Carroll, Iowa on March 10, 1976 · Page 5
Get access to this page with a Free Trial

Carrol Daily Times Herald from Carroll, Iowa · Page 5

Carroll, Iowa
Issue Date:
Wednesday, March 10, 1976
Page 5
Start Free Trial

Historic Iowa Court Case Upheld Freedom of Ex-Slave By Vincent Butler (Drake University Journalism Student) DESMOINES-When the Iowa territorial Supreme Court first began reviewing cases in July 1839, a monumental case was quickly thrust upon it. The court decided that a slave, set free, could not be enslaved again for any reason The ruling conflicted with the Missouri Compromise of 1820, which gave slaveowners the right to go into a free state or territory to capture "fugitive" slaves. It also came at a time when the Iowa territorial legislature had enacted many laws trying to restrict the number of blacks in its domain. The case is in the Iowa Reports, a bobk that reviews many territorial Supreme Court cases, as being "In the matter of Ralph '(A colored man) on Habeas Corpus." The controversy started in 1834 when a man named Montgomery, who resided in Missouri, and his slave Ralph came to a contractual agreement. Ralph was to pay $550 in exchange for his freedom, beginning Jan. 1, 1835. At the time, Ralph apparently was sincere in saying he would pay his debt. Dubuque then was a vast reservoir for mining lead ore, and Ralph heard reports that a fortune awaited anyone with a strong back and a willingness to work hard. .When reaching Dubuque, Ralph found it to be "a typical mining town." The townspeople were basically of Spanish, French, Irish and German heritage. According to an article in an early Palimpsest magazine, the miners in this Northeast Iowa town spent much of their leisure time getting drunk and gambling and the residents were a rugged sort, always, looking for a fight. After a period of five years, Ralph was unable to earn enough money to pay off his debt. Two miners from Virginia heard about Ralph's problem and saw an excellent opportunity to make some Tlm«t H«rald, Carrall, la. _ Wednesday, March 10, 1976 3 •"* • »••<•.......«.„...„ quick cash. The Virginians sent a letter to Montgomery telling him of Ralph's whereabouts. Montgomery, who had given up the idea of getting his money from the ex-slave, jumped at the opportunity to get back Ralph. He offered $100 to the miners for Ralph's return. The Virginians found Ralph working in a mine west of Dubuque. They jumped the black man, handcuffed him and dragged him away from the mines. Fortunately for Ralph, Alexander Butterworth, farming nearby, observed the incident. Butterworth contacted Thomas Wilson, an associate justice of the Iowa territorial Supreme Court, who lived in Dubuque. Wilson ordered Dubuque sheriff George Cummings to track down the kidnapers. The miners wer? apprehended near Bellevue and taken back to Dubuque. When Wilson heard the .details of the incident, he decided that the case would be too important for a district , court. The Iowa territorial Supreme Court consisted of three members — Chief Justice Charles Mason, associate justices Joseph Williams and Wilson. Mason graduated from West Point with the likes of Robert E. Lee and Jefferson Davis. After graduating from law school in New York, Mason became editor of the New York Evening Post. He soon went back into law becoming the district attorney in Burlington. Mason was appointed chief justice by President Martin Van Buren in 1838. One of the better lawyers in the state, David Rorer, was hired as Ralph's attorney while John V. Berry of Dubuque was Montgomery^ lawyer. Rorer contended that Montgomery, having signed an agreement giving Ralph freedom, had forfeited his right ever to own the slave again. Rorer added that Ralph's only obligation to his ex-master was the payment of the debt. Berry argued that Ralph had not kept his part of the contract so the black man was nothing more than a fugitive slave. After listening to both arguments, Mason gave the court's opinion: "When a slave with his master's consent becomes a resident of a free state or territory he could not be regarded thereafter as a fugitive slave, nor could the master under such circumstances exercise any rights of ownership over him." The court justices believed that slavery would virtually exist in Iowa if Ralph was forced back into slavery. This case was very similar to the U.S. Supreme Court's decision on Dred Scott in 1857, except for the outcome. Scott had lived in a shack near Davenport to hold the land for his master. After living in a free state for nearly four years, Scott considered himself a free man. Chief Justice Roger Taney, in his court opinion, said that no black man could be considered a citizen of the United States in a constitutional sense. Ralph's case was never mentioned in the Scott , decision. Ralph returned to Dubuque after the trial and started mining again. His tedious labor finally paid off and the fortune he had heard so much about became a reality. Instead of paying off his debt to Montgomery, Ralph gambled it away. He never recovered from his losses and died in poverty. Ralph's place of burial is unknown. Don't be ffuefish. OFflC£ OF CNEHGY CONSOVATION Of THE ffDt«Al ENE»CY OFFICE ,* ' *• ; ^ This is the big one!.. yn .id, ^__ THE SINGER SWUNG SALE $AA Are Z| G-ZAG MACHINE AND R»?Sfc. DECORATOR CABINET COMBINATION Dependability in a machine with 17 sew-easy features) Has built-in blindstitch, exclusively designed front drop-in bobbin, much more. BOTH FOR $1J|O95 H^^ J Reg. $20! THE FABULOUS FUTURA* II SEWING MACHINE WITH FLIP & SEW *2-WAY SURFACE Flip a panel for instant free-arm sewing of cuffs, pantlegs, all hard-to-reach places. Has 1-step buttonholer, much morel 100 Reg. Price 920 IN EXCLUSIVE SWING-AWAY* CABINET 'Sewing center' 2-level cabinet design. 262 There'! No Place Like SINGER Snvlng Ciniwi ini pvilclpliln? Approwd Oaliii' 518 N.Adams, 792-4926 'A Trademark of THE SINGER COMPANY We Must Move This Merchandise To Make Room For New Carpet! Wall-to Wall Broadloom * Remnants * Room Size Rugs Nylons • Acrylics • Polyesters Shags • Plush •Textures • Tweeds SAVINGS N REMNANTS Reg. SALE 8'xlO'l" Brown-gold hexagon figured. Jute back. 12 XI2 9" Green shag carpet, jure back 12'x9'l" and 2'xlO 1 ' Red-Blue rubber back kitchen carpet 12 X23 Green sculptured shag, jute back 12 Xlo'2" Gold-brown sculptured shag 3*X7'4" . Figured axminister, jute back 8'10"X8'4" Blue-White sculptured shag 5'6"x4'4"«md 2'10"X4T' Green Tweed, rubber back 12 / X2C W 9" Brown-Gold rubber back 12'xl3' Green shag, jute back 6'8 ff XlO'4" Green and white, jute back 12'x7'9" Orapge and brown "Mod" Kitchen Carpet 19'vfl'p." I * AO O Orange stripe, outdoor-indoor, r.b. grass carpet «;x5'6"«m«l 36 *X2 J 3" Green figured plush jute back 12'x8'9" • Armstrong Kitchen carpet, rubber back 12'xlO' Gold and brown, jute back 7 X9 8" Beige and off white plush, jute back 12'xl7'8" Red and black tweed, rubber back' 12'xl9 4 Flame Caravelle, jute back 12'xlO'2" Lavender shag, rubber back '24000*108°° 320.00 139°° ,108.00 89°° 440.00 199°° 335.00 165°° 3500 20°° •w - » ^ Mohawk DAWN FANTASY INSTALLED FIGURED CARPET Excellent for that extra Choice of 2 rolls JsT«- FAT TWO FOAM' TONE SHAG Choice of three rolls, two-ton* brown, red or bliM. Excellent for bedrooms Reg. $7.95 Sq. Yd. SALE , (Not I Sq. Yd. yif w» - wwy, LOW PROFILE TWEED CARPET Rubber bock. Choice -' •' Two-tone gray, gc Reg. $6.95 Sq. Yd. rolls. Ti SALE Sq. Yd. OPEN SUNDAY 1 p.m. to 5 p.m. PRENGER FURNITURE "Qualify Name Brands you know at always Low Prieas." West on Hwy. 30 — Carroll (Not Installed) %WSP OPEN WED.&FRI. Till 9 P.M.

What members have found on this page

Get access to

  • The largest online newspaper archive
  • 11,200+ newspapers from the 1700s–2000s
  • Millions of additional pages added every month

Try it free